List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

[The Royal Sampler]

It'd take us the next 50 years to work out exactly who got the best deal out of the trade.

Pfffft, BigFooty always knows same day.

 

[Pedro]

Langdon Brown Williams
Maynard Reid Scharenburg
Treloar Adams Sidebottom
Grundy Pendlebury Greenwood
Swan Cloke DeGoey
Elliott Dixon Motlop

Varcoe Crisp Moore Witts

That team would go alright

Ins: Treloar, Dixon, Motlop

Outs: ?????

 

[NT.Thunder]

Ins: Treloar, Dixon, Motlop

Outs: ?????

Sharenberg, Witts, JT and Keefe

 

[Prochard123]

Sharenberg, Witts, JT and Keefe

Dont think Sharenberg will go to any of GWS Geelong or GC. If he ends up going to adelaide, that means we most likely will get Dangerfield in return

 

[ThePhantom777]

Dont think Sharenberg will go to any of GWS Geelong or GC. If he ends up going to adelaide, that means we most likely will get Dangerfield in return

Would you trade Shaz for Danger?

 

[PicaBoo]

Dont think Sharenberg will go to any of GWS Geelong or GC. If he ends up going to adelaide, that means we most likely will get Dangerfield in return

Or part of a multi club deal. Danger is going somewhere else and Adelaide want someone in return. How that is orchestrated, doesn't need to be just the 2 clubs directly involved.

 

[NT.Thunder]

Would you trade Shaz for Danger?

 

[Prochard123]

Would you trade Shaz for Danger?

Yes I would. Im sure Shaz is more valuable to Adelaide than whatever Geelong will offer them.
We also have a plethora of those halfbacks and inside clearance mid with burst is clearly a huge deficiency and is one of the most influential roles in the game.
As talented as Scharenberg is, I would happily trade away his upside for a top 5 mid in the game.

 

[ThePhantom777]

Do we have the salary cap space to get Danger and Treloar? Would we need both? I don't think there is a KPF available worth paying the cash for (Dixon is rubbish IMO).

 

[iGNITER]

Do we have the salary cap space to get Danger and Treloar? Would we need both? I don't think there is a KPF available worth paying the cash for (Dixon is rubbish IMO).

Just go for Treloar and Motlop.

 

[ThePhantom777]

Just go for Treloar and Motlop.

That would be very nice. Hopefully we have the right mix of draft picks and players to satisfy.

 

[iGNITER]

That would be very nice. Hopefully we have the right mix of draft picks and players to satisfy.

Can always hope.

However I think our main priority is Treloar and we will negotiate with GWS on it, hopefully giving up our first and second round picks for this year as a best case scenario.

 

[Old Spice]

Can always hope.

However I think our main priority is Treloar and we will negotiate with GWS on it, hopefully giving up our first and second round picks for this year as a best case scenario.

Reckon we should be using the Beams trade as the benchmark.

 

[iGNITER]

Reckon we should be using the Beams trade as the benchmark.

So first and second round picks plus steak knives. Depending on the steak knives I could live with that.
Really depends on who GWS would want.

 

[Old Spice]

So first and second round picks plus steak knives. Depending on the steak knives I could live with that.
Really depends on who GWS would want.

That's what I'd be arguing, but this whole future pick trading might make it hard.

 

[ThePhantom777]

Reckon we should be using the Beams trade as the benchmark.

Beams was a bit more established than Treloar though. Premiership player 2010 at age 20, Copeland Winner and All-Australian at age 22.

 

[Anzacday]

Beams was a bit more established than Treloar though. Premiership player 2010 at age 20, Copeland Winner and All-Australian at age 22.

And contracted

 

[Old Spice]

Beams was a bit more established than Treloar though. Premiership player 2010 at age 20, Copeland Winner and All-Australian at age 22.

Which should work in our favour, arguably. But of course it's all about knocking a deal together with Graham Allan.

 

[Kappa]

Which should work in our favour, arguably. But of course it's all about knocking a deal together with Graham Allan.

A hard man to get a good deal out of unfortunately...

 

[Old Spice]

A hard man to get a good deal out of unfortunately...

Yeah. He'll be picking our pockets. We could always play 'Ball' if they get too outlandish.

 

[Pedro]

Sharenberg, Witts, JT and Keefe

Really? How much would you be willing to hand over for JT and Keeffe? They aren't worth a cold crumpet in their current predicament

 

[NT.Thunder]

Really? How much would you be willing to hand over for JT and Keeffe? They aren't worth a cold crumpet in their current predicament

That's just who I think does have some value, whether as steak knives or alone that could be out from rumours floating around boards.

 

[Buena]

Beams was a bit more established than Treloar though. Premiership player 2010 at age 20, Copeland Winner and All-Australian at age 22.

And contracted

These are the reasons we shouldn't have to give up both 1st and 2nd round picks, as well as a player. Treloar is tracking really nicely, but he's not an All Australian, premiership winning, Copeland trophy holding contracted player.

I'd be happy with a 1st rounder, and 2nd rounder at maximum. Ideally for us to be spread across 2 years.

 

[TradeDraft]

Sharenberg, Witts, JT and Keefe

All 3 have the Potential of Leaving

 

[TradeDraft]

Matthew Scharenberg, Collingwood, out of contract
The South Australian has yet to re-sign amid speculation he has struggled to settle in Victoria since Collingwood claimed him with pick No.6 in the 2013 national draft. The 191cm utility is a special talent and the Pies remain confident he will stay, but rumours persist he will seek a trade to Adelaide or Port Adelaide.

So is this still a Possibility that we will Trade Scharanberg?

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-07-30/staying-or-going-this-years-afl-exchange-period-previewed