Votes v Collingwood

[macca23]

Thought I'd get a thread started. Back with mine shortly.

 

[AngelEyes]

struggling with votes this week.


BOG
5. Hart (We missed you!)
4. Stenglein
3. Riccuito
2. Hudson
1. Begley (until he left us)

BTM
3. Hart
2. Martin Mattner (Dont kill me for this guys, but I thought he played real well. great tackle on Rocca in the first quarter)
1. Stenglein

Rookie
Hayden Skipworth

and McLeod and Welsh, please wake up now!

 

[sapaul]

POTY

5-McGregor
4-Clarke
3-Hart
2-Bock
1-Begley

TTM

3-McGregor
2-Begley
1-Hart

Rookie

1-Bock

 

[MarksGirl-kbcrowgirl]

I seriously don't think I can give votes.

Nobody deserves them. I would be dishonest if I praised any of them tonight.

sorry.

k
xx

 

[Nige_Bix]

Originally posted by MarksGirl-kbcrowgirl
I seriously don't think I can give votes.

Nobody deserves them. I would be dishonest if I praised any of them tonight.

sorry.

k
xx

Ditto - especially as I missed the 1st 20 minutes - which obviously was the best part. A couple of ports might sway me otherwise!

 

[macca23]

POTY

5. McGregor - IMO without a doubt our best at CHB. Gave Rocca a hiding.
4. Hart - welcome return by a genuine top-liner.
3. Edwards - very skilful and one of the few that can hit a target.
2. Mcleod - once again showed glimpses of the old Mcleod. Unaccountable at times.
1. Stenglein - worked hard in the clinches.


Best Team Man

3. McGregor - see above
2. Begley - excellent until injured - gave dash and used the ball well.
1. Hart - welcome back champ

Rookie

Nearly gave it to Bock who played several roles including CHF for a while and wasn't disgraced.

1. Hentschel - good game at HB and can actually kick to a team-mate.

 

[Stiffy_18]

POTY

5. McGregor - BOG by FAR
4. Hart - played loose across the HB and was influencial but got his pants pulled down by Tarrant
3. Edwards - probably his best game for the year
2. Mcleod - I am struggling now
1. Hudson - Gives his heart and soul


Best Team Man

3. McGregor - see above
2. Bassett - did a reasonable job on Tarrant before injuring his ankle.
1. Hart - see above

Rookie

1. Bock - liked his game up forward. Does need to tidy up his disposal but he did present which was encouraging.

 

[tribey]

POTY

5. Hart - Serenity now!!! What a ****ful game to return to.
4. McGregor - Grug was good
3. Ricciuto - Looked stuffed, was he ill?
2. Johncock - Faded in and out but tried hard forward and back.
1. Edwards - Was decent.


Best Team Man

3. Carey - 33 years old, no help from team mates, never gave up.
2. McGregor - See above
1. Hart - See above

Rookie

1. Bock - Attacked the ball like a trojan, kicked his obligatory goal.

 

[Sezza_20]

At least you lot didn't sit at telstra dome watching that s*** like me!!

I'm not giving votes either. You guys are getting really desperate with some of yours!!

Best players: Edwards, Hart, Doughty, McLeod and Bassett was ok and thats it.

Disposal was woeful by everyone. Forwards were CRAP!!

Jericho was way better than Bock (he's so slow)

McGregor made too many mistakes to be in the best and Roo was really disappointing. Stenglein's disposal was crap too.

Umpires made us look good at the start.

Ouch.

 

[tribey]

Originally posted by Sezza_20
Best players: Edwards, Hart, Doughty, McLeod and Bassett was ok and thats it.

How many bloody "compromising position" polaroids does Dogga have in his keeping?!!!!

 

[-WWJD-]

Look, I know I said after the Showdown that I'd be happy if we didn't win another game for the year...but I was obviously joking boys. Come on...

POTY

5. Hart
4. McGregor
3. Ricciuto
2. Edwards
1. Stenglein


Best Team Man

3. Hart
2. Carey
1. McGregor

Rookie

1. Bock

 

[Sezza_20]

Dyertribe!

I'm not a huge fan of Doughty but I thought he did ok tonight (well thats what I thought watching the game live).

I was surprised he came straight back into the team - he must have a few of the same photos that Marty Mattner has!! This weeks team selection was a joke.

 

[MarksGirl-kbcrowgirl]

Originally posted by dyertribe
How many bloody "compromising position" polaroids does Dogga have in his keeping?!!!!

there is somebody else on this board you should be asking about that.......not Sarah! hahaha

k
xx

 

[MRobbo]

Very Poor Performance last night by the boys I hope things improve for next weeks game against the Hawks.

POTY

5. McGregor
4. Ricciuto
3. Hart
2. Edwards
1. Stenglein


Best Team Man

3. Hart
2. Carey
1. McGregor

Rookie

1. Bock

 

[noddy]

Even when we was 5 goals up i had the feeling we would end up 2nd best once again.

