2015 Trade Hypotheticals

[pinot]

two weeks into pre season when the whips are cracking his finger would be pulled out. all it takes is one heart to heart with senior coach before 1st day of pre season. it is really that simple or you just haven't been in a football environment.

 

[coxy149]

Ryan shoenmakers and hawks 2nd round pick for David zaharkis?

 

[telsor]

two weeks into pre season when the whips are cracking his finger would be pulled out. all it takes is one heart to heart with senior coach before 1st day of pre season. it is really that simple or you just haven't been in a football environment.

Yeah, because is efforts during the year really show that....

 

[PK WCE]

Scott Selwood to Geelong.

Then that first round compensation and maybe a later pick for Redden..

fair?

 

[AusMC]

Scott Selwood to Geelong.

Then that first round compensation and maybe a later pick for Redden..

fair?

I didn't think teams got a compensation pick if they claimed a free agent in the same period?

 

[Milanista28]

Ryan shoenmakers and hawks 2nd round pick for David zaharkis?

I wouldn't do it, Zaka adds much needed class to our side, He'll bounce back, like a lot of our better players once the WADA cloud is gone.

 

[blueiris]

I didn't think teams got a compensation pick if they claimed a free agent in the same period?

Redden isn't a free agent until next year and is still contracted

 

[Milanista28]

Pick 4, 22 and Carlisle for Pick 1 and 19?

 

[blueiris]

Pick 4, 22 and Carlisle for Pick 1 and 19?

Carlton could just get Carlisle in the PSD

 

[Hipster Doofus]

Pick 4, 22 and Carlisle for Pick 1 and 19?

You're severely overrating Carlisle here, his 2015 season was pathetic.

 

[kingkingston]

You're severely overrating Carlisle here, his 2015 season was pathetic.

he didn't have a bad season, just that he was alternating from the forward and backlines far too much. His last 6 games were good

 

[Here we go dogs]

Pick 4, 22 and Carlisle for Pick 1 and 19?

Probably a fair deal, but this year it sounds like the top 2 players are miles better than the rest. Sounds like all teams are reluctant to trade much for Carslisle when he should be worth around the pick 7 to 10 mark for me

 

[BRAB]

Carlisle is pretty rare. AFL ready KPP.

He'd almost be worth the first rounder for a team who has come 3rd or below (Schache and Weitering are probably better prospects then him)

 

[Milanista28]

Probably a fair deal, but this year it sounds like the top 2 players are miles better than the rest. Sounds like all teams are reluctant to trade much for Carslisle when he should be worth around the pick 7 to 10 mark for me

I would take Dogs 1st rounder for him that's for sure. And would pay 150k of his future wage if the Saints or Blues didn't improve their offers.

 

[SABlue]

Pick 4, 22 and Carlisle for Pick 1 and 19?

Nah.

 

[Milanista28]

Nah.

Fair enough that's why this is a good thread.

 

[Kony Abbott]

Richmond incompetent to land a big fish. They won't get Yarran... they will haggle and haggle until someone else comes along..like Swans that have $450k cleared on salary cap to swoop him away. They need Shaw replaced.

Did I stumble upon the VFL trade thread ? Because it sounds like you suggest yarran is a big fish.

 

[pinot]

Did I stumble upon the VFL trade thread ? Because it sounds like you suggest yarran is a big fish.

Yaz is a top player.

Yaz as 19 year old

 

[kingkingston]

Yaz is a top player.

Yaz as 19 year old

he was 20 in those highlights

 

[coxy149]

Carlisle,zaharkis and Essendon 4th round pick to the hawks for shoenmakers and our first and third round pick maybe another player?

 

[Vindicater]

Carlisle,zaharkis and Essendon 4th round pick to the hawks for shoenmakers and our first and third round pick maybe another player?

 

[slowedawg]

Carlisle,zaharkis and Essendon 4th round pick to the hawks for shoenmakers and our first and third round pick maybe another player?

Why not ask for Daniher and Heppell as well? Ridiculous.

 

[BPikkers]

You're severely overrating Carlisle here, his 2015 season was pathetic.

And he has a real grubby look about him....dirty.
I think he is over-rated. Sons are best getting rid of him. Seems to be a whinger as well.

 

[Cringle]

Pick 4, 22 and Carlisle for Pick 1 and 19?

I rate Carlilse highly and feel draft picks are being overrated relative to proven performers. However Carlton won't trade out pick 1 knowing we'll get Weitering.

Is a mid first rounder what you're expecting for Carlilse straight swap... Or more inclined to upgrade into the first few picks with St Kilda?

 

[Murraj1966]

3rd Rounder and Pick 25 for Freeman and 27