MRP / Trib. Tom Lynch eye gouge on Adam Saad

[Elmer_Judd]

Cool story.

Honest question, can you honestly say you were happy with Richmond's performance against a Carlton team without a backline and Cerra who torched you in Round 1 (I will let the umpiring slide, I don't like making excuses)

It was just a merely adequate performances from what I saw, and certainly not one that would cut the mustard against the best teams in the comp.

 

[footyfan1978]

Take your post to the bay.
Probably where you should have started with such silly posting.

 

[TheOptimum18]

If you watch it in slow motion, it looks pretty cut and dry in my opinion.

Look I think maybe been a bit hasty in my OP for the severity of the punishment for Lynch, but it still was a very reckless and negligent act from Lynch, I can accept the argument he probably didn't mean to do it, but it was still a very bad look and shouldn't go unpunished

Everything looks worse in slow motion mate. You could write all kinds of narratives by only looking at slow motion.

 

[Gak Attack]

Anything short of a lifetime ban would be an injustice.

 

[tiger_tough]

Honest question, can you honestly say you were happy with Richmond's performance against a Carlton team without a backline and Cerra who torched you in Round 1 (I will let the umpiring slide, I don't like making excuses)

It was just a merely adequate performances from what I saw, and certainly not one that would cut the mustard against the best teams in the comp.

I'm always happy with a win.

The rain somewhat offset the lacking of a couple of tall backs. Docherty and Saad were you're best players. Only 3 of Weitering, Marchbank, McDonald, Young, Durdin and McGovern would've played anyway. Young looks like a lock now as is Weitering obviously so blues fans can't keep claiming Omac, Marchbank AND Gov as best 22 also, it just doesn't add up. Looks like great depth when they're all fit though.
75% Dusty offset Cerra.
We dominated the best stoppage team in the comp in clearances, which is one of our biggest weaknesses.
Blues played pretty shite for the majority. We can still play better than we did too and yes we're clearly a rung below the real contenders atm but we're improving each week. I'm not expecting to beat cats or lions but I was expecting a win last night. Thats 6 of the last 7 which is a hell of a lot better than we were dishing up last year and early this year.

In short, yes I was happy with the win as I assume you were after r1.

 

[Elmer_Judd]

I'm always happy with a win.

The rain somewhat offset the lacking of a couple of tall backs. Docherty and Saad were you're best players. Only 3 of Weitering, Marchbank, McDonald, Young, Durdin and McGovern would've played anyway. Young looks like a lock now as is Weitering obviously so blues fans can't keep claiming Omac, Marchbank AND Gov as best 22 also, it just doesn't add up. Looks like great depth when they're all fit though.
75% Dusty offset Cerra.
We dominated the best storage team in the comp in clearances, which is one of our biggest weaknesses.
Blues played pretty shite for the majority. We can still play better than we did too and yes we're clearly a rung below the real contenders atm but we're improving each week. I'm not expecting to beat cats or lions but I was expecting a win last night. Thats 6 of the last 7 which is a hell of a lot better than we were dishing up last year and early this year.

In short, yes I was happy with the win.

Fair enough, I probably do come across as a bit more salty than I intended.
You have found a couple of cracking kids in Ralphsmith and Gibcus (Maurice Jnr is going to be wonderful once he gets 50-100 games under his belt)

 

[tiger_tough]

Fair enough, I probably do come across as a bit more salty than I intended.
You have found a couple of cracking kids in Ralphsmith and Gibcus (Maurice Jnr is going to be wonderful once he gets 50-100 games under his belt)

A Richmond Carlton final near full strength would be awesome. Let's hope.

 

[Area51]

Surely this thread is going to win some sort prize. Where is the voting for biggest one eyed post on big footy?

 

[Elmer_Judd]

A Richmond Carlton final near full strength would be awesome. Let's hope.

It's good to have that bitter rivarly of the 70s and early 80s that I missed back.

I still rate our round 1 triumph as the most satisfying and emotionally nurturing win we have had in several years, let alone this season.

Yeah a Blues v Tiges final would be amazing and the AFL would love it (would sell out within the first few hours tix go on sale)

 

[Righteo]

Credit to the OP for getting so many bites with such an obvious troll thread.

