Autopsy Round 6, 2023 : Positives and Negatives v Port Adelaide

[Biggie]

Positive



Fire away

 

[Spooky17]

Positives:

• There is genuine hope for the future with some promising performances from our young players like Culley and BBBW.
• Kelly having an AA season.
• Barrass return to form.
• Waterman stepped up this season.
• JJ is a gun.

Negatives:

• Second quarters.
• Shuey’s body isn’t up to the rigours of AFL.

 

[Shueygod]

Want some written apologies on BBW, you hacks thought Jamo was a better prospect .

Finally plays some one his own age and tears it up, having a better year than Jackson who’s the only other ruck his age playing and is apparently worth two 1sts.

Put some respect on the man’s name.

 

[CoastersFlag No.5]

Positive: Culley for Coleman.
Negatives: Flat quarter. Again.

 

[Biggie]

Want some written apologies on BBW, you hacks thought Jamo was a better prospect .

Finally plays some one his own age and tears it up, having a better year than Jackson who’s the only other ruck his age playing and is apparently worth two 1sts.

Put some respect on the man’s name.

Played well today.

Like to see him back that up next week.

 

[Byron_Clanger]

Positive - Culley and we didn't let them blow us out once it got to 40. Last year that would've been an 70/80 pointer

Negative - Shuey...give it up, mate

 

[Cuzz09]

Cant complain really.

We would've lost that by 100+ last year

On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[timeforanother22]

BBBW! He will make it, he is starting to put it together game after game just a bit better than the last.

Culley in the forward line, nice work down there with four goals and he applied much needed pressure in our 50.

Waterman good, Kelly, Gaff, JJ, SPS, Hunt all OK.

Negatives, second quarter, again. Shuey injured again. Early goal kicking, again.

At least we are consistent?

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Played well today.

Like to see him back that up next week.

He’s been showing a lot since the Cats game late last year.

For a young ruck, he deserves more credit(s).

 

[amazingjoshy]

Want some written apologies on BBW, you hacks thought Jamo was a better prospect .

Finally plays some one his own age and tears it up, having a better year than Jackson who’s the only other ruck his age playing and is apparently worth two 1sts.

Put some respect on the man’s name.

Agree with all except the potting of Jamo

Give him a chance too

Rucks take time is a pretty universal rule

 

[BBQ Mania]

Culley and Williams. No need to say any more.

Negative:

We only had 26 players to pick from for this game, now with Shuey likely out, that's down to 25. So who are the three listed players who don't get a game.

 

[Doashuey]

Great to see Culley kick 4 and that we have another mid/hybrid to add some versatility. But I didn't have him in my Top 5.
Some good performances out there today as positives. Bailey Williams has huge and played a full 4 quarters. Kelly likewise. Petchs first half was great, much more involvment. I thought Waterman played a fantastic game but he had 2 horrible.clangera in the 3 Rd quarter that the usual haters will grasp onto to reinforce their preconceived ideas but he did a mountain of work all over the ground. Barrass back in form was a delight. Finlayson kicked 5 but only one of them against Tommy and he really frustrated the s**t out of him when he went to him.

Negatives... Shuey, 2nd quarters, Gaffs delivery I50.

 

[RedWeddingGuest]

+ BBW, Culley up front, TK, return to some form of TB

– We aren’t gonna get Harley Reid. If we fix our second quarters, we could finish as high as 12th.

– – – Petch. He is *ing useless.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[BrotherDodge]

Positives

We're cracking in and playing a style of fast, attacking footy that will win a lot of games when we have the class to actually pull it off. It's far better to watch than the soulless trash we served up last year.

Jai Coleman-ey.

Williams was a beast today. Some players get complacent when there's no option to replace them, but he's just grown in confidence. I've bagged him as hard as anyone and I'm delighted to see him beclowning me.

Negatives

We get carved up on overlapping counterattacks and our backline just looks bewildered a lot of the time. Pitiful lack of synergy there.

 

[Crimson King]

BBBW with 21 disposals and a personal best of 13 clearances. Also, had the most contested possessions (16) for us. Hopefully, he can start delivering such performances consistently now.

 

[Doashuey]

Played well today.

Like to see him back that up next week.

He backed it up from last week. Was solid.
But yeah the call on Williams >>Jamo is premature given Williams has had all the opportunity this year.

 

[amazingjoshy]

+ BBW, Culley up front, TK, return to some form of TB

– We aren’t gonna get Harley Reid. If we fix our second quarters, we could finish as high as 12th.

– – – Petch. He is *ing useless.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

12th???

 

[eagle1]

Not sure some of you watch the game re Shuey... no soft tissue injury, got his ankle caught in a tackle in the 1st.. came back on and played well but obviously it got the better of him.
i would be willing to bet he was always going to be subbed as part of managing him as well.
i thought until he got subbed he was playing well.

 

[Cuzz09]

Guess if we had everyone to pick from we'd be a top 8 team.

We are having a crack, playing some kids and gonna collect a bunch more early picks in November.

Just be nice to snag a couple more wins in 2023.

I'd be happy to win 5+ games and go from pick 1-2 to pick 3-4

On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Biggie]

He backed it up from last week. Was solid.
But yeah the call on Williams >>Jamo is premature given Williams has had all the opportunity this year.

I mean back up to this extent he showed today. He had a game like this v Geelong last year. Need more like this.

 

[junebug]

Want some written apologies on BBW....Put some respect on the man’s name.

Already made mine in the game thread. He's clearly copped it because he's had to step up for NN before he was ready, and I'm very glad that he's showing some skills at last. Not just in the ruck itself but following up with second efforts, roving his own balls and so on.

 

[timeforanother22]

Not sure some of you watch the game re Shuey... no soft tissue injury, got his ankle caught in a tackle in the 1st.. came back on and played well but obviously it got the better of him.
i would be willing to bet he was always going to be subbed as part of managing him as well.
i thought until he got subbed he was playing well.

I would say he got a bit of the ball, but his disposal is not what it used to be.

 

[Shueygod]

Also the calls of this list being worse in the league are shocking.

Best 22 is comfortably top 8.

 

[KERRPOW]

Want some written apologies on BBW, you hacks thought Jamo was a better prospect .

Finally plays some one his own age and tears it up, having a better year than Jackson who’s the only other ruck his age playing and is apparently worth two 1sts.

Put some respect on the man’s name.

Youre a an odd ball.

Good game from williams today but hes playing against someone whos only played 3 games.

 

[RedWeddingGuest]

12th???

It’s a long season…


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app