Roast We've got the season wrong and it needs to change now

Remove this Banner Ad

Sep 22, 2011
40,744
88,391
Your girlfriend's dreams
AFL Club
Essendon
Interesting day at the MCG today. 74k baked in the sun in 29deg weather. If you're unfortunate enough to be on the southern side of the ground, it's certainly not comfortable in direct sunlight. In fact, it's downright unhealthy given what medical science now knows.

Out on the field, the last quarter was marked by player, after player, after player going down with cramp. It certainly affected the contest. Player fatigue was obviously greater as well, and the capping of interchange in recent years means they get less rest.

Elsewhere across the country, tens and tens of thousands of footballers were engaged in full-scale practice matches. State and community level seasons start in April, which means the full dress rehearsals must be held in March. Plenty of heatstroke and sunburn for the masses as they were cooked in the oven-like temperatures.

I actually don't quite know why it started... it'll be way back in the annals of history somewhere. But footy was always April to September, and cricket was October to March. That's simply how ground tenancies were split.

And over the decades and centuries, for whatever reason, footy has (with a few minor exceptions) remained absolutely glued to vacating on the last Saturday in September.

The AFL has grown into a bigger and bigger beast in that time. in 2024 it's reached another peak. With a four-week finals series, a pre-finals bye for all clubs, the addition of Gather Round, and now the addition of Opening Round, this year's AFL season takes place across 30 weeks.

As we're stubbornly stuck to the last Saturday in September, things just keep getting earlier.

We started on the 7th of March. The AFL are very lucky that Opening Round didn't include Melbourne, where it was 38deg on every day of the long weekend.

It's simple... it's too hot.

Footy was not meant to be played in this heat. It impacts the game and the athletes. Moreso in this era of non-stop running for all positions.

It's terrible for the fans. Moreso in this era of huge, concrete bowl stadiums with little shade and reserved seats. In the flexibility of yesteryear, you might seek shade. Not now. You're crammed in, in direct sunlight with nowhere to go. Absolutely perfect for discomfort, dehydration, sunburn and skin cancer.

People will simply stay home.

Across the bush and the suburbs, footy is increasingly professionalised in the way it's played, but without the medical technology and on-hand care that they have at the elite level. Players swelter in the conditions.

The bottom line...

We really have to stop playing footy in March.

Here's the BOM monthly median temperatures by capital cities for the 1991-2020 dataset.

MelbSydBrisAdelPerth
Jan
27​
27​
30.4​
30​
31.4​
Feb
26.9​
26.8​
30.2​
29.7​
31.7​
Mar
24.6​
25.7​
29.2​
26.6​
29.6​
Apr
21.1​
23.6​
27.2​
23​
25.9​
May
17.6​
20.9​
24.5​
19​
22.3​
Jun
15.1​
18.3​
22.1​
16.2​
19.4​
Jul
14.5​
17.9​
22​
15.6​
18.5​
Aug
15.9​
19.3​
23.4​
16.7​
19.1​
Sep
18.1​
21.6​
25.7​
19.3​
20.6​
Oct
20.5​
23.2​
27.1​
22.5​
23.4​
Nov
22.9​
24.2​
28.3​
25.4​
26.8​
Dec
24.8​
25.7​
29.6​
27​
29.5​

The solution? Pretty simple really... we have to just push everything back by a month.

In Melbourne, where most games are played, the Oct median temp is 4.1deg lower in October than it is in March. That's a huge difference.

In Adelaide it's also 4.1deg. In Sydney it's 2.5deg. Brisbane 2.1deg.

It Perth it's 6.2deg!

The median temp in Perth in March is 29.6deg! In Brisbane it's 29.2.

You cannot play good football in these temperatures. The players suffer, the spectacle suffers, the fans suffer.

It all needs to go back by a month. Finish at the end of October. Start a month later. Better footy, bigger and happier crowds, healthier fans, healthier players.

A far more enjoyable game to play and watch - and it has to be enjoyable for the future of the game.

It makes no difference to cricket - they lose a month at the start and gain one at the end. International cricket tours don't start until late November anyway, and they're increasingly focused on the Big Bash which is in January.

At state and local levels, it just goes back by a month too. Footy is May to October, Cricket is November to April. Same six months each.

You know it makes sense.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Interesting day at the MCG today. 74k baked in the sun in 29deg weather. If you're unfortunate enough to be on the southern side of the ground, it's certainly not comfortable in direct sunlight. In fact, it's downright unhealthy given what medical science now knows.

Out on the field, the last quarter was marked by player, after player, after player going down with cramp. It certainly affected the contest. Player fatigue was obviously greater as well, and the capping of interchange in recent years means they get less rest.

Elsewhere across the country, tens and tens of thousands of footballers were engaged in full-scale practice matches. State and community level seasons start in April, which means the full dress rehearsals must be held in March. Plenty of heatstroke and sunburn for the masses as they were cooked in the oven-like temperatures.

I actually don't quite know why it started... it'll be way back in the annals of history somewhere. But footy was always April to September, and cricket was October to March. That's simply how ground tenancies were split.

And over the decades and centuries, for whatever reason, footy has (with a few minor exceptions) remained absolutely glued to vacating on the last Saturday in September.

The AFL has grown into a bigger and bigger beast in that time. in 2024 it's reached another peak. With a four-week finals series, a pre-finals bye for all clubs, the addition of Gather Round, and now the addition of Opening Round, this year's AFL season takes place across 30 weeks.

As we're stubbornly stuck to the last Saturday in September, things just keep getting earlier.

We started on the 7th of March. The AFL are very lucky that Opening Round didn't include Melbourne, where it was 38deg on every day of the long weekend.

