Warnock for .....?

[dominguez]

There's no chance of them trading pick one. The first pick was off the table last year and Judd was involved so why trade pick one for a ruckman who has played a handful of games and pick three.

Assuming the top 3 players are hard to split the Demons will still want to make that decision rather than let 2 other clubs make the choice for them.

Rich's form hasn't been outstanding so far this year. Depending on how he goes at the champs there's a chance that he could slide to pick 4 or 5 anyway.

 

[Windas_Magic]

The only WA 'talent' you could possibly take from Essendon is Johns..The likes of Jetta, Gumby, Ryder etc aren't going anywhere and it looks like you could potentially lose Warnock in the PSD to Melbourne. He isn't worth a hell of a lot anyway, was a pick in the forties and has only shown potential and apparently his attitude hasn't been to flash either

 

[theGav56]

The only WA 'talent' you could possibly take from Essendon is Johns..The likes of Jetta, Gumby, Ryder etc aren't going anywhere and it looks like you could potentially lose Warnock in the PSD to Melbourne. He isn't worth a hell of a lot anyway, was a pick in the forties and has only shown potential and apparently his attitude hasn't been to flash either

It looks like they are contracted into the future, so the PSD does not come into play for us, but if Melbourne were suing the PSD for Warnock, then, assuming we may be looking at pick 2, we could and will do exactly the same thing if a player wants to come West.

 

[dominguez]

It looks like they are contracted into the future, so the PSD does not come into play for us, but if Melbourne were using the PSD for Warnock, then, assuming we may be looking at pick 2, we could and will do exactly the same thing if a player wants to come West.

Good point Gav. Assuming that the club have planned for Warnock and Mundy to stay and they both go we should have some cap space to play with. Would love to lure a good player from Richmond since they used the PSD as leverage when trading for Polak and Simmonds.

 

[Lach72]

Langdon was saying he's gone...has been speaking to him at footy on the road and he's dirty and is basicallly gone...

 

[dominguez]

Langdon was saying he's gone...has been speaking to him at footy on the road and he's dirty and is basicallly gone...

Lets just hope Richmond or Carlton offer him a lot more $$$$ than Melbourne.

 

[Chops_a_must]

Would love to lure a good player from Richmond

You gotta laugh when sentences like these come out.

 

[Moo]

I'd rather he walk than stay uncommitted.

I'd rather he go via the PSD than accept a pick in the 4th round.

To be honest from here on in - if you are not committed _____ off

 

[Milky]

Does anybody else think there is a big chance of Nathan Carroll returning home for Warnock?

Personally i would be happy with Carroll and a late second or early to mid third pick.

Carroll may be past it at Melbourne? im not sure

Thoughts

 

[raffrox]

Does anybody else think there is a big chance of Nathan Carroll returning home for Warnock?

Personally i would be happy with Carroll and a late second or early to mid third pick.

Carroll may be past it at Melbourne? im not sure

Thoughts

No thanks. No thanks at all. Carroll is preseason draft material at best and we want younger fellas these days.

I'd like us to target Swallow and that would be an ok trade imo.

 

[Moo]

Does anybody else think there is a big chance of Nathan Carroll returning home for Warnock?

Personally i would be happy with Carroll and a late second or early to mid third pick.

Carroll may be past it at Melbourne? im not sure

Thoughts

If the answer is Carroll ...I don't think I like the question.

A 28 year old player who is past his best (or past his average) is certainly not what our club requires.

 

[theGav56]

Good point Gav. Assuming that the club have planned for Warnock and Mundy to stay and they both go we should have some cap space to play with. Would love to lure a good player from Richmond since they used the PSD as leverage when trading for Polak and Simmonds.

Hopefully it's not the salary that ends up getting them here. At this stage it is looking very realistic that we will be absolute cellar dwellars, and while I would love to get a good deal for any player who wants to leave the club, I am also very keen that the club uses the psd in the other direction as they did with MacPharlin.

 

[Plugga]

We will get NOTHING for Warnock.

He will be out of contract & will flip thru to #1 pick in December draft to Melbourne.

Unless anotehr Victorian Club pitches something good to him - he will go to Melbourne for nothing. To be traded - HE - has to agree to the trade.

Freo knew he wasn't going to sign after this year - earlier this year & have handled the whole situation very very badly ( AS USUAL )

 

[Lach72]

We will get NOTHING for Warnock.

He will be out of contract & will flip thru to #1 pick in December draft to Melbourne.

