Teams SC 2016 - My Team (NAB Challenge)

[Hairy Lager]

So I've done some juggling

Yeo > Dea
Polec > Gresham
Lobbe > Gawn
Thomas > Martin

Funnily enough my projected score went down by roughly 20 odd points


I'll sit and watch for now
But at $300 I'm tempted to put daisy back in, he looked as good as he has in a long time on Thirsday night

Go with your gut, just watch out how many Carlton players you put in, don't be too bias.
Projected score projects rookies at 25-40 avg. so dismiss it.

 

[Mitchell54]

Any analysis and suggestions on this team are welcome
Thoughts on the team?

 

[the cold spur]

A decent ruck (goldy, martin, gawn)

Tippet including finals
last 5 games averaged 124.8
last 8 games averaged 117.4
last 10 games averaged 110.6
This is when he started rucking as the more preferred ruckman and has said over this preseason wants to be the ruckman, if this continues into the new season an average of 110 he is just a quality as Martin and superior to Gawn. Lobbe also averaged 100 as number one ruckman in 2014 and with no Ryder could assume he would be able to repeat the efforts at roughly 160K cheaper than Gawn

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Tippet including finals
last 5 games averaged 124.8
last 8 games averaged 117.4
last 10 games averaged 110.6
This is when he started rucking as the more preferred ruckman and has said over this preseason wants to be the ruckman, if this continues into the new season an average of 110 he is just a quality as Martin and superior to Gawn. Lobbe also averaged 100 as number one ruckman in 2014 and with no Ryder could assume he would be able to repeat the efforts at roughly 160K cheaper than Gawn

Tippett a superior ruckman to Gawn.

 

[toxic]

Tippet including finals
last 5 games averaged 124.8
last 8 games averaged 117.4
last 10 games averaged 110.6
This is when he started rucking as the more preferred ruckman and has said over this preseason wants to be the ruckman, if this continues into the new season an average of 110 he is just a quality as Martin and superior to Gawn. Lobbe also averaged 100 as number one ruckman in 2014 and with no Ryder could assume he would be able to repeat the efforts at roughly 160K cheaper than Gawn

Nice thoughts

Good luck springs to mind

 

[Unique Name]

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Had to make a few adjustments. Shaw>Simpson Lobbe>Gawn
About out 55k left

 

[Keg on legs]

Had to make a few adjustments. Shaw>Simpson Lobbe>Gawn
About out 55k left

View attachment 218057

Going that deep in the midfield leaves you too short elsewhere IMO. You don't want to have no wriggle room to bring in an unexpected breakout mid.
I'd offload either Gray (who I love as a POD pick) or Shiel and buy a Barlow / Wingard type up forward.

Respect in not going any of Shaw, Fyfe, Goldy or Lids by the way.... I'm not game enough to do it, but ballsy by you!

 

[Mitchell54]

Respect in not going any of Shaw, Fyfe, Goldy or Lids by the way.... ballsy!

I don't have neither of those players too. Their too expensive for my liking. Their are some good mid-pricers available this year and some undervalued premos

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Had to make a few adjustments. Shaw>Simpson Lobbe>Gawn
About out 55k left

View attachment 218057

Wow different team but still 12 keepers over 500k.

Risky but structure wise still strong.

Don't know what to think honestly. Would be worried if I was against you in round 1 of a league.

Back yourself in and see if you're still happy with this team come round 1.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

I don't have neither of those players too. Their too expensive for my liking. Their are some good mid-pricers available this year and some undervalued premos

This is spot on but if the super premos go nuts you will bleed points to the top teams and have less rookies making you cash.
You might break on eberyone points wise early but when the teams with the locked in premos start upgrading you will start going backwards.

 

[Keg on legs]

OPERATION GOT-TO-GET-SEB

Ok, as some of you may be aware I have spruiked Seb Ross once or twice this pre season across the occasional thread (ie everywhere I've had the chance).

Ive have him in and out of my team, but he currently sits out of it. After today, I think that has to change!

My team at the moment:







Now, a few ideas spring to mind:

A) I downgrade shaw and Fyfe and upgrade a Davis to Sc Ultra Premo Edition Ross (did you notice that spells SUPER!) or

B) sidebum to Sc Ultra Premo Edition Ross and the reamining cash upgrades a rookie to mills / hopper and a forward rookie to wells / Simpkin or

C) leave the team the hell alone, any playing around will stuff it up.



I have my concerns with all three scenarios. Happy for input or any other whacky ideas guys!

Oh, and I currently have $67k to play with as my teams currently stands

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Can't see your team ..

 

[Keg on legs]

Can't see your team ..

Just fixed it I think

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

OPERATION GOT-TO-GET-SEB

Ok, as some of you may be aware I have spruiked Seb Ross once or twice this pre season across the occasional thread (ie everywhere I've had the chance).

Ive have him in and out of my team, but he currently sits out of it. After today, I think that has to change!

