Remove this Banner Ad

Team Mgmt. Talk about the makeup of our list - midfield balance, height profile, endurance runners

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Keystone agony said:
Baz has it all for me

Great Size
Penetrating kick
Breaks lines
Hits the scoreboard
Has aggression

Poor year and didnt look interested but his assets are undeniable

Our pick 9 should be there for the dogs, but i doubt theyd accept it

Whether you went 9 and F1 for 10 and Baz is a tight call
Click to expand...
that last deal is a steal imo and not one i can see the Dogs doing
i think they'd want 9 and F1 and we'd push for the Lions 1st back (potential for Reid there)

McKay via FA
Smith & Thomas via trade.
pads that group in the 22-25yo range out nicely and fills some gaps.
But, 2 come with serious questions on off-field behaviour and work ethic
 
citizen-erased said:
we have Caldwell and Hobbs
We have Setterfield as someone with size, tackling and blocking.
And ideally get Draper up for a full season. Bryan looks like he doesn't mind a bit of physicality too.

for mine, we need to sort the fwd line out. good fwd lines will make hack kicks look good.
or at least hide the impact by locking the ball down.
Click to expand...
need to sort out the defence too. Hack kicks into the F50 only work for the other team's defence
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

WindyHillZephyr said:
As a re-signing its fine by me. The issue is that now we are/should be locked into signing players with "grunt". If they do that we just might get out of this.
Click to expand...

So the issue is the same as it was if he left but we get a top 5 clearance midfielder in the AFL as a throw in?
 
citizen-erased said:
we have Caldwell and Hobbs
We have Setterfield as someone with size, tackling and blocking.
And ideally get Draper up for a full season. Bryan looks like he doesn't mind a bit of physicality too.

for mine, we need to sort the fwd line out. good fwd lines will make hack kicks look good.
or at least hide the impact by locking the ball down.
Click to expand...
Still need something different. Powerful explosive bloke we can throw in the middle that can win a clearance by smashing straight though the front . Caldwell is not that guy . In fact I think he becomes the casualty with Parish staying and will have to settle for more of a forward role. Hobbs will be okay in and under but he does not offer the same as Dangerfield / Cripps / DeGoey . Stringer did for a while but has too many injuries . Perkins is simply not a clearance player. Setterfield does a good job with the blocking for sure but we need a dynamic clearance player.
We need grunt for sure. Biggest weakness is contested footy and I am not talking clearance. I am talking ball is there to be won at a contest either on the ground or marking. We have **** all players who play to be in the contest. That want to play like Hobbs does. Then there is also contested marking.
Yes we need another decent KPF and a quick pressure forward that can kick goals but we simply need to sort out our limited number of real hard edge players.
And Bryan is not a physical player. He does not seek out a contest. He goes for his marks and always has a crack in the ruck but he does not put the fear of god into the opposition. The area he has to find in is physical strength and playing a bit more angry . Draper needs to forget the rock star shit and the podcasts and get back to having the physical impact he had when he first came in the side and stop running around trying to do the flashy shit all the time.
 
ant555 said:
Still need something different. Powerful explosive bloke we can throw in the middle that can win a clearance by smashing straight though the front . Caldwell is not that guy . In fact I think he becomes the casualty with Parish staying and will have to settle for more of a forward role. Hobbs will be okay in and under but he does not offer the same as Dangerfield / Cripps / DeGoey . Stringer did for a while but has too many injuries . Perkins is simply not a clearance player. Setterfield does a good job with the blocking for sure but we need a dynamic clearance player.
We need grunt for sure. Biggest weakness is contested footy and I am not talking clearance. I am talking ball is there to be won at a contest either on the ground or marking. We have * all players who play to be in the contest. That want to play like Hobbs does. Then there is also contested marking.
Yes we need another decent KPF and a quick pressure forward that can kick goals but we simply need to sort out our limited number of real hard edge players.
And Bryan is not a physical player. He does not seek out a contest. He goes for his marks and always has a crack in the ruck but he does not put the fear of god into the opposition. The area he has to find in is physical strength and playing a bit more angry . Draper needs to forget the rock star s**t and the podcasts and get back to having the physical impact he had when he first came in the side and stop running around trying to do the flashy s**t all the time.
Click to expand...
Is Tarryn the guy?
 
ghostdog said:
Is Tarryn the guy?
Click to expand...
No . We do not currently have the leadership or culture to be bringing in projects that have a lot going on off field.
 