Unless anotehr Victorian Club pitches something good to him - he will go to Melbourne for nothing. To be traded - HE - has to agree to the trade.

Freo knew he wasn't going to sign after this year - earlier this year & have handled the whole situation very very badly ( AS USUAL )

Depends...if Warnock says "Play me or I'll leave" then he should get pushed...

 

[chook2734]

We will get NOTHING for Warnock.

He will be out of contract & will flip thru to #1 pick in December draft to Melbourne.

Unless anotehr Victorian Club pitches something good to him - he will go to Melbourne for nothing. To be traded - HE - has to agree to the trade.

Freo knew he wasn't going to sign after this year - earlier this year & have handled the whole situation very very badly ( AS USUAL )

So what should they have done? Played him so he's ready to go for Melbourne round 1 next year? I'd send him back now if he wants to go. He certainly doesn't seem to be giving it 100% and I can imagine West Perth aren't exactly thrilled at having to carry him week in week out.

 

[Moo]

We will get NOTHING for Warnock.

He will be out of contract & will flip thru to #1 pick in December draft to Melbourne.

Unless anotehr Victorian Club pitches something good to him - he will go to Melbourne for nothing. To be traded - HE - has to agree to the trade.

Freo knew he wasn't going to sign after this year - earlier this year & have handled the whole situation very very badly ( AS USUAL )

As opposed to what Superstar?

 

[raffrox]

So what should they have done? Played him so he's ready to go for Melbourne round 1 next year? I'd send him back now if he wants to go. He certainly doesn't seem to be giving it 100% and I can imagine West Perth aren't exactly thrilled at having to carry him week in week out.

Play him and get his trade value up. Be totally ruthless in our favour about it.

If he stays then we spent time developing him otherwise use him and turf him.

 

[Mattlowry]

Gumbleton, Jetta and to an extent Ryder may haven't shown they will be superstars but there are very promising signs for all three.

I would imagine it would take a top 2-3 pick for Essendon to consider getting rid of Gumbeton or Ryder and a top 10 pick to get rid of Jetta. The are the future of the club and won't be going anywhere.

I'd like Warnock at Essendon. Not the best player but could definately replace Laycock in the side as numbe 2 ruckman so we could leave Ryder down back. I don't think you'll get more than a third round pick for him however.

To think how useful Bradley could be to us right now haha...

 

[bomber c]

essendon will never trade with fremantle after what they did with keplar bradley...full stop..

 

[raffrox]

essendon will never trade with fremantle after what they did with keplar bradley...full stop..

Can't believe that Essendon did that to Kepler.

Thats what you mean isn't it?

 

[dominguez]

Hopefully it's not the salary that ends up getting them here. At this stage it is looking very realistic that we will be absolute cellar dwellars, and while I would love to get a good deal for any player who wants to leave the club, I am also very keen that the club uses the psd in the other direction as they did with MacPharlin.

Yeah fair enough. We're going to have to trade out one or possibly two players to have the cap space to lure a player of any ability to the club though.

 

[Chops_a_must]

If Warnock does want to go to Melbourne, just play him as our number 1 ruck, spare Sandi.

Just get the ____er injured.

If we aren't gonna get anything for him, at least expose the twig to some breeze.

 

[bomber c]

Can't believe that Essendon did that to Kepler.

Thats what you mean isn't it?

no harvey and shaw promised 3rd round pick then reneged on the last minute deal at the trade table...
you got him for nothing...
taught us a lesson we never will forget...
good luck to keps ,i am glad he is doing the job...

 

[dominguez]

We will get NOTHING for Warnock.

He will be out of contract & will flip thru to #1 pick in December draft to Melbourne.

Unless anotehr Victorian Club pitches something good to him - he will go to Melbourne for nothing. To be traded - HE - has to agree to the trade.

Freo knew he wasn't going to sign after this year - earlier this year & have handled the whole situation very very badly ( AS USUAL )

It sounds like the obvious option for Melbourne but how often does it happen? I can't think of any talented players who got to their club of choice through the PSD after their new club refused to discuss a trade with their old club.

The PSD isn't until December. Melbourne can either trade something for Warnock in the 2nd week of October or leave him in limbo for two months.

Melbourne will offer their 3rd round pick (probably pick 35).

 

[dominguez]

Does anybody else think there is a big chance of Nathan Carroll returning home for Warnock?

Personally i would be happy with Carroll and a late second or early to mid third pick.

Carroll may be past it at Melbourne? im not sure

Thoughts