Westhoff V Gibbs

[SWANNIES RULE]

Both play in different positions, so this isn't really a direct comparison.

But in general, who will be the better player in the future. Were at opposite ends in the draft, but Westhoff is looking just as good, if not better than Gibbs at the moment.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Gibbs.. Only a bandwagoning twat who has NFI about AFL would think otherwise.

 

[WatWouldCyrilDo]

Gibbs.. Only a bandwagoning twat who has NFI about AFL would think otherwise.

Was gonna vote gibbs but i am a bandwagoning twat so guess u made up my mind for me

 

[Stormer]

Gibbs.

 

[parrot]

Couldn't be bothered voting. Gibbs is the best #1 pick we've seen in the last 25 years. Strange poll.

 

[Lets Roar like '44]

Couldn't be bothered voting. Gibbs is the best #1 pick we've seen in the last 25 years. Strange poll.

Cant be serious surely, another carlton dud, saw him duck his head 3 times in one game earler in the year, good traid bait after next year.

 

[Stifler's mom]

Westhoff easily. Marty Clarke is a better player than Gibbs is now and he's only been kicking a footy for less than a year.
Westhoff = gun
Gibbs = rolled up newspaper.

I guess Carlton supporters are entitled to be angry about another early pick failure. cough* Kennedy* cough.

I think Kenny Rogers coward of the county was penned in Bryce's "honour"

 

[Stokes-Selwood-Prismall]

Couldn't be bothered voting. Gibbs is the best #1 pick we've seen in the last 25 years. Strange poll.

w***er!
murphy?????????????????

 

[parrot]

.... Marty Clarke is a...

Clarke looks like an Irish Shaw. Strange, round thing, with ordinary skills. Was actually throwing the ball yesterday. Had to laugh. The quality of the Pies younger players is pretty low at the moment. Take out Pendlebury, and it's a bit of a talent wasteland.

 

[Pancakes]

Westhoff easily, I'd rather a kpp forward who in his first season can kick 2-3 each game, rather than a spud who struggles in a BP.

Westhoff is just one of about 20 players of last years draft who will be much better than Gibbs.

 

[didaka]

Clarke looks like an Irish Shaw. Strange, round thing, with ordinary skills. Was actually throwing the ball yesterday. Had to laugh. The quality of the Pies younger players is pretty low at the moment. Take out Pendlebury, and it's a bit of a talent wasteland.

Whose list are you on???

 

[borgy]

Gibbs was pick 1 for a reason....Westhoff was 60 something for a reason.

Who has shown more so far? Westhoff with ease.

Who will be better long term? Gibbs no doubt.

Also Westhoff is 2 or 3 years older than Gibbs.

 

[SWANNIES RULE]

Gibbs.. Only a bandwagoning twat who has NFI about AFL would think otherwise.

Well it looks like more than half the people on this site are bandwagoning twats who have NFI about AFL.

 

[blues4flag]

Well it looks like more than half the people on this site are bandwagoning twats who have NFI about AFL.

No surprises here.

Gibbs, while not playing as good as Westhoff, is without the better prospect. Westhoff has a good future ahead of him, but Gibbs is a very, very special kid.

 

[WatWouldCyrilDo]

Gibbs was pick 1 for a reason....Westhoff was 60 something for a reason.

Who has shown more so far? Westhoff with ease.

Who will be better long term? Gibbs no doubt.

Also Westhoff is 2 or 3 years older than Gibbs.

Hird was 70 something.
Whats your point?

 

[Jeremias]

Gibbs is 2-3 years younger than Westhoff.

We are very happy with Gibbs, and all you saying that Westhoff is better are either delusional or complete morons.

 

[Monkeyboy]

Offer 14 clubs the choice of either, and all would take Gibbs in a heartbeat.
I do like Westoff however. Very nice player.
Also can't vote due to rediculousness of comparison.

 

[Silvagnis]

I wouldn't give back any of our picks in the 2006 draft to take Westhoff.

Not one of them.

 

[gandaal]

This is why recruiters don't listen to idiots from Bigfooty when they draft players

 

[gandaal]

I wouldn't give back any of our picks in the 2006 draft to take Westhoff.

Not one of them.

Neither would I. Benjamin is probably the only one I'd even consider and he was always going to be a long term prospect.

 

[Silvagnis]

Neither would I. Benjamin is probably the only one I'd even consider and he was always going to be a long term prospect.

Hampson and Austin will be better than Westhoff at 21, so we had no need to draft another athletic tall at the expense of two players who have legspeed.

Our list is still top heavy.

I'm rapt we picked Joe Anderson ahead of Westhoff.

Joey is hard as nails and won Darwin's senior B & F at just 18.

Gun.

 

[DonMania#5]

Gibbs will come good soon.

 

[SWANNIES RULE]

Gibbs will come good soon.

That's what Fremantle fans said about Clive Waterhouse.

 

[trueblue_91]

That's what Fremantle fans said about Clive Waterhouse.

Waterhouse was destroyed by injuries. Would have been a gun player

 

[SWANNIES RULE]

Waterhouse was destroyed by injuries. Would have been a gun player

Yeah I do agree somewhat.