Mega Thread Trade Targets 2014

[Weiterbot23]

Get Membrey!

Don't get Melksham! Seriously though, can't be arsed going back over the last 20 pages...what is the talk on Melksham (apart from his extremely punchable face)?

The talk is generally that everyone hates him and a few people think he's better than Brock.

 

[Dramoth]

Someone do a pic of Membrey in a Carlton jumper and we flood Twitter with it

 

[Crippa16]

If he averaged 40 goals over 4 years surely we can get a 3rd upgraded to a second round pick for him.

Operation get membrey. Come on Blues...fu... get it done.

What an off-season it will be if we get KJ Membrey Jones and keep pick 6

 

[Magruder]

The talk is generally that everyone hates him and a few people think he's better than Brock.

yep, but you can hate him and still rate him as OK.

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Don't want to lose pick 6 and don't want to lose Jaksch either.
Has he really come out and said that he wants us? or was it Rogers just saying that he has "indicated" he would like to join us?
If we were to give up a pick that high for Jaksch, I would want their end of 1st and start of second thrown in. Maybe we would need to give up our mid second to them for that to happen

 

[The Bunyip]

Am so glad Higgins isn't in the mix.
Funnily enough when it was first rumoured he was leaving the kennel I knew for some bizarre reason he'd be immediately linked to Carlton.
They must have worked out we don't need another fringe player who can't get his own ball.
I'm thinking a Lucas & back in the dark old days a Troy Longmuir.They promise so much & never deliver.

 

[kingkingston]

Last year we didn't do anything for the sake of depth with the exception of rookie-ing Wood but even there, I would consider it more of a need given our lack of ruck stocks.

Given we may just move on up to 12 players this year some holes will need to be filled.
Jones is worthy of chance if he's cheap enough as he does potentially fit a need and the same may be said for Tutt, given his pace.
We just don't want to take too many chances with those that have already had plenty of chances.

every move is a gamble and you don't know how it will work out. All i'm saying is, is that some people think that if a player doesn't make it at one club, they think he is no good but as history has shown us, players have made a habit of being far better at their next club than the original as long as they have the right coach

 

[Magruder]

Am so glad Higgins isn't in the mix.
Funnily enough when it was first rumoured he was leaving the kennel I knew for some bizarre reason he'd be immediately linked to Carlton.
They must have worked out we don't need another fringe player who can't get his own ball.
I'm thinking a Lucas & back in the dark old days a Troy Longmuir.They promise so much & never deliver.

Wouldn't have been upset if we'd snaffled him though. My first reaction was No but he does have something to offer, just doubtful whether he will ever deliver.

 

[Tom Joad]

Considering our interest in players like Membrey, Jaksch, Jones and Tutt, does that not make it essential to ship out Robinson, Garlett, maybe Lucas as soon as possible in the week?

There'll be competition for Membrey/Jaksch and you'd assume, if our interest holds in Jones and Tutt, they'd both require 3rd and 4th round picks respectively.

Therefore we'll need to consolidate on draft picks. Can't see GWS and especially not Sydney being interested in straight player swaps with Robbo or Garlett.

 

[Blue since 72]

Tutt's stats from this year are pretty good for a small forward. Seems a hard working type.

This would be the attraction for Mick (vs what we currently have in the small forward dept).

If Garlett goes we have possible replacements in this guy and Saad and tbh one of the biggest knocks on jeff, even when he was going well was inconsistency.

 

[GT619]

Jay Clark has just said that Membrey as requested a trade.

Get it done Carlton!

u mean get it done nicky graham

 

[GT619]

Seems like exciting times for us blues. Judd did say he's excited what's coming

 

[Cringle]

After Rogers words is safe to exclude pick 6 in anymore hypotheticals.

 

[zeeCFC]

After Rogers words is safe to exclude pick 6 in anymore hypotheticals.

KRUEGER AND PICK 6 FOR O'ROURKE AND FROST!

 

[Jeremias]

KRUEGER AND PICK 6 FOR O'ROURKE AND FROST!

K UGER! K UGER!

 

[F_therest]

Not sure Membrey would be a target since Walker and Menzel would appear to have the 'mid size forward' positions sown up

 

[swaggyD]

May allow Walker to play higher up e.g: through wing or mids. Never have to many quality players with speed and endurance running through the middle.

Not sure Membrey would be a target since Walker and Menzel would appear to have the 'mid size forward' positions sown up

 

[etsal1]

 

[bluekidjoe]

On ya Puss! Love Nicky G's work, good to have a cheeky young bloke who seems to love the club.

 

[Cringle]

Just saw a facebook trade page throw up a trade of our pick 26 for Tutt and Jones.

Please don't allow two fringe players equal a 2nd rounder. That's like us chucking Robinson and Lucas for pick 25 from the Dogs. Even then Robinson has done more than both Tutt and Jones combined.

 

[etsal1]

Just saw a facebook trade page throw up a trade of our pick 26 for Tutt and Jones.

Please don't allow two fringe players equal a 2nd rounder. That's like us chucking Robinson and Lucas for pick 25 from the Dogs. Even then Robinson has done more than both Tutt and Jones combined.

IMO it won't happen. Jones for a 3rd said Rogers. And Tutt isn't a high priority.

 

[Mezzoculo]

We've been saying that for a couple of weeks but no-one believed............

Wanting to come and getting to where you want to go isn't always easy. Jaksch may have to settle for the long drive to Seaford.

Would sending six to gws in exchange for kj and a later pick which we could send to swans for Membrey work? KJ and Membrey for pick 6?

 

[Cringle]

Would sending six to gws in exchange for kj and a later pick which we could send to swans for Membrey work? KJ and Membrey for pick 6?

...

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Would sending six to gws in exchange for kj and a later pick which we could send to swans for Membrey work? KJ and Membrey for pick 6?

Membrey is worth a third round pick at best.

 

[F_therest]

Would sending six to gws in exchange for kj and a later pick which we could send to swans for Membrey work? KJ and Membrey for pick 6?

People were floating pick 6 for Jaksch and pick 18...which imo isnt worth it.
And Membrey is not worthy of pick 18.