Think his name is Marc Shmurf 3, or something like that?
List Mgmt. 2016 Free Agency/Trades/Draft thread Part 2
- Thread starter King Elvis
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
If its just our first rounder start the car.
Obviously you havent seen Gibbs play in the last few years.
- Moderator
- #9,904
Yeah, thats the general consensus. Those in the know say its almost def B/S.
Personally, I reckon there sounds like there could be a trickle of truth in this one though.
My view re any trade starts at the assumption that we wont be a flag chance till 2020 at the earliest, so retaining over 26 year old players is a little pointless (barring having enough experience around the club to avoid what happened with Melbourne).
- Sep 19, 2015
- 2,529
- 1,705
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Exactly and betts has became a game winner in the right team/environment
- Oct 6, 2012
- 13,003
- 25,588
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
I swear Rowie and Bicks trawl here.
I've seen a few times people quote stuff Rowie has said on the radio that has copied verbatim stuff that I've posted eg earlier this year when Brouch was coming back I said on here "you don't run your group 1s in the country". Later that night someone quoted Rowie saying exactly the same thing (exact same terminology) on the radio that night. This has happened more than once over the years.
Hes had a kid and justin reid is our list manager and likes bringing south australians home
Would getting Gibbs and Hartlett and keeping our 1st round pick be considered a win?
I know its not what I would call a big fish but both would add enormous depth to the midfield and would add a new dynamic mix that combined probably would allow us to take that next step.
I know its not what I would call a big fish but both would add enormous depth to the midfield and would add a new dynamic mix that combined probably would allow us to take that next step.
Bryce had a baby and his wife is from Adelaide. Apparently wants to move back home to be close to family.
Familiar story? Hopefully we can be on the right side for once.
- Sep 19, 2015
- 2,529
- 1,705
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
When we are talking match winner is that not a good indication of Brownlow votes? As being in the best 3 on the ground
Gibbs snagged 13 or 14 votes this year in a crap team with another good mid in Cripps in there with him
Sloaney is a jet and stepped up this Yr to get 24
But last year Sloane got 4 votes and the year before 10 votes
And we know the caliber of him
Get Gibbs and Rocky and we are a very very good team
Gibbs snagged 13 or 14 votes this year in a crap team with another good mid in Cripps in there with him
Sloaney is a jet and stepped up this Yr to get 24
But last year Sloane got 4 votes and the year before 10 votes
And we know the caliber of him
Get Gibbs and Rocky and we are a very very good team
We will be giving up our first if we are getting Gibbs.
TexForPM
Premiership Player
Last edited:
- Jun 10, 2009
- 29,795
- 44,888
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Panthers, GWV Rebels Beaufort Crows
That's the problem...this year's draft is probably the most even in years with depth in good prospective midfielders in particular probably up to late 2nd round .....next year looks to be even better with some standout talls available and SA in particular looks very strong with some really prospective prodigious talent in Callum Coleman-Jones, Darcy Fogarty, Nathan Kreuger, Lachlan Pascoe, Jackson Edwards, Andrew McPherson, Isaac Hewson and Tom Schmusch to name but a few.
TSR ......that logic makes no sense at all .....signs a 4 year longterm contract, club is obviously on the up and being well coached and managed, so Gibbs says "i'm outta here"
I'm sure as a Free Agent we enquired about Gibbs last season
I don't accept illogical arguments
Gibbs is contracted player and in this case it is not the player or the destination club that hold the cards
Like GWS last year Carlton don't have to trade and I doubt Gibbs will return home and step out of footy
If we want Gibbs it will cost us in a trade, if you can't understand this logic then I can't help you
The Blues will expect Pick 13 and next year's first. Three years left on the contract. Senior player. B&F two year's ago.
Pick 13 + fringe will get laughed out of the room.
Pick 13 + fringe will get laughed out of the room.
Bacon8
Cancelled
Two years ago.TSR ......that logic makes no sense at all .....signs a 4 year longterm contract, club is obviously on the up and being well coached and managed, so Gibbs says "i'm outta here"
I'm sure as a Free Agent we enquired about Gibbs last season
I don't accept illogical arguments
Bacon8
Cancelled
If they want 14, go talk to Hawthorn .
They wont be stupid it works for Carlton's age profile to trade him
13 + Lyons sounds painful for both teams and i would do the deal.
- Status
Similar threads
- Poll
