MVP Votes R12 vs Carlton @ ES

[Determinant]

Well, here we celebrate the best of an underwhelming bunch

5
4
3
2
1
Be at it

 

[Andre the Giant]

5 - Shiel
4 - Ward
3 - Whitfield (that 50 metre penalty though...)
2 - Davis (pure courage)
1 - Kennedy (tried very hard)

Would have given Mummy a vote but that dropped chest mark...Perryman hardly touched it but he did a couple of pressure acts at the end that nearly won it for us...love the kid.

 

[Gigantic]

5 Shiel
4 Whitfield
3 Ward
2 De Boer
1 Corr

Not many to choose from this week

 

[_GT_]

5 - Shiel
4 - Ward
3 - Corr
2 - Whitfield
1 - Kelly

Still angry

 

[Giant Strides]

Struggling to find anyone deserving this week ...

5 - Dylan Shiel: for his possessions, contested work, clearances & 2 goals
4 - Aidan Corr: stood tall in defence & had a lot of work to do
3 - Lachie Whitfield: continues to be very solid for us on the wing, great hands and good vision (mostly)
2 - Callan Ward: for his possessions, contested work, clearances & a great goal
1 - Matt de Boer: while those around him were losing their heads, I thought MDB was a steadying influence & was very solid

 

[fridgeman]

5 Shiel
4 Whitfield
3 Kelly
2 Ward
1 Corr best game I have seen him play

 

[Bokonon_]

5. Dylan Shiel
4. Lachie Whitfield
3. Callan Ward- Still think he's in a more invisible defensive role at the moment but he led from the front as always
2. Mummy- Always reliable when things aren't going well his hearts bigger than Phar Laps.
1. Matt De Boer- On effort mostly, but also a steadying influence I thought. He's not a gifted player but he's no bludger.

 

[kulak]

5 - Kelly - was our only midfielder who played both offence and defence
4 - Whitfield - all round contributor
3 - Shiel - dominant in the clearances
2 - Greene - despite poor finishing, was our only forward who consistently looked like winning a contest
1 - Corr - stout defence

 

[Raymann]

5. SHIEL
4. WHITFIELD
3. KELLY
2. WILLIAMS
1. CORR

 

[Determinant]

Vastly different viewpoint for me than normal for votes, I'm normally either at home or high enough in the stands to see what's happening.
This week we sat on the boundary line behind the posts and relied on Sports Ears for information, no way I'm watching a replay so here goes

5 Whitfield - Seemed to be the key in most links that worked.
4 Shiel - Extractor humungous
3 Corr - With Phil hobbling for 3 quarters Apples well and truly stood up
2 Kelly - Wasn't as prolific as normal, but his defensive work appeared outstanding and head and shoulders above any other mid on ground from either side
1 MDB - Never though I'd be typing this in, but his effort was unquestionable.

FWIW Marchbank would have got 5 if he hadn't swapped jumpers.

 

[Drummond]

Can I vote? If so…

5. Shiel. Awesome. 2 goals, 32 possessions, 8 clearances, started like a machine and pretty much continued all day.
4. Corr. Thought he was the standout in defence. Can’t recall him losing too many contests, and also had it 17 times and went at 88%. Great game.
3. Whitfield. Certainly elevated his game to new levels. Winning more of the ball, and more contested footy. 11 score involvements; his workrate was huge.
2. Mumford. Thought he was the main reason behind the midfield domination, continuously gave first use.
1. Kelly. Not quite as damaging, and a few uncharacteristic misses in front of goal prevented him from having a better game.

 

[Determinant]

Can I vote? If so…

5. Shiel. Awesome. 2 goals, 32 possessions, 8 clearances, started like a machine and pretty much continued all day.
4. Corr. Thought he was the standout in defence. Can’t recall him losing too many contests, and also had it 17 times and went at 88%. Great game.
3. Whitfield. Certainly elevated his game to new levels. Winning more of the ball, and more contested footy. 11 score involvements; his workrate was huge.
2. Mumford. Thought he was the main reason behind the midfield domination, continuously gave first use.
1. Kelly. Not quite as damaging, and a few uncharacteristic misses in front of goal prevented him from having a better game.

For sure, anyone with an exposed interest/following of the team is welcome to

 

[Determinant]

Bumping for last votes

 

[Andre the Giant]

5. Dylan Shiel
4. Lachie Whitfield
3. Callan Ward- Still think he's in a more invisible defensive role at the moment but he led from the front as always
4. Mummy- Always reliable when things aren't going well his hearts bigger than Phar Laps.
5. Matt De Boer- On effort mostly, but also a steadying influence I thought. He's not a gifted player but he's no bludger.

Is that the FIFA voting scale Bokonon?

 

[Colonial]

Is that the FIFA voting scale Bokonon?

Think he had some help from PJ Gallaghers and their Guinness.

Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk

 

[Bokonon_]

Is that the FIFA voting scale Bokonon?

Just a simple screw up. Will edit