It's simple... it's too hot.

Footy was not meant to be played in this heat. It impacts the game and the athletes. Moreso in this era of non-stop running for all positions.

It's terrible for the fans. Moreso in this era of huge, concrete bowl stadiums with little shade and reserved seats. In the flexibility of yesteryear, you might seek shade. Not now. You're crammed in, in direct sunlight with nowhere to go. Absolutely perfect for discomfort, dehydration, sunburn and skin cancer.

People will simply stay home.

Across the bush and the suburbs, footy is increasingly professionalised in the way it's played, but without the medical technology and on-hand care that they have at the elite level. Players swelter in the conditions.

The bottom line...

We really have to stop playing footy in March.

Here's the BOM monthly median temperatures by capital cities for the 1991-2020 dataset.

MelbSydBrisAdelPerth
Jan
27​
27​
30.4​
30​
31.4​
Feb
26.9​
26.8​
30.2​
29.7​
31.7​
Mar
24.6​
25.7​
29.2​
26.6​
29.6​
Apr
21.1​
23.6​
27.2​
23​
25.9​
May
17.6​
20.9​
24.5​
19​
22.3​
Jun
15.1​
18.3​
22.1​
16.2​
19.4​
Jul
14.5​
17.9​
22​
15.6​
18.5​
Aug
15.9​
19.3​
23.4​
16.7​
19.1​
Sep
18.1​
21.6​
25.7​
19.3​
20.6​
Oct
20.5​
23.2​
27.1​
22.5​
23.4​
Nov
22.9​
24.2​
28.3​
25.4​
26.8​
Dec
24.8​
25.7​
29.6​
27​
29.5​

The solution? Pretty simple really... we have to just push everything back by a month.

In Melbourne, where most games are played, the Oct median temp is 4.1deg lower in October than it is in March. That's a huge difference.

In Adelaide it's also 4.1deg. In Sydney it's 2.5deg. Brisbane 2.1deg.

It Perth it's 6.2deg!

The median temp in Perth in March is 29.6deg! In Brisbane it's 29.2.

You cannot play good football in these temperatures. The players suffer, the spectacle suffers, the fans suffer.

It all needs to go back by a month. Finish at the end of October. Start a month later. Better footy, bigger and happier crowds, healthier fans, healthier players.

A far more enjoyable game to play and watch - and it has to be enjoyable for the future of the game.

It makes no difference to cricket - they lose a month at the start and gain one at the end. International cricket tours don't start until late November anyway, and they're increasingly focused on the Big Bash which is in January.

At state and local levels, it just goes back by a month too. Footy is May to October, Cricket is November to April. Same six months each.

You know it makes sense.

Are the grounds even available at the end of October? Did you check?
 
74k baked in the sun in 29deg weather. If you're unfortunate enough to be on the southern side of the ground, it's certainly not comfortable in direct sunlight. In fact, it's downright unhealthy given what medical science now knows.
Thanks Dr Nick.
Given I spent today watching local cricket in this heat I will see my GP on Monday to see what day this week I am expected to die.

/Sarcasm

Harden the * up.
 
Ignore the haters OP. I'm 💯 with you.

That's a massive difference in average temperature for Melbourne between March and October . That data speaks for itself.

It's still bloody monsoon season in Qld.

Still beach weather in Vic

Still cricket season (Shield Final is next week).

Footy season used to start after Shield Final but now the AFL is trying "compete" with other sports

All this early hot summer start does is leave us with absolutely * all to do in October and November unless you think the "spring carnival" is really a thing .

And the weather in Melbourne in October is usually pretty s**t so might as well go and watch footy.
 
Went to the round 1 Giants-Crows game at Olympic Park last year in near-40 degree heat. Most extraordinary conditions I’ve ever seen at a footy game. It was basically impossible to sit in the direct sunlight (thankfully the ground staff saw sense and turned a blind eye to people sneaking up into more expensive grandstand seating in the shade) so to this day I still have no idea how the players were able to run out a game of football in it.

The existing heat policy probably needs to be reviewed because it really isn’t adequate for matches starting as early as March. Measures like extra time during breaks and extra water carriers are nothing compared to some of the extreme heat measures other sports have put in place.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Ignore the haters OP. I'm 💯 with you.

That's a massive difference in average temperature for Melbourne between March and October . That data speaks for itself.

It's still bloody monsoon season in Qld.

Still beach weather in Vic

Still cricket season (Shield Final is next week).

Footy season used to start after Shield Final but now the AFL is trying "compete" with other sports

All this early hot summer start does is leave us with absolutely * all to do in October and November unless you think the "spring carnival" is really a thing .

And the weather in Melbourne in October is usually pretty s**t so might as well go and watch footy.

They’re not necessarily haters, they just often excel at totally missing the point and are happy to not even look at cold, hard data, preferring to use “their own knowledge” from one isolated thing that they themselves happened to witness.

March is comfortably the fourth-hottest month of the year. In some cities where we play it’s the third hottest. Football is better played in cooler conditions. It’s better for the players, the product and the supporters.

We could make a change that would work for all parties.

The horsie set would go off their collectives if the footy season was extended well into October.

They need to push back a month too. This might make them do it.
 
Most people did the smart thing and sat in one of the 50,000 shaded seats rather than baking in the sun.

No they didn’t. They sat where their seat was.

I already addressed it. It’s not 1985. Between huge members reserves (half the ground at the MCG), season seat holders and buying a reserved seat ticket weeks before the game, that’s just not the case.
 
Selfishly I'm well and truly footy starved by February I don't want to wait until April.

However I do agree that hot weather, particularly humid weather.
Can ruin the spectacle of games.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top