My team at the moment:

View attachment 218103

I ask questions.

Is Seb going to finish top 20 in the Mids?

If not why pick him?

What's your structure. Premos with midpricers or full Guns n Rookies?




View attachment 218104


Now, a few ideas spring to mind:

A) I downgrade shaw and Fyfe and upgrade a Davis to Sc Ultra Premo Edition Ross (did you notice that spells SUPER!) or

B) sidebum to Sc Ultra Premo Edition Ross and the reamining cash upgrades a rookie to mills / hopper and a forward rookie to wells / Simpkin or

C) leave the team the hell alone, any playing around will stuff it up.



I have my concerns with all three scenarios. Happy for input or any other whacky ideas guys!

Oh, and I currently have $67k to play with as my teams currently stands

I ask questions?

Is Seb going to finsh to 20 for his line?

Are you going permos and a few midpricers or pure Guns and rookies?

If you pick players based on a NAB one game do you think you will do well this year in SC?

 

[Keg on legs]

Haven't you been in the piss all day? And yet you come at me with a question that makes sense and I can't immediately answer?? And i haven't even had a beer??????

Umm, I guess it's just that I reckon he will pull a 90+ average and make some good coin. Is that a reason to bump a keeper to get him in? Probably not!


Damn you and your buzz killing!!

And I usually am able to do ok on the breakout category. I have a pretty good strike rate. But you are right - you don't get all excited off one NAB game. I've rated him for a while

As for my structure, I'm usually a pure guns and rookie kind of guy, but I see value in mid pricers in defence this year.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Haven't you been in the piss all day? And yet you come at me with a question that makes sense and I can't immediately answer?? And i haven't even had a beer??????

Umm, I guess it's just that I reckon he will pull a 90+ average and make some good coin. Is that a reason to bump a keeper to get him in? Probably not!


Damn you and your buzz killing!!

And I usually am able to do ok on the breakout category. I have a pretty good strike rate. But you are right - you don't get all excited off one NAB game. I've rated him for a while

As for my structure, I'm usually a pure guns and rookie kind of guy, but I see value in mid pricers in defence this year.

Nah I've only had a can of pirate life, 3 pale stubbies, two pints of homebrew and 5 or 6 pints of 6% ginger beer, two cigars and a coffee.
I'm of sound mind and judgement.

It's Saturday night FFS. This is me on a weekend.
If you don't like it put SEB into your team. Don't let my drunk and sleeping on the couch arse make you question yourself.

Now what was the question again?

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

PS back yourself.

 

[Kadog]

PS back yourself.

I agree.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

OPERATION GOT-TO-GET-SEB

Ok, as some of you may be aware I have spruiked Seb Ross once or twice this pre season across the occasional thread (ie everywhere I've had the chance).

Ive have him in and out of my team, but he currently sits out of it. After today, I think that has to change!

My team at the moment:

View attachment 218103


View attachment 218104


Now, a few ideas spring to mind:

A) I downgrade shaw and Fyfe and upgrade a Davis to Sc Ultra Premo Edition Ross (did you notice that spells SUPER!) or

B) sidebum to Sc Ultra Premo Edition Ross and the reamining cash upgrades a rookie to mills / hopper and a forward rookie to wells / Simpkin or

C) leave the team the hell alone, any playing around will stuff it up.



I have my concerns with all three scenarios. Happy for input or any other whacky ideas guys!

Oh, and I currently have $67k to play with as my teams currently stands

I'd take a look at your backline, you have spent about 1.9 on your 4 "keepers" I would think about downgrading one of yeo or Jasper to free up some cash. Also options other than Goldy? He's almost 700k that's more than Gaz!! Blitz, Stef, Sandi are all solid options. You may loose 15-25 points in the ruck but gain 60-80 upgrading a rookie to Ross.

Don't touch Sidebum he's a gun. If your confident in Ross then do it. Be that 1% ownership. He could be the difference one day

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Ross is a POD. Goldy not so much.
Risk reward and all that.

Pint anyone?

 

[Keg on legs]

Ross is a POD. Goldy not so much.
Risk reward and all that.

Pint anyone?

Love one! Maybe it'll make things clearer... Many a great decision has been made after a few pints...... But then I have also made some shockers too!

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Ross is a POD. Goldy not so much.
Risk reward and all that.

Pint anyone?

On my 4th, while watching some shit movie hall pass on TV

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Love one! Maybe it'll make things clearer... Many a great decision has been made after a few pints...... But then I have also made some shockers too!

I havent even looked at Ross but I don't have your St Kilda inside knowledge.
Yeo is my West Coast break out.
Problem is 25% of team have him too.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

On my 4th, while watching some shit movie hall pass on TV

Why bother watching shit. It's a waste of time.

I'm cranking my 6th Bad Religion album and posting a little too much.
SC is life.

Time to call it a night. Happy SCering everyone.