Prediction The AFC 12 Game Challenge

Joined
Sep 28, 2016
Posts
2,929
Likes
4,528
AFL Club
Adelaide
Thread starter #1
Hey All,

I hope you are all enjoying the offseason. I for 1 cannot wait to get back into some football. I did this last year in a thread but thought it would be quite interesting to do as its own thread this year.

How likely are the following fringe/up and coming/declining players to play in 12 games in 2019 (i.e, more then half a season). Feel free to add surprise players to your own lists.

No prize but bragging rights if you can pick a breakout darkhorse

For me its;

Douglas 25%
Mackay 15%
Otten 10%
CEY 40%
FOG 70%
Kelly 15%
Atkins 60%
Knight 80%
Gooch 100%
Poholke 5%
Stengle 5%
Jones 5%
McHenry 5%
Mcpherson 2%
Keath 50%
Davis 5%
O'Brien 20%

Best of luck and have fun!
 
Last edited:

(Log in to remove this ad.)

jackster83

Bring Rankine home!
Joined
Jul 31, 2007
Posts
9,711
Likes
10,994
Location
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Sin City Swamprats, Dethklok
#2
Douglas 100%
Mackay 95%
Otten 10%
CEY 30%
Fog 30%
Kelly 80%
Atkins 100%
Knight 60%
Gooch 90%
Poholke 20%
Stengle 5%
Jones 20%
McHenry 15%
McPherson 1% (doubt he even plays 12 SANFL games)
Keath 90%
Davis 10%
O'Brien < 5%
McAdam 30%
Murphy 50%
 

Scorpus

Rubber Stamper
Joined
Apr 16, 2014
Posts
27,877
Likes
58,614
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Adelaide
#3
Douglas 100%
Mackay 100%
Otten 50%
CEY 0%
Fogarty 0%
Kelly 100%
Atkins 100%
Knight 50%
Gooch 100%
Poholke 0%
Stengle 0%
Jones 0%
McHenry 0%
Mcpherson 0%
Keath 50%
Davis 0%
O'Brien 0%
McAdam 0%
Murphy 0%
 

kulak

Club Legend
Joined
May 16, 2006
Posts
2,348
Likes
2,811
Location
Sydney!!!
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
GWS
#4
Douglas 100%
Mackay 95%
Otten 10%
CEY 30%
Fog 30%
Kelly 80%
Atkins 100%
Knight 60%
Gooch 90%
Poholke 20%
Stengle 5%
Jones 20%
McHenry 15%
McPherson 1% (doubt he even plays 12 SANFL games)
Keath 90%
Davis 10%
O'Brien < 5%
McAdam 30%
Murphy 50%
I would have Keath lower because he faces the dual threat of getting injured and getting dropped when Harto is fit. Sadly.

Other than that, it mirrors my thoughts.
 
Joined
Sep 28, 2016
Posts
2,929
Likes
4,528
AFL Club
Adelaide
Thread starter #5
Douglas 100%
Mackay 100%
Otten 50%
CEY 0%
Fogarty 0%
Kelly 100%
Atkins 100%
Knight 50%
Gooch 100%
Poholke 0%
Stengle 0%
Jones 0%
McHenry 0%
Mcpherson 0%
Keath 50%
Davis 0%
O'Brien 0%
McAdam 0%
Murphy 0%
Cheers, personally I think the age of Dougy and Mackay is behind us, dont get me wrong I know they will play games, but whether they play half the season or not i'm pretty doubtful.

Dougy has a better opportunity as he is so flexible and is generally well regarded in the club, but having said that I wouldn't put him in our top 8 forwards, mids or defenders anymore. And we have guys like Sloane, Knight, Milera, and Greenwood who can play the jack of all trades role.

I know the running joke is we will never drop these guys, but 2019 might finally be the end! At least thats what i'm predicting
 
Last edited:
Joined
Sep 28, 2016
Posts
2,929
Likes
4,528
AFL Club
Adelaide
Thread starter #6
Douglas 100%
Mackay 95%
Otten 10%
CEY 30%
Fog 30%
Kelly 80%
Atkins 100%
Knight 60%
Gooch 90%
Poholke 20%
Stengle 5%
Jones 20%
McHenry 15%
McPherson 1% (doubt he even plays 12 SANFL games)
Keath 90%
Davis 10%
O'Brien < 5%
McAdam 30%
Murphy 50%
Lol, Yeah you're probably spot on about McPherson
 

Scorpus

Rubber Stamper
Joined
Apr 16, 2014
Posts
27,877
Likes
58,614
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Adelaide
#7
Cheers, personally I think the age of Dougy and Mackay is behind us, dont get me wrong I know they will play games, but whether they play half the season or not i'm pretty doubtful.

Dougy has a better opportunity as he is so flexible and is generally well regarded in the club, but having said that I wouldn't put him in our top 8 forwards, mids or defenders anymore. And we have guys like Sloane, Knight, Milera, and Greenwood who can play the jack of all trades role.

I know the running joke is we will never drop these guys, but 2019 might finally be the end! At least thats what i'm predicting
When in doubt, the shit aging player always plays at the AFC
 
Top Bottom