Autopsy St Kilda v Sydney Rd 18 2017

[Joffaboy]

Only we can make him look like a superstar.

I agree with your posts regarding Richo, the heat will come if we stagnate next year.

So it should. If wecare in this position in 12 months, Richo should have the pressure right on.
Still reckon this hand wringing is premature.

 

[Saint Shags]

I just told you where. I can't recall the opponent so as such I can't tell you the game. But it's this season at etihad at half time.

I don't have to do anything. If you want to go see it go watch coverage of each of the etihad games at half time

You make an accusation and then give a weak effort to back it up.
Can't remember who or when. It might have been the forwards he was talking to.
But not sure.
Speaks volumes.

 

[bennymc7]

Players who played last night who have played less than 50 games:
- Sydney = 9
- St Kilda = 6

How many blokes do Sydney have in their prime in crucial positions of the ground compared to us?

 

[Joffaboy]

You put it out there... back it up.

Yep. Back it up please. Otherwise you are making up stuff to back baseless 'issues' at the club.

 

[Saint12]

You make an accusation and then give a weak effort to back it up.
Can't remember who or when. It might have been the forwards he was talking to.
But not sure.
Speaks volumes.

Nothing to see here, move along.

 

[bennymc7]

Agree Koby is vfl pace both in leg speed and decision
Making to many of the same in our midfield change necessary.

Reckon he is a deaset list clogger... his no.1 attribute is aggro, which on the performance of last night means he gets games

 

[plugger66]

Reckon he is a deaset list clogger... his no.1 attribute is aggro, which on the performance of last night means he gets games

He is a player who sums up where the club is at the moment. He can play decent games but then have a few very ordinary games. He is the type of mid that must be replaced for us to be a top 6 side. I am still of the opinion that Dunstan, Stevens and Steele will play in more losing sides together than winning ones. They will take it in turns to play well but will hardly ever play well together. And best result recently was against Richmond when Ross and Steven were nearly our best because they provide run and space. The other mids are hard working tacklers and don't really set up play certainly against good sides.

 

[lewdogs]

Reckon he is a deaset list clogger... his no.1 attribute is aggro, which on the performance of last night means he gets games

He was outstanding two weeks ago. Form has dropped off though. Hardly a list clogger.

 

[bennymc7]

He is a player who sums up where the club is at the moment. He can play decent games but then have a few very ordinary games. He is the type of mid that must be replaced for us to be a top 6 side. I am still of the opinion that Dunstan, Stevens and Steele will play in more losing sides together than winning ones. They will take it in turns to play well but will hardly ever play well together. And best result recently was against Richmond when Ross and Steven were nearly our best because they provide run and space. The other mids are hard working tacklers and don't really set up play certainly against good sides.

I agree, i just don't see him as a long term best 22 prospect..

 

[bennymc7]

He was outstanding two weeks ago. Form has dropped off though. Hardly a list clogger.

Do you see him in our next finals push?

I'd be hoping gresh and acres push him out

 

[sonnywalters]

I would argue that he is giving young players experience, Steele is young , Stevens is pretty young .

Steele , Stevens , Dunstan , Ross , Steven are probably our key mids going forward . They need to be played together to they can mould into one group, with Whoever is in ruck . Is there any point at this stage of throwing Gresh in the middle when he doesn't have the tank yet . I thought everyone was happy having Billings as a forward . The longer that mid group plays together the better they will become imo.

Stevens is 26.
We are a side in no-mans land.
We arent a contender and we arent developing kids.
We are just stuck in the mud.

 

[sonnywalters]

For someone who puts on no pressure he led the team in pressure acts last night..

"pressure acts' is a really stupid statistic.

 

[Louis Slungpue]

hahahahahahahhhahahaha callum sinclair oh poo poo

 

[Gangnam Saint]

Koby a list clogger?
FMD
We have to turn over half our list if that's the case.

 

[Hayes4PM]

Koby a list clogger?
FMD
We have to turn over half our list if that's the case.

More than half our list at that rate! Short memories around here I think. Didn't Koby kick a few goals and get named in our best a few weeks ago?

We are an incredibly inconsistent team, so to pot anyone off one or two of our games as a permanent list flogger is pretty stupid I reckon.

 

[pluggeranddoc]

Billings and Gresh need to learn to get dangerous verse strong opposition. They are our barometers and when they aren't influential it's hard to win games. I'd love to have the ball is Jill's hands more often too.

Dunstan had a really good game.

Only highlight of the game was Jake dropping Buddy like a sack of s**t.

Fighting over the stash?

 

[pebblesofsand]

List clogger ha that's hilarious - I watched the Sandy game - Koby is not keeping anyone out of the side.

On K107 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Macgruber]

Last night was all about pressure. We were always under pressure and Sydney weren't.

We are still a finals chance if we win our last 4 which we are more than capable of.

I'm more in the it's the players fault category. Richo ain't that bad let's not forget two weeks ago. It's not his fault players kick straight to the opposition when you see they have clear open options.

I'm happy for Joey to move on as it's time for Dmac White Rice to step up. Newnes/Weller to take his Role. As for Roo if he can play wing more than forward like he did last year then I'm happy to keep him on.

If he's just going to play forward like this year then with Mccartin Battle and Marshall see above.

I want Roo to play for ever. But his knees are gone.

 

[Louis Slungpue]

only a special side can consistently make absolute hacks look like world beaters, callum sinclair campaigner was struggling in the neafl FFS i dont know how we manage to do it week in week out year after year

 

[Mowman]

only a special side can consistently make absolute hacks look like world beaters, callum sinclair campaigner was struggling in the neafl FFS i dont know how we manage to do it week in week out year after year

But we do do it well don't we

 

[saintsrfreak]

only a special side can consistently make absolute hacks look like world beaters, callum sinclair campaigner was struggling in the neafl FFS i dont know how we manage to do it week in week out year after year

He took the most contested marks in a game of any player for the year, no joke

 

[Louis Slungpue]

its at the point where i dont even get mad anymore just gotta laugh lmao

 

[Mowman]

its at the point where i dont even get mad anymore just gotta laugh lmao

very much the same for me, just have to accept we are average middle of table side that is still a fair way off

 

[Kilroy]

its at the point where i dont even get mad anymore just gotta laugh lmao

So you're saying we bring out the best in people?

 

[Mowman]

So you're saying we bring out the best in people?

Wish we could get the best out of the players a little more often