would you do this change?

[thomo]

Adelaide- Ian Perrie and Nathan Van Berlo (both Western Australians)

4

Fremantle- Matthew Pavlich and Byron Schammer (Both South Australians)

 

[Punchy Bassett]

Yes.

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

I would be very reluctant to trade VB, I just think it would baf form seeing we are crying out for our interstaters to stay so if we then trade a player who seems intent on staying then I think it would be a touch hpocritical.

Personally I do not think Pavlich is the be all and end all for the Crows like it once was.

 

[Southerntakeover]

No, Van Berlo is a legend.

Besides, the money Pavlich would want would force other players out our team.

 

[Gets!]

Yep Pav isn't THAT good.

 

[rayven]

Sorry but I consider the last time Pav played us at AAMI he was making a statement.

The bloke would straighten us up big time and with him at CHF our other forwards when fit would thrive.

 

[CrowMagnum]

a trade made in heaven (for us) but not even Freo are that stupid

 

[GrandfinalGurus]

a trade made in heaven (for us) but not even Freo are that stupid

Not anymore......surely you would hope after the well documented email that circulated last year of their trading blunders!

 

[Crow-mo]

you got be kidding, we'd bite their hand off if they even thought of offering that.

we'd take it everyday and 19 times on sunday.

 

[Stiffy_18]

a trade made in heaven (for us) but not even Freo are that stupid

Well said

 

[Jeremias]

of course adelaide would take it. if freo accepted it however, they would be the worst traders in the competition (as if they aren't already...)

 

[Crowked]

Adelaide- Ian Perrie and Nathan Van Berlo (both Western Australians)

4

Fremantle- Matthew Pavlich and Byron Schammer (Both South Australians)

Yes, but Freo would have for brains to go with that.

As much as I like Perrie, as he is a good, solid, honest trier, he isnt worth Pavlich's jock strap in the trade market to be blunt. I'd rate Pav as a top 10 player in the AFL, while Perrie would rate outside the top 50, maybe even outside the top 100.

Shammer and VanBerlo are pretty close on trade value and could perhaps be considered as a fair trade though. Personally though, I like VB and would keep him.

If we are going after Pav, Freo might consider Perrie and Van Berlo for him, but you can forget any added bonuses like Shammer, they just wouldnt be that silly. Not even Freo with their history of trade blunders would be that silly.

 

[Markthirtytwo]

Let's not tell them until the transfer is done and dusted.

 

[PrideOf]

I'm sure if this trade was on the table, one of our poor cousins down the road would ring them and tell them it wasn't a good deal.