I love the way some posters use the "Ed didn't want Bucks to go to North" line as though that in itself was some driving factor in the succession plan. I don't think you can say it had zero bearing but the bizarre suggestion here is that Mick was pushed specifically to make space for Bucks. The simple truth is that Mick was washed up. The board wanted him out as did a large percentage of the fans. He was increasingly being seen as "Mr Almost" with a bad attitude and that was the prime mover for the succession plan. Eddie still insists that it was Mick who said he was finding it increasingly difficult to keep going. The fact that Bucks was available and highly regarded if a bit raw was little more than serendipity in terms of what evolved in Eddie's and the board's heads.
I also find the suggestion that Mick can be absolved for his decision to sign a contract and later renege to be absolutely ridiculous. The suggestion in that is that both he and his manager are 5 year old children who don't know their own minds. Clearly I believe that the club did not do due diligence in the matter but as far as I'm concerned that is just as true of Mick.
A/ Although not official it is highly likely that Ed did not want Bucks to go to North, that would be difficult to argue against
B/ To say that the truth was that MM was washed up is not, it is speculation unless of course you know him personally and he told you as much or you were in the same room when he told Eddie he was not coping - speculation. I'd argue that if the board wanted him gone it is not necessarily a correct position and may have been proven otherwise
C/ Don't think you'd find many who'd agree that MM should be absolved on the way he reacted, if you are thinking I'm saying this in my post that would be incorrect. I was merely making an observation that he reacted poorly because he thought he was hard done by in the "plan"
D/ Nail, hammer, head - MM and the club have a lot to answer for. The writing was on the wall when you could visually see MM get his nose out of joint, this plan was never ever ever going to succeed. The poor schlep who has had to take pot shots from all comers because of it is Nathan, and still shows to be the consummate professional
Lastly, although it would be bad pr I'd like the club to come out and publicly admit fault and apologize to us - that would be satisfying, however I know they won't and know they shouldn't.
Way to p*** your fans off Collingwood