SNFL Div 1 discussion 2022

[bullzo1234]

Cranbourne vs city

- who do you have ?

- and why ?

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Cranbourne vs city

- who do you have ?

- and why ?

Interesting game, Cranny should be too strong on experience and form and I haven't seen many games but from reports Swan has been the main driver for Citys form and will be a huge loss, They managed well against Dingley without Fevola so not sure that will be much of a loss, Magner has come back in and will pick up extra load, City have strong depth of 20-23yo that have come out of there successful 19s program which will provide the run and pace that will worry Cranbourne.

 

[sammelb80]

Interesting game, Cranny should be too strong on experience and form and I haven't seen many games but from reports Swan has been the main driver for Citys form and will be a huge loss, They managed well against Dingley without Fevola so not sure that will be much of a loss, Magner has come back in and will pick up extra load, City have strong depth of 20-23yo that have come out of there successful 19s program which will provide the run and pace that will worry Cranbourne.

City have had this never say die attitude and belief this finals series, no Swan is a big loss but Edwards is tearing it up at Linton St.
Though Cranbourne are just very solid. Leaning towards Cranbourne although I do hope City win so we could potentially see a Fev and Swan grand final, would be one for the ages.

 

[Gobbler]

City have had this never say die attitude and belief this finals series, no Swan is a big loss but Edwards is tearing it up at Linton St.
Though Cranbourne are just very solid. Leaning towards Cranbourne although I do hope City win so we could potentially see a Fev and Swan grand final, would be one for the ages.

Yeah it’s been the city “2nd stringers“ that have been so impressive and were great against my doggies.

Really impressed the way they run and play .
If the can contain holt and Dickson then it could be City v Chelt

 

[footymad_17]

Key match ups
Kelm v boland
DeGois v Holt
Cochrane v Dickson
Edwards v Osborne
Potts v Carosella
Andrews v Roscoe

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

With Fevola out with Hoy be tempted to throw DeGois forward?? Arguably the best full back in the comp but can also be a dangerous forward..

 

[footymad_17]

With Fevola out with Hoy be tempted to throw DeGois forward?? Arguably the best full back in the comp but can also be a dangerous forward..

Would be a big call to make. Has beaten holt twice this season. Irving didnt play fwd last time vs cranbourne either. What are the chances fev doesnt play?

Side not. B. Osborne by far the best FB in the comp

 

[bullzo1234]

I’m hearing the following

Swan - out
Fevola - out
Magner - out

Going to be a tough day for city with those 3 out .

If you were a bookie you would be giving 4-1 for city to win

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Would be a monuments coaching performance by Ryan Hoy is city can get chokies with those 3 out.

 

[bullzo1234]

Would be a monuments coaching performance by Ryan Hoy is city can get chokies with those 3 out.

Listened to him last week, he spoke very well , lifted his boys at 3 qtr time .

Only blemish I feel is he gets very emotional

 

[bedford]

Listened to him last week, he spoke very well , lifted his boys at 3 qtr time .

Only blemish I feel is he gets very emotional

Did nothing for me when i heard him after they lost to St Pauls

 

[DangerousD]

Does anyone know what happened to Liam Sumner

Liam Sumner

Age

32

Ht

178cm

Wt

74kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

8.8

2star

K

5.4

2star

HB

3.4

3star

M

2.2

2star

T

2.4

4star

G

0.6

4star

No current season stats available

D

11.6

3star

K

6.2

3star

HB

5.4

4star

M

2.4

3star

T

3.2

5star

G

0.8

4star

playing for St Paul’s this year? Every time I checked he didn’t seem to be playing.

Swan and Fev missing todays game was big, would have liked them to miss last week, but that’s footy.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Just checked results and looks like poor kicking for goal cost City.

 

[gotherosellas]

St kilda city dominated most areas of the game nearly all thete goals were kickable. They were very hard at it but could not convert inside 50. Cranbourne are very skillful and will need a dry deck to compete with Cheltenham.

 

[bullzo1234]

City dominated the whole game !

Poor kicking cost them big time !

But the two best teams for the season will play off

Chelt to do Cranbourne by 10 goals plus

 

[Mr north man]

Any news on the possibility of Bonbeach and Chelsea coming into the SFNL in 2023? Or to early to tell

 

[Wild Thing]

Any news on the possibility of Bonbeach and Chelsea coming into the SFNL in 2023? Or to early to tell

Bonbeach are playing off in MPNFL D1 GF (lot higher standard than this league)…..so have no reason on coming across here. Chelsea on the other hand have been treading water for quite some time now….doubt they move across especially with main rivals Edi Asp in D2 next year but you never know

 

[Greg Tivendale]

Well so much for the great st pauls coach up by heaps playing against city without a bench…….hmmm

Harry Hunt missing due to concussion from the week before was a huge loss for the team, but all credit to City I thought they were cooked and they rallied hard.

 

[Greg Tivendale]

Does anyone know what happened to Liam Sumner playing for St Paul’s this year? Every time I checked he didn’t seem to be playing.

Swan and Fev missing todays game was big, would have liked them to miss last week, but that’s footy.

Did some damage to his knee about 5 rounds out before end of season. Finally gave it in last round as was struggling to get around.

 

[DangerousD]

Well so much for the great st pauls coach up by heaps playing against city without a bench…….hmmm

Teams with good coaches still lose football matches.

 

[bullzo1234]

what crap coming out of dingley ,

I know first hand ades was sacked as coach.

He was fully committed to retire as a player and focus on coaching the club .

Dingley showing there true colours .

Sacking a coach in his first full season at the club !

I thought dingley were better than that

 

[2s Hack]

what crap coming out of dingley ,

I know first hand ades was sacked as coach.

He was fully committed to retire as a player and focus on coaching the club .

Dingley showing there true colours .

Sacking a coach in his first full season at the club !

I thought dingley were better than that

They must have someone REALLY good lined up then

 

[whowantstoknow]

They must have someone REALLY good lined up then

Yea yeates from port colts

 

[batfink]

St kilda city dominated most areas of the game nearly all thete goals were kickable. They were very hard at it but could not convert inside 50. Cranbourne are very skillful and will need a dry deck to compete with Cheltenham.

They have a roof at Moorabbin?

 

[gotherosellas]

They have a roof at Moorabbin?

I was not there today but full credit to cranbourne they were lucky to win last weekend but got the job done. Must have been a great game today well done cranny and back to the drawing board for Cheltenham the drought continues!!