I’d rather keep players I enjoy watching, unless the offer is too good to refuse. I’ve always loved watching Elliot and last week reaffirmed he still has it. Sidey unfortunately just isn’t as exciting these days.
Absolutely from a personal preference point of view.... you want to be entertained. But that’s not how list management works.
At the end of the day Elliott and Sidebottom are likely to be far more valuable to Collingwood than they will be to other teams. I suspect they will both be at Collingwood next year