Verdun
Premium Gold
- Oct 16, 2011
- 4,694
- 8,189
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Righto - some discussion kicked off last night on which is the better team 2005 (Plugger) v everyone else 2009. Are there others besides Plugger who rate the 2005 side over the 2009 team? Which team is better??
We seem to be drifting off in the vicious circle of discussing politics which does not have nuance, think it would be good to bring it back to footy even if it is from the past.
Took me a while to find the team lists (might have had one or two many glasses of Jameson whisky last night but here they are below:
2005:
B Baker Penny Hudghton
HB Jones Maguire Voss
C X.Clarke Ball Goddard
HF Hamill Riewoldt Dal Santo
F Milne Gehrig Guerra
Foll: Koschitzke, Hayes, Harvey
Inter: Powell, Thompson, Blake, Fiora
ARRIVALS Cain Ackland, James Gwilt, Mark McGough, Andrew McQualter (all 2004 National Draft), Aaron Fiora (traded, from Richmond), Dylan Pfitzner, Nick Stone (from rookie list)
DEPARTURES Heath Black (traded, to Fremantle), Craig Callaghan (retired), Josh Houlihan, Trent Knobel, Brett Moyle, Daniel Wulf (all delisted).
2009: (Grand Final Team):
ST. KILDA
B: Blake Dawson Baker
HB: Goddard Fisher Gilbert
C: Ray Hayes Dal Santo
HF: McQualter Koschitzke Jones
F: Milne Riewoldt Gram
Foll: King Montagna Schneider
I/C: Ball Raphael Clarke Dempster Gardiner
Emg: Armitage Geary Gwilt
We seem to be drifting off in the vicious circle of discussing politics which does not have nuance, think it would be good to bring it back to footy even if it is from the past.
Took me a while to find the team lists (might have had one or two many glasses of Jameson whisky last night but here they are below:
2005:
B Baker Penny Hudghton
HB Jones Maguire Voss
C X.Clarke Ball Goddard
HF Hamill Riewoldt Dal Santo
F Milne Gehrig Guerra
Foll: Koschitzke, Hayes, Harvey
Inter: Powell, Thompson, Blake, Fiora
ARRIVALS Cain Ackland, James Gwilt, Mark McGough, Andrew McQualter (all 2004 National Draft), Aaron Fiora (traded, from Richmond), Dylan Pfitzner, Nick Stone (from rookie list)
DEPARTURES Heath Black (traded, to Fremantle), Craig Callaghan (retired), Josh Houlihan, Trent Knobel, Brett Moyle, Daniel Wulf (all delisted).
2009: (Grand Final Team):
ST. KILDA
B: Blake Dawson Baker
HB: Goddard Fisher Gilbert
C: Ray Hayes Dal Santo
HF: McQualter Koschitzke Jones
F: Milne Riewoldt Gram
Foll: King Montagna Schneider
I/C: Ball Raphael Clarke Dempster Gardiner
Emg: Armitage Geary Gwilt
Last edited: