MVP Versus Carlton

[Tonycam*]

5. Enright
4. Corey
3. Selwood
2. Harley
1. Mack

 

[DanA]

5. Enright
4. Harley
3. Selwood
2. Corey
1. Mackie


Enright never seems to lose.

Harley was really good against Eddiie Betts. He's been a very good lately but was completely unsighted and a one point dragged while Harley pealed of him all night.

 

[noclashjumpers]

5 - Enright
4 - Corey
3 - Selwood
2 - Mackie
1 - Bartel

 

[Ricketts]

Midfield was disgraceful. Suprised at all the votes posters here are giving them. Although i guess when we play as bad as we did last night it's probably easy to just look at the possession counts and go on that.

5- Enright - Just can't be beaten

4- Harley - Took marks from their kicks (hello Walls) which is his M.O. If he can keep that form up when Harry and Scarlett come back then we might be alright.

3- Mooney - Thought he was looking good when we could get it to him, was duking everything, kicked a couple, hit the post with one he should have got, looked dangerous i thought, but no love from this board.

2- Gillies - Knows his way around the backline. Obviously there's no point in judging a first year KP defender on his one-one-one battles, given the size and strength issues, but his kicking coming out of the 50 is good and smart, looks to keep it in the corridor, also knows where to position his body in relation to the forward and the ball.

1- Selwood - Was ok.

 

[James1970]

5. Enright
4. Mackie
3. Harley
2. Selwood
1. Corey (just....playing on edge, he's lost his confidence)

 

[krisholio14]

Did lonergan win any 1on1 contests?

Yes he did.

 

[watermelonslice]

1. Enright
2. Corey
3. Selwood
2. Harley
1. Mackie

 

[Generalissimo]

5. Enright
4. Selwood
3. Ling
2. Harley
1. Mumford
young gun: Gillies
Spud: S. Johnson

 

[The Rusty Clam]

5. Enright
4. Selwood
3. Corey
2. Mackie
1. Ling

 

[Hood007]

5. Enright - Clearly our best. Some of his kicks out of defence on his left under pressure were spectacular.
4. Selwood - Always puts his head over it. 11 tackles out of 41 shows his effort.
3. Harley - Kept Betts goaless. Took a few grabs. Just needs to play himself back into form. Was the same in '07 when everyone was calling for him to be dropped.
2. Corey
1. Mackie


Jimmy had a shocker. Barely touched it after halftime...
Gaz is looking whingey/lazier by the week. He'll bounce back.
Gillies looks promising. Needs to bulk up though, can't have him being beaten by Kade Simpson in marking contests...
Mooney tried hard.

 

[Ninty]

I'm not so sure I should be voting as my brain never saved much memory for this game (not because of alcohol of course ), but I can remember Enright obviously being everywhere. Gun.

5. Enright
4. Mackie
3. Selwood
2. Harley
1. Mumford

 

[bingle]

5. Enright
4. Selwood
3. Corey
2. Harley
1. Bartel

 

[timmyhass]

5. Enright (tried hard all night, great kick always finds a target)
4. Corey (had a massive first half, to bad there was no one to help him out)

3. Selwood

2. Harley
1. Mackie

 

[Fuzzyash]

Have only just mentally recovered from this game, so late votes:

5. Enright
4. Selwood
3. Harley
2. Corey
1. Mackie

Selwood and Corey weren't actually that effective because they never had any space, but votes for effort. Harley completely shut down his opponent and dropped off him to mark it a few times.

Thought Mooney and Stokes both tried hard, but you really didn't want to be playing in front of the ball for Geelong on Friday night.

S.Johnson played one of the worst individual games I've seen at this level.

 

[thegerman]

5 - Enright
4 - Joel Corey
3 - Selwood
2 - Ling
1 - Mumford

 

[vegemite]

Good to see some people giving Harley some credit - some were putting him out to pasture effective immediately a week ago:

5-Enright
4-Harley
3-Mackie
2-Corey
1-Mooney

 

[CF]

Round 19 - Versus Carlton

(5) 142 Enright
(4) 110 Selwood
(3) 68 Corey
(2) 47 Harley
(1) 39 Mackie

10 Ling
9 Milburn
7 Mumford
4 Gillies
4 Mooney
3 Bartel

Most Valuable Player after Round 19

45 Ablett
44 Selwood
36 Chapman
28 S Johnson
26 Enright
25 Bartel