Ultimate Phantom Draft

[sergei]

Using a number of the more recent Phantom draft's already created by BF members I have calculated the number of times a player is nominated for each pick, the player that is nominated most is therefore deemed as the most likely to go at that pick. In the event of a tie I have just chosen the nominee that has been named more often in higher picks. The last four picks are a little Hazy though.

The following Phantom drafts were considered:
Phantom draft top 30
Phantom Draft V2
Phantom Draft VI
Hallad Hawks
swans4eva
Hedgehog
R Pettard 15
McGun's Phantom draft
Saxy Maxy Phantom Draft
Much thanks to all the creators for their efforts.

Here Goes:
P Pick 1 Melbourne Tom Scully
Pick 2 Melbourne Jack Trengove
Pick 3 Richmond John Butcher
Pick 4 Fremantle Anthony Morabito
Pick 5 Kangaroos Dustin Martin
Pick 6 Sydney Gary Rohan
Pick 7 West Coast Kane Lucas
Pick 8 Port Adelaide Luke Tapscott
Pick 9 Hawthorn Daniel Tahlia
Pick 10 Essendon Ben Cunnington
Pick 11 Carlton Matthew Panos
Pick 12 Brisbane Koby Stevens
Pick 13 Adelaide Lewis Jetta
Pick 14 Collingwood Nathan Vardy
Pick 15 Western Bulldogs Mitch Duncan
Pick 16 Geelong Allen Christenson
Pick 17 St Kilda Jordan Gysberts
I must admit that I know little of most the players here so any 'improvements' are welcome.

 

[swans16]

Sydney can swap Gary Rohan for Dustin Martin.

 

[roos_fanatic08]

nah...roos want martin.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Rather Koby thanks

 

[swans4eva]

I think that this is the 2009 generic big footy order!
there is also an order which newbies (myself included) abide by and this is that order, the draft will hardly resemble this order at all... can't wait for matt burgon's haha

 

[Shere Khan]

Richmond won't take Butcher due to the fact we already have way too many players that butcher the ball as badly as Butcher.

 

[swans16]

nah...roos want martin.

LOL you mean Paul Roos

 

[Balony_pony16]

I think that this is the 2009 generic big footy order!
there is also an order which newbies (myself included) abide by and this is that order, the draft will hardly resemble this order at all... can't wait for matt burgon's haha

I agree..all thes drafts seem to be a cop paste of others...I actually think tapscott will slip to the lions like Rich did last season.

 

[TimeFor11]

Richmond won't take Butcher due to the fact we already have way too many players that butcher the ball as badly as Butcher.

And how would it feel if he went on to become a star. We need to take him imo, we need a KPF he is the best one its obvious in my eyes.

 

[freaky]

Richmond won't take Butcher due to the fact we already have way too many players that butcher the ball as badly as Butcher.

Francis Jackson will not select Butcher at 3. Provided he has a good draft camp...Martin is a certainty!!

 

[Shere Khan]

And how would it feel if he went on to become a star. We need to take him imo, we need a KPF he is the best one its obvious in my eyes.

It's thinking like that which has made us the laughing stock at draft day.

Get the best kid with the best skills and stop looking for some magic X factor. We don't need another JON.

 

[thejester]

So we've actually reached the acme of BigFooty groupthink.

Mad.

 

[sergei]

I think that this is the 2009 generic big footy order!
there is also an order which newbies (myself included) abide by and this is that order, the draft will hardly resemble this order at all... can't wait for matt burgon's haha

I couldn't agree more. Although it's hardly surprising as none of this is my own opinion (as I must confess I know sweet F***All about the possible draftees) it is merely a tally of the other Phantom drafts (yours included) featured on BF.

 

[Marlin01]

I agree..all thes drafts seem to be a cop paste of others...I actually think tapscott will slip to the lions like Rich did last season.

I have a feeling the Eagles will take him with their first pick. That's pure speculation though.

 

[-VC-]

I couldn't agree more. Although it's hardly surprising as none of this is my own opinion (as I must confess I know sweet F***All about the possible draftees) it is merely a tally of the other Phantom drafts (yours included) featured on BF.

When compiling this list did it occur to you that the Phantom's so far might range from poor to very poor?

 

[sergei]

When compiling this list did it occur to you that the Phantom's so far might range from poor to very poor?

Of course it did, but then again of all the speculation on Big Footy what isn't.
Anyway what significance does that hold, it is basically just a tally of where BF users think a player may end up, I did not state anywhere that this would be anything close to the actual draft.