 

[tiger_tough]

Credit to the OP for getting so many bites with such an obvious troll thread.

Trolls don't admit they got it wrong. Fair play for that.

 

[captain blood 17]

That's a good one!

1 win in 9 years against us is all of those gifs plus more.

 

[Cdog71]

I don't believe it was as accidentally as you or most others think, but meh, regardless,enjoy your victory against a Carlton VFL team.

We were rubbish for most of the game last night, a true premiership contender like Freo or Brisbane or Geelong would have buried us by 10 goals on that performance by us.

Just don't get carried away with the win, you won't beat the teams I mentioned if you play like that.

We’ll just eye gouge em

 

[_RT_]

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

What’s evident clear is without umpire assistance you guys are nowhere against us. You needed those 8 50’s in the first game to get anywhere near the tiges. You guys got a goal when Broad got taken out with front on contact and no free kick. So i guess we’re even now.

That's clear is it?

Your injury list is 1? Martin out sick.

Do you reckon Weitering, Cerra, Williams, McGovern (who was great in round 1), Pittonet may have made a difference to our game?

 

[Vikingnz]

That's clear is it?

Your injury list is 1? Martin out sick.

Do you reckon Weitering, Cerra, Williams, McGovern (who was great in round 1), Pittonet may have made a difference to our game?

No.

Next question.

 

[TiggyTig]

Honest question, can you honestly say you were happy with Richmond's performance against a Carlton team without a backline and Cerra who torched you in Round 1 (I will let the umpiring slide, I don't like making excuses)

It was just a merely adequate performances from what I saw, and certainly not one that would cut the mustard against the best teams in the comp.

Richmond had the most inside 50’s ever as a club with lots more room for improvement. Happy enough with that in Rd 14


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[SunshineBoy]

Only player wrestling apperently

 

[theyellowsash]

carlton fans

 

[Tiger71]

That's clear is it?

Your injury list is 1? Martin out sick.

Do you reckon Weitering, Cerra, Williams, McGovern (who was great in round 1), Pittonet may have made a difference to our game?

Remember our outs in round 1 ?

Remember we losing Prestia 10 minutes in the first. Jacking breaking his hand 2 seconds into the first ?

Remember us giving 8 50's which resulted in 6 goals

Do you think that would have made a difference in round 1 result ? Funny, never say really any blues supporters mentioning it

 

[Moonatic77]

Somewhere between 4-6 weeks he should get, but because Richmond are the pets of the MRP/Tribunal, that sniper will likely only get 1 or 2 weeks. who's this bad wolf sniper btw

 

[footyfan1978]

Anything short of a lifetime ban would be an injustice.

Not sure the moderators allowed to ban that long for starting such a stupid thread.

 

[Heisenberg_]

Yeah I probably went off a bit half-cocked

Still think it's worth a week or two, but it seems this was a massive overreaction from me.

That’s still a massive overreaction

 

[SunshineBoy]

Remember our outs in round 1 ?

Remember we losing Prestia 10 minutes in the first. Jacking breaking his hand 2 seconds into the first ?

Remember us giving 8 50's which resulted in 6 goals

Do you think that would have made a difference in round 1 result ? Funny, never say really any blues supporters mentioning it

It was 9 one was a double 50

 

[Tiger71]

Honest question, can you honestly say you were happy with Richmond's performance against a Carlton team without a backline and Cerra who torched you in Round 1 (I will let the umpiring slide, I don't like making excuses)

It was just a merely adequate performances from what I saw, and certainly not one that would cut the mustard against the best teams in the comp.

This is what I don't get. You cry injury when it effects your side yet celebrate your round 1 victory while ignoring that you played our vfl side in round 1 due to being smashed injury wise.

Just go look at the side. We had no midfield outside Dusty and cotch. Dusty also playing first game after father's death and should not have played.

Our backline also was guttered and in that game the umpires gave you a complete ride. So why are 99.9% of Carlton supporters after beating a heavily injury compromised Richmond side acting like you actually smashed a full strength Richmond and by doing so you have already proven to be now a better side then the tigers?