Travis Cloke vs Josh J Kennedy

[Mundy]

Nobody flukes 100 goals in a year.

Buddy > Kennedy, that's no snipe at Kennedy either who I rate.

 

[CrazyQ]

You may be on drugs, so I will slowly leave this thread and never speak of this again.

 

[bigburger]

Nobody flukes 100 goals in a year.

Buddy > Kennedy, that's no snipe at Kennedy either who I rate.

I rate your opinion Pav so how highly do you rate JK. Where do you think he will be in two years?

 

[Mundy]

I rate your opinion Pav so how highly do you rate JK. Where do you think he will be in two years?

Depends on how your midfield develops.

Personally, I think he'll work his way into the premier forwards department, should your midfield feed him enough.

What he has shown this year, IMO, is that he wants to have an influence no matter how poorly the rest of the eagles outfit may be travelling.

That's an admirable trait. He has all the traits to develop into a top 5 CHF and will do so if your midfield holds up.

Love his workrate, love his hands, set shot leaves a little to be desired but beyond that has all the traits.

 

[bigburger]

Depends on how your midfield develops.

Personally, I think he'll work his way into the premier forwards department, should your midfield feed him enough.

What he has shown this year, IMO, is that he wants to have an influence no matter how poorly the rest of the eagles outfit may be travelling.

That's an admirable trait. He has all the traits to develop into a top 5 CHF and will do so if your midfield holds up.

Love his workrate, love his hands, set shot leaves a little to be desired but beyond that has all the traits.

Totally agree with that assessment.

 

[Palmer Stoat]

He's had a poor year so far, but still Travis comfortably. Can't believe the number of people voting for Kennedy.

 

[eaglevic]

Or the fact Cloke has done more in his career.

Cloke won the Copeland trophy in 2007 and carried that same form through to the 2008 season averaging very similar numbers across both years. Career wise, Cloke is superior to Kennedy as well.

What has Kennedy achieved?

Well he got out of carltank, thats an achievement.

 

[didaka]

Cloke suits our structure better, but Kennedy is a furking gun and his best will be very good.

 

[Black Flag]

Kennedy can't kick, can't run, can't play below his knees. Making him better than Cloke.

 

[magpie10]

Kennedy can't kick, can't run, can't play below his knees. Making him better than Cloke.

Yet both are miles ahead of your makeshift CHF, setanta o'hailphin or simon wiggins or cameron cloke or whoever the f@#$k is your CHF these days, that is, if carltank even have one

 

[Hodgepodge]

As the midfield gets better Kennedy will become a handful for opposition defenders.

Has a great tank and nice hands. Is a good long kick at goal, too.

 

[bigburger]

Thoughts on this currently?

 

[Play by Numbers]

I agree with Mundy but I am bias.

 

[Heater39]

I agree with Mundy but I am bias.

Biased

But yes, Kennedy has moved past Cloke.

 

[brettman135]

Kennedy is better but Cloke has better delivery.

 

[bigburger]

Kennedy is better but Cloke has better delivery.

/thread