Jazny
Brownlow Medallist
- Nov 2, 2014
- 19,441
- 37,274
- AFL Club
- Tasmania
- Other Teams
- #TeamTurboChooks
Who are the most convincing ones? Let's go through their reasoning.Many genocide experts believe it IS genocide.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Who are the most convincing ones? Let's go through their reasoning.Many genocide experts believe it IS genocide.
Who are the most convincing ones? Let's go through their reasoning.
For sure that's the reason why. All that energy it takes to cite expert opinions you have already read which has formed the basis of your belief that Israel is committing genocideMate you’re talking about things people were flagging 6 months ago. It’s not new, I’m not going to handhold you and I simply don’t have the time nor energy to try.
For sure that's the reason why. All that energy it takes to cite expert opinions you have already read which has formed the basis of your belief that Israel is committing genocide
Which experts have you read? Why do you take their opinion over the experts who disagree with them?I'd suggest the expert opinions are much more accurate than hasbara and junket journalism.
But you and Zurg seem to think otherwise.
More accurately that's Francesca Albanese. She the expert you listen to?
A guess a mature debate would entail providing alternative expert opinion. What expert opinion have you referred to in this assertion? I would take any expert opinion from Israel/Israel connections with a grain of salt - it would really need to be independent expert - which for us mug punters would be hard to verify readilyMore accurately that's Francesca Albanese. She the expert you listen to?
More accurately that's Francesca Albanese. She the expert you listen to?
You shouldn't dismiss someone's argument because of where they are from or who they are connected to. It's pretty easy to do that to Francesca Albanese but I think her arguments can stand on their own if they are good enough.A guess a mature debate would entail providing alternative expert opinion. What expert opinion have you referred to in this assertion? I would take any expert opinion from Israel/Israel connections with a grain of salt - it would really need to be independent expert - which for us mug punters would be hard to verify readily
Just a quick response as just finished work and preparing dinner.You shouldn't dismiss someone's argument because of where they are from or who they are connected to. It's pretty easy to do that to Francesca Albanese but I think her arguments can stand on their own if they are good enough.
If someone is going to claim they believe Israel is committing genocide because of 'experts', I just want to see which expert they have been listening to. It's usually not hard to find experts who agree or disagree with what you want to believe on any topic. You can find climate change experts who say climate change is not caused by humans if you want to. Some people also claim to listen to experts, but then can't even tell you which experts.
I guess the more interesting question around genocide is do you guys believe Israel does not intend to just destroy Hamas, but also the Palestinian people in Gaza? And do you think they have justification for declaring war against Hamas in the first place?
Just whoever was in the thread to discuss the topic and felt like answering.Just a quick response as just finished work and preparing dinner.
Im confused to who are us guys, id love clarification on that
Yes, I want it to stop! But I don't see how Hamas can continue to be a thing. They need to surrender or at least accept the ceasefire terms asap before the full Rafah operation for the sake of the innocent civilians of Gaza.It does not matter what my thoughts are, rather what matters is mass innocent death is occuring, homelands are being destroyed... dont care about petty semi academic debate.... innocent people are being murdered at mass levels.... it needs to stop. You would agree wouldnt you
Plausible risk of genocide.
Many genocide experts believe it IS genocide.
I’m comfortable with my assessment.
I’m comfortable in not supporting Israel’s actions.
I’m comfortable in not supporting Hamas’ actions.
One of many.
Israel Not Complying with World Court Order in Genocide Case
The Israeli government has failed to comply with at least one measure in the legally binding order from the International Court of Justice, in South Africa’s genocide case.www.hrw.org
South Africa v. Israel (Genocide Convention) - Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org
What a weird warping of history. They were in Syria because they had been cleansed from Israel in the NakbaWhat did these experts have to say about the genocide of 160000 Palestinian civilians in Yarmouk over 5 years by Assad (South African ally) including withholding water, electricity & food?
As you say they are experts in genocide. Can you show me their thoughts on this genocide of Palestinians?
What did these experts have to say about the genocide of 160000 Palestinian civilians in Yarmouk over 5 years by Assad (South African ally) including withholding water, electricity & food?
As you say they are experts in genocide. Can you show me their thoughts on this genocide of Palestinians?
For sure that's the reason why. All that energy it takes to cite expert opinions you have already read which has formed the basis of your belief that Israel is committing genocide
For someone who claims to not support Hamas you seem to have be very comfortable repeating Hamas propaganda literally straight out of their playbook.
Others will confirm this.
Please cite any Hamas propaganda I've cited.
While you're at it, please cite what I've said about Hamas time and time again, in direct replies to you and others.
You're absolutely cooked mate.
Whataboutism, hasbara. Do you have any other hobbies?
Are your comfortable with the continued existence of Hamas? An actual genocidal regime that actually deliberately kills civilians and boasts about it?I'm comfortable with being opposed to this kind of stuff.
Assuming you mean Gazan civilians, how is verifiable fact "propaganda"? Israel has murdered those civilians.You have many times repeated the false claim that Israel has murdered over 30,000 Israeli civilians in Gaza.
Are your comfortable with the continued existence of Hamas? An actual genocidal regime that actually deliberately kills civilians and boasts about it?
How many times has he said Hamas needs to go? Have you read this thread? How is Hamas an "actual genocidal regime" and Israeli government is not? How many Israeli civilians has Hamas killed? How many Palestinian civilians has IDF killed? Which one is more genocidal? They both need to be tried and held accountable for war crimes, they both (Hamas and IDF/War Council) need to go.Are your comfortable with the continued existence of Hamas? An actual genocidal regime that actually deliberately kills civilians and boasts about it?
Assuming you mean Gazan civilians, how is verifiable fact "propaganda"? Israel has murdered those civilians.