Last edited:
ant555 said:
Still need something different. Powerful explosive bloke we can throw in the middle that can win a clearance by smashing straight though the front . Caldwell is not that guy . In fact I think he becomes the casualty with Parish staying and will have to settle for more of a forward role. Hobbs will be okay in and under but he does not offer the same as Dangerfield / Cripps / DeGoey . Stringer did for a while but has too many injuries . Perkins is simply not a clearance player. Setterfield does a good job with the blocking for sure but we need a dynamic clearance player.
We need grunt for sure. Biggest weakness is contested footy and I am not talking clearance. I am talking ball is there to be won at a contest either on the ground or marking. We have * all players who play to be in the contest. That want to play like Hobbs does. Then there is also contested marking.
Yes we need another decent KPF and a quick pressure forward that can kick goals but we simply need to sort out our limited number of real hard edge players.
And Bryan is not a physical player. He does not seek out a contest. He goes for his marks and always has a crack in the ruck but he does not put the fear of god into the opposition. The area he has to find in is physical strength and playing a bit more angry . Draper needs to forget the rock star s**t and the podcasts and get back to having the physical impact he had when he first came in the side and stop running around trying to do the flashy s**t all the time.
Click to expand...
Yeah, Dangerfield / Cripps / DeGoey certainly have that explosive pace and tough ball getting ability. Also penetrating kick. I think we try and use Parish to get it to a shiel type but it fails if the opp clearance player is the type you mentioned. Tom Green is emerging well too.

Burst speed at the ball, as you say, would definitely combine well what we have, and probably the missing piece. When Stringer was up and about, it made a huge difference.

Hopefully addressed. Even a Butters type, with manic pressure & ball getting ability, would be handy if there are no bigger options available.

Re Draper, one thing he needs to do less of is grabbing the ball and trying for goal of the year all the time.
 
ant555 said:
Still need something different. Powerful explosive bloke we can throw in the middle that can win a clearance by smashing straight though the front . Caldwell is not that guy . In fact I think he becomes the casualty with Parish staying and will have to settle for more of a forward role. Hobbs will be okay in and under but he does not offer the same as Dangerfield / Cripps / DeGoey . Stringer did for a while but has too many injuries . Perkins is simply not a clearance player. Setterfield does a good job with the blocking for sure but we need a dynamic clearance player.
We need grunt for sure. Biggest weakness is contested footy and I am not talking clearance. I am talking ball is there to be won at a contest either on the ground or marking. We have * all players who play to be in the contest. That want to play like Hobbs does. Then there is also contested marking.
Yes we need another decent KPF and a quick pressure forward that can kick goals but we simply need to sort out our limited number of real hard edge players.
And Bryan is not a physical player. He does not seek out a contest. He goes for his marks and always has a crack in the ruck but he does not put the fear of god into the opposition. The area he has to find in is physical strength and playing a bit more angry . Draper needs to forget the rock star s**t and the podcasts and get back to having the physical impact he had when he first came in the side and stop running around trying to do the flashy s**t all the time.
Click to expand...
Agree with a lot of that. With Bryan, what i saw in his two games was a lanky kid still developing his frame but not letting that stop him go in and crash into a contest. He may not strike fear, but that doesn't stop him going in anyway. completely agree on Draper too. His spotlight from Gather Round went to his head.

on the "beast' side of things, i think we need to move away from copying what others have.
lions don't have Danger type. nor do Port.
Cripps is a different type for me & i don't see anyone at GWS or St Kilda that fits that profile.
We need our brand of grunt. Hobbs is a great example and just needs to tidy up a few bits to his game.

I like Caldwell as a Brayshaw type. run and compete all day. Crash in despite size. Wear the hits

the contested marking is a good call out. And it's something we have around the midfield but not really in it
Perkins, langford, Caldwell and Durham are the 4 i see really hitting aerial contests with strength and intent.
Outside Langford though, the other 3 are still developing.

A little off the Parish topic, but i think Darcy is an important part of a mix we're still getting right.
 
I'll try to resist doing this again until the trade period is done but no promises.

Out of contract:

2 years: Jye Menzie, Kaine Baldwin
1 year: Jaiden Hunter, Patrick Voss

Delist: Alastair Lord, Cian McBride, Will Snelling, James Stewart, Anthony Munkara, Rhett Montgomerie
Retire: Andrew Phillips, Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti

Trade/FA:

1. Riley Bonner FA (enough to get band 3)
2. Brandon Zerk-Thatcher for pick 35-40 (Bonner compensation pick, probably ends up as 37 pre bids)
3. Dylan Shiel to St Kilda for pick 34
4. Massimo D'Ambrosio to North for F3 (would rather keep but think he goes)
5. Todd Goldstein FA
6. Elijah Hollands and pick 5 for F1, picks 34, 37 and 70
7. Travis Colyer DFA

Leaves us with picks 5, 9, 29 and 49 with 3 list spots open (min 2 on senior list). Going into the draft I'd go:

Pick 7 (Bid on Ethan Read if still there): Nick Watson (Eastern Ranges, 169/70 small forward)
Pick 12 (Sanders to North maybe): Darcy Wilson (Murray Bushrangers, 185/73 midfielder/forward)
Pick ~30: Taylor Goad (South Adelaide, 205/90 ruck)
Pick ~50: Will Brown (Sandringham Dragons, 194/85 midfielder/forward)

Cat B: Wil Parker (Cricket, 180/80 half back), Mahmoud Taha (Calder Cannons, 182/75 outside midfielder)

Leaves us at:

Defence (14):

Key Defenders: Sam Weideman (KF), Lewis Hayes, Kaine Baldwin, Zach Reid
Medium Defenders: Nik Cox (MF), Jordan Ridley, Jayden Laverde, Dyson Heppell, Jake Kelly, Riley Bonner (OM)
Small Defenders: Andrew McGrath, Nick Hind, Mason Redman, Wil Parker

Midfielders (17):

Inside Midfielders: Darcy Parish, Elijah Tsatas, Jye Caldwell, Zach Merrett, Ben Hobbs, Will Setterfield, Will Brown (MF), Elijah Hollands, Darcy Wilson (MF)
Outside Midfielders: Sam Durham, Alwyn Davey Jr (SF), Nic Martin, Mahmoud Taha
Rucks: Sam Draper, Nick Bryan, Todd Goldstein, Taylor Goad

Forwards (13):

Key Forwards: Peter Wright (Ruc), Harrison Jones, Jaiden Hunter
Medium Forwards: Kyle Langford (OM), Archie Perkins (IM), Jake Stringer, Patrick Voss
Small Forwards: Matt Guelfi, Jayden Davey, Tex Wanganeen, Jye Menzie, Nic Watson, Travis Colyer

Seniors:

FB: Andrew McGrath - Kaine Baldwin - Jordan Ridley
HB: Mason Redman - Sam Weideman - Riley Bonner
MF: Nic Martin - Ben Hobbs- Sam Durham
HF: Archie Perkins - Kyle Langford - Tex Wanganeen
FF: Jye Menzie - Peter Wright - Jake Stringer
OB: Sam Draper - Zach Merrett - Darcy Parish
IC: Nik Cox - Jye Caldwell - Nick Bryan - Elijah Hollands
TS: Matt Guelfi

Reserves:

FB: Jayden Laverde - Zach Reid - Jake Kelly
HB: Nick Hind - Lewis Hayes - Dyson Heppell
MF: Alwyn Davey Jr - Darcy Wilson - Mahmoud Taha
HF: Travis Colyer - Harrison Jones - Patrick Voss
FF: Nick Watson - Jaiden Hunter - Jayden Davey
OB: Todd Goldstein - Will Setterfield -Elijah Tsatas
IC: Taylor Goad - Wil Parker - Will Brown

I've done some projection there, that's a mix of what I think happens (Goldstein, Bonner, Shiel, D'Ambrisio) and stuff I want to happen (Watson, Colyer, the draft). Makes the list a lot more balanced but I'd be keen to replace guys like Laverde, Heppell and Kelly for key position players as well.

Averages:

Height: 184.84 cm
Weight: 86.07 kg
Games played: 66.66
 
Last edited:
eth-dog said:
I'll try to resist doing this again until the trade period is done but no promises.

