Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion The 'Carlton related stuff that doesn't need it's own thread' thread Part 2

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Zac Williams taking an extended time off doesn’t fill me with great hope for the condition he would return in. Been the disappointing player of the year for mine. Turned up later than the others. Turned up out of shape. Saad turned up day one in mint condition. He’s played with niggles all year. Gets it 20+ Every week. Doesn’t set state records for clangers every second week. He’s an absolute credit to himself Adam Saad. Will finish third in the B+F for sure IMO.
Williams "turned up later than the others" because he was stuck in NSW due to the Vic Govt's border closure. He ended up staying at his sister's place in Albury & doing what training he could in the local area. In a pre-season shortened by the later than usual end to the 2020 season, he was behind the eight ball from the start.
 
Williams "turned up later than the others" because he was stuck in NSW due to the Vic Govt's border closure. He ended up staying at his sister's place in Albury & doing what training he could in the local area. In a pre-season shortened by the later than usual end to the 2020 season, he was behind the eight ball from the start.


But 'He's lazy, unfit, and not committed' makes much better fodder for those looking to be outraged and find something else to pot the club about. Damn you and your silly facts ;)
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I'd have him in, but he's not a certainty. It's a logjam in the middle
In no particular order.
Walsh
Parish
Mitchell
Wines
Oliver
Petracca
Macrae
Bont
Merrett
Laird
Guthrie
Touk Miller
Steele
Boak
Gaff
Sheed
Josh Kelly
Keays
Mundy
Fyfe
Taranto
Lyons
Mills
Hopper
Cunnington
Brayshaw (Freo)
Libba
McLuggage
Seedsman
Menegola
Zorko
Greenwood (GC)

Then you have to remember that they always throw in a curveball or two and worry about them trying to squeeze in some of the usual names, despite them having a substandard year, or borderline on playing enough games.
Danger (games? Always find room)
Neale (games?)
Duncan (games?)
Dusty (always find room)
Pendles
Selwood
Dunkley (games)
Sloane (games)
Treloar (games)

Now, admittedly, some of those names are questionable, but that's about 40 players without considering rucks, forwards and defenders. Plus the automatic penalty that Walsh will get for wearing Navy Blue.

My point is, that while I would expect/hope he makes the squad and be in serious consideration for the 22, he can't be considered a lock for the squad, any more than he can be called a lock for the team. Stranger things have happened.
heaps better post and yes, there's a few there.......
 
I'd have him in, but he's not a certainty. It's a logjam in the middle
In no particular order.
Walsh
Parish
Mitchell
Wines
Oliver
Petracca
Macrae
Bont
Merrett
Laird
Guthrie
Touk Miller
Steele
Boak
Gaff
Sheed
Josh Kelly
Keays
Mundy
Fyfe
Taranto
Lyons
Mills
Hopper
Cunnington
Brayshaw (Freo)
Libba
McLuggage
Seedsman
Menegola
Zorko
Greenwood (GC)

Then you have to remember that they always throw in a curveball or two and worry about them trying to squeeze in some of the usual names, despite them having a substandard year, or borderline on playing enough games.
Danger (games? Always find room)
Neale (games?)
Duncan (games?)
Dusty (always find room)
Pendles
Selwood
Dunkley (games)
Sloane (games)
Treloar (games)

Now, admittedly, some of those names are questionable, but that's about 40 players without considering rucks, forwards and defenders. Plus the automatic penalty that Walsh will get for wearing Navy Blue.

My point is, that while I would expect/hope he makes the squad and be in serious consideration for the 22, he can't be considered a lock for the squad, any more than he can be called a lock for the team. Stranger things have happened.



So no Connor Rozee then?

:think:
 
Williams "turned up later than the others" because he was stuck in NSW due to the Vic Govt's border closure. He ended up staying at his sister's place in Albury & doing what training he could in the local area. In a pre-season shortened by the later than usual end to the 2020 season, he was behind the eight ball from the start.
Yep. Why did he get stuck? It wasn’t a snap lockdown? Check your facts. He chose to stay there. Says a lot. Im
Cutting the guy zero slack.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top