POTY

5. McGregor
4. Hart
3. Ricciuto
2. Hentschel
1. Stenglein


Best Team Man

3. McGregor
2. Carey
1. McLeod

Rookie

1. Bock

 

[Bockchoy67]

I was there, and it was an extremely dissapointing game by all accounts. No real heart, no real confidence, and no real guts. Only a few players stood out...

Player of the Year

5. Hart - Gave contests, disposed very well, and was a shining light for our woeful side. Great to have him back.

4. McGregor - Pretty much dominated Rocca. Kept tight on his opponent and played an important part in our game.

3. Hentschel - Played one of his best games for the season. Disposed well, contested well and took some very good marks.

2. McLeod - Our best midfielder last night, showed some of his natural brilliance. However, his delivery into the forward line was not too good. Still managed 2 goals though.

1. Riccuito - Not his best game for the season, but still managed a bit of the ball. His disposal was alright, but seemed to lack aggression. Still far from disgraced.

Best Team Man

3. McGregor - see above.

2. Basset - Actually did quite well on Tarrant until he did his ankle. Pretty impressive, and a solid team effort.

1. Hudson - Received little game time but still gave his all. I believe he was actually better than Clarke in the ruck at stages of the game.

Rookie of the Year

Bock - One of his best games. Went hard at the ball and kicked a goal as well (nearly got two). His disposal was not the best under pressure but he certainly tried hard.

Just a thought, I noticed that none of my votes went to the forwards. DISGACEFUL effort by our forwards, and one of the reasons was because our delivery was also terrible.

And Scotty Welsh, pull your finger out, because you went at the ball like a fairy. You could so much better than that.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Gotta say once again how impressive was the effort of Hudson.
Was stationed at FF for only about 5 minutes, not enough to make any assessments, but I would like to see him in a KP to how he would go.

 

[macca23]

Originally posted by Wayne's-World
Gotta say once again how impressive was the effort of Hudson.
Was stationed at FF for only about 5 minutes, not enough to make any assessments, but I would like to see him in a KP to how he would go.

Once again, he had 10 possessions in 44 minutes out of 110 - exactly 40% which pro ratas to 25 disposals for a full game.

He gets a lot more of the ball than some give him credit for, and has great 2nd and 3rd efforts.

 

[Nige_Bix]

POTY
5.Hart
4.McGregor
3.Stenglein
2.Edwards
1.Roo

BTM
3.Stenglein
2.Hudson
1.Begley

R
Bock

 

[Stiffy_18]

Originally posted by Wayne's-World
Gotta say once again how impressive was the effort of Hudson.
Was stationed at FF for only about 5 minutes, not enough to make any assessments, but I would like to see him in a KP to how he would go.

Thats Huddo for you. For the game time he gets he gives 110% every time. I think it speaks volumes, when you consider who was in the ruck when we had to make a run at it to win. HUddo played his heart out. Loved it whe he kicked a goal

He is developing nicely and he will be a pretty good player once he gets a bit more experience and will be a very good number 1 ruckman for us in a couple of years.

 

[Stiffy_18]

Originally posted by macca23
Once again, he had 10 possessions in 44 minutes out of 110 - exactly 40% which pro ratas to 25 disposals for a full game.

He gets a lot more of the ball than some give him credit for, and has great 2nd and 3rd efforts.

He offers a lot more in field play than any of our ruckman and he was pretty impressive last night.

 

[conVINCEd]

POTY

5. Hart (is it just me or has he bulked up?)
4. McGregor
3. Stenlein
2. Hentschel
1. McLeod (I'm struggling here)

BTM

3. Stenglein
2. McGregor
1. abstain

ROTY

1. Hentschel

 

[Scotty's_Girl]

POTY

5. McGregor
4. Edwards
3. Hart
2. Hentschel
1. Stenglein

BTM

3. Hart
2. McGregor
1. Carey

Rookie

Hentschel

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Originally posted by Stiffy_18
Thats Huddo for you. For the game time he gets he gives 110% every time. I think it speaks volumes, when you consider who was in the ruck when we had to make a run at it to win. HUddo played his heart out. Loved it whe he kicked a goal

He is developing nicely and he will be a pretty good player once he gets a bit more experience and will be a very good number 1 ruckman for us in a couple of years.

Haven't raised this to this point, but was extremely disappointing to see Hudson kick his first goal in AFL footy, was obviously over the moon, and no-one, but no-one went to him to congtaulate him.
It was one of those moments that said alot about this team.

The next moment was when Macleod kicked the goal to put us 3 points down, with a minute to play.
Excitement, enthusisam, crowd participation - nope, I WILL SAY THE MOST FLAT, UNEMOTIONAL GAME PERIOD I HAVE SEEN and we could have still won it.

 

[Nige_Bix]

Originally posted by McLeod23
POTY

5. Hart (is it just me or has he bulked up?)

No its just that he needs a haircut