Out of contract:

2 years: Jye Menzie, Kaine Baldwin
1 year: Jaiden Hunter, Patrick Voss

Delist: Alastair Lord, Cian McBride, Will Snelling, James Stewart, Anthony Munkara, Rhett Montgomerie
Retire: Andrew Phillips, Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti

Trade/FA:

1. Riley Bonner FA (enough to get band 3)
2. Brandon Zerk-Thatcher for pick 35-40 (Bonner compensation pick, probably ends up as 37 pre bids)
3. Dylan Shiel to St Kilda for pick 34
4. Massimo D'Ambrosio to North for F3 (would rather keep but think he goes)
5. Todd Goldstein FA
6. Elijah Hollands and pick 5 for F1, picks 34, 37 and 70
7. Travis Colyer DFA

Leaves us with picks 5, 9, 29 and 49 with 3 list spots open (min 2 on senior list). Going into the draft I'd go:

Pick 7 (Bid on Ethan Read if still there): Nick Watson (Eastern Ranges, 169/70 small forward)
Pick 12 (Sanders to North maybe): Darcy Wilson (Murray Bushrangers, 185/73 midfielder/forward)
Pick ~30: Taylor Goad (South Adelaide, 205/90 ruck)
Pick ~50: Will Brown (Sandringham Dragons, 194/85 midfielder/forward)

Cat B: Wil Parker (Cricket, 180/80 half back), Mahmoud Taha (Calder Cannons, 182/75 outside midfielder)

Leaves us at:

Defence (14):

Key Defenders: Sam Weideman (KF), Lewis Hayes, Kaine Baldwin, Zach Reid
Medium Defenders: Nik Cox (MF), Jordan Ridley, Jayden Laverde, Dyson Heppell, Jake Kelly, Riley Bonner (OM)
Small Defenders: Andrew McGrath, Nick Hind, Mason Redman, Wil Parker

Midfielders (17):

Inside Midfielders: Darcy Parish, Elijah Tsatas, Jye Caldwell, Zach Merrett, Ben Hobbs, Will Setterfield, Will Brown (MF), Elijah Hollands, Darcy Wilson (MF)
Outside Midfielders: Sam Durham, Alwyn Davey Jr (SF), Nic Martin, Mahmoud Taha
Rucks: Sam Draper, Nick Bryan, Todd Goldstein, Taylor Goad

Forwards (13):

Key Forwards: Peter Wright (Ruc), Harrison Jones, Jaiden Hunter
Medium Forwards: Kyle Langford (OM), Archie Perkins (IM), Jake Stringer, Patrick Voss
Small Forwards: Matt Guelfi, Jayden Davey, Tex Wanganeen, Jye Menzie, Nic Watson, Travis Colyer

Seniors:

FB: Andrew McGrath - Kaine Baldwin - Jordan Ridley
HB: Mason Redman - Sam Weideman - Riley Bonner
MF: Nic Martin - Ben Hobbs- Sam Durham
HF: Archie Perkins - Kyle Langford - Tex Wanganeen
FF: Jye Menzie - Peter Wright - Jake Stringer
OB: Sam Draper - Zach Merrett - Darcy Parish
IC: Nik Cox - Jye Caldwell - Nick Bryan - Elijah Hollands
TS: Matt Guelfi

Reserves:

FB: Jayden Laverde - Zach Reid - Jake Kelly
HB: Nick Hind - Lewis Hayes - Dyson Heppell
MF: Alwyn Davey Jr - Darcy Wilson - Mahmoud Taha
HF: Travis Colyer - Harrison Jones - Patrick Voss
FF: Nick Watson - Jaiden Hunter - Jayden Davey
OB: Todd Goldstein - Will Setterfield -Elijah Tsatas
IC: Taylor Goad - Wil Parker - Will Brown

I've done some projection there, that's a mix of what I think happens (Goldstein, Bonner, Shiel, D'Ambrisio) and stuff I want to happen (Watson, Colyer, the draft). Makes the list a lot more balanced but I'd be keen to replace guys like Laverde, Heppell and Kelly for key position players as well.

Averages:

Height: 184.84 cm
Weight: 86.07 kg
Games played: 66.66
Click to expand...
To use one of your own sayings. Colyer is not up to AFL level.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

ant555 said:
To use one of your own sayings. Colyer is not up to AFL level.
Click to expand...
Yes, however I would counter that with the fact that he's played 87 games for us and all we need to do is give him 13 games as sub (maybe on field for game 100 for us and game 150 in total) to get his kids in play for us.
 
eth-dog said:
Yes, however I would counter that with the fact that he's played 87 games for us and all we need to do is give him 13 games as sub (maybe on field for game 100 for us and game 150 in total) to get his kids in play for us.
Click to expand...
that is so dumb it almost sounds like something we'd do.
 
eth-dog said:
Yes, however I would counter that with the fact that he's played 87 games for us and all we need to do is give him 13 games as sub (maybe on field for game 100 for us and game 150 in total) to get his kids in play for us.
Click to expand...

His wife is shorter than him. His kids might not ever get to ride a rollercoaster.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

ant555 said:
Still need something different. Powerful explosive bloke we can throw in the middle that can win a clearance by smashing straight though the front . Caldwell is not that guy . In fact I think he becomes the casualty with Parish staying and will have to settle for more of a forward role. Hobbs will be okay in and under but he does not offer the same as Dangerfield / Cripps / DeGoey . Stringer did for a while but has too many injuries . Perkins is simply not a clearance player. Setterfield does a good job with the blocking for sure but we need a dynamic clearance player.
We need grunt for sure. Biggest weakness is contested footy and I am not talking clearance. I am talking ball is there to be won at a contest either on the ground or marking. We have * all players who play to be in the contest. That want to play like Hobbs does. Then there is also contested marking.
Yes we need another decent KPF and a quick pressure forward that can kick goals but we simply need to sort out our limited number of real hard edge players.
And Bryan is not a physical player. He does not seek out a contest. He goes for his marks and always has a crack in the ruck but he does not put the fear of god into the opposition. The area he has to find in is physical strength and playing a bit more angry . Draper needs to forget the rock star s**t and the podcasts and get back to having the physical impact he had when he first came in the side and stop running around trying to do the flashy s**t all the time.
Click to expand...
Bailey Smith is a bloke that intrigues me. Is he a guy that could step up a level or two with more responsibility to be "the guy"? If he can that would be awesome, ala Tom Mitchell or is he simply another Brent Prismall?
 
I think competitiveness is a quality that is more about team culture than anything else.

When the standard is set and that’s the expectation it tends to work out. Essendon currently doesn’t have that standard, but it’s improved a lot this year due to captain Zac

What Essendon needs is more midsize players who can play most parts of the ground, take a mark and kick accurately.
 
Thought when Scott got the job he needed 4/5 years to do first part of the job. Turn list over, improve the recruiting and development areas and change the culture. Sadly, all this needs to be done before we become a serious team. Let’s be honest for the better part of 15 years we have been at best limping into finals or at worse a 13/15 finishing. I think we have to be realistic, other than Eagles our list I think is the second worse. Think hawks are in front and suspect Roos will soon be. Roos have compiled a lot of elite/top end talent , and will continue to this draft period.Now, will the management have the balls to see this through. Personally , I can live with 2/3 years of bottom 4 finishes and trust in that time Scott changes the DNA of the club.
 
leonleon said:
Thought when Scott got the job he needed 4/5 years to do first part of the job. Turn list over, improve the recruiting and development areas and change the culture. Sadly, all this needs to be done before we become a serious team. Let’s be honest for the better part of 15 years we have been at best limping into finals or at worse a 13/15 finishing. I think we have to be realistic, other than Eagles our list I think is the second worse. Think hawks are in front and suspect Roos will soon be. Roos have compiled a lot of elite/top end talent , and will continue to this draft period.Now, will the management have the balls to see this through. Personally , I can live with 2/3 years of bottom 4 finishes and trust in that time Scott changes the DNA of the club.
Click to expand...
We aren't going to do that, we will build on top of what we have and hope some of our kids stop getting injured and turn into the guys we hoped when we picked em.

There would be nothing worse than finishing 10th next season with a very similar 22 that played this year.

I pray for Jones, Reid, Cox, Tsatas, Davey and Baldwin to push in and play a lot, at a good AFL standard, if those blokes become best 22, finishing 10th is more than welcome.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

Howard Moon
Opinion Our starts and the patterns of our games
2
Replies
27
Views
1K
joey_jo_jo
J
ghostdog
General Bombers Talk Club Merch
Replies
16
Views
613
Bunk Moreland
Bunk Moreland
Lore
AFL Player 15: Dyson Sharp - 187cm midfielder & SA Captain, Welcome to Essendon!
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
129
Views
9K
TheUnicorn
TheUnicorn
Blind Turn
Opinion Elite Potential on our List
7 8 9 10 11
Replies
267
Views
17K
Blind Turn
Blind Turn
boncer34
General Bombers Talk Percentage Watch
2 3 4
Replies
87
Views
3K
boncer34
boncer34
Sporno 4 Pyros
General Bombers Talk Don The Stat: 100 Greatest Essendon Players Since 1980
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
150
Views
8K
Blind Turn
Blind Turn
silk
  • Locked
Preview Round 23: Essendon Bombers vs Our Second Round Pick, Friday August 15th 7:40pm, Marvel Stadium
2 3 4
Replies
88
Views
4K
VelvetSledge
VelvetSledge

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top