Autopsy Round 10 - West Coast v St Kilda

[saintbill]

Top 5 pick at lest. NAS possibly gone, could have 2 top 10 picks.

Maybe one day we will get lucky and draft a few players so good that even our poor player development can't stuff them up.

 

[Ads734]

Despicable performance

Guys who held their heads high

Ro
Wilkie
Sincs
Higgins

The rest piss poor.

Just so bad. No composure. No willingness to chase. Terrible tackling efforts.

Just so poor.

Brad hill


The umpiring - disgusting

We are playing seriously bad football. It’s becoming a habit with this squad where we have weekend of just pure shite

 

[Sarcoidevo]

Have we ever won a game under our Euro Yroke name?

 

[Dr Spaceman]

 

[Teflon]

Never been a rip up membership guy always thought that was poor
Pay 4 a year for last 30 years - I’m only one who goes now
Tonight first time I’ve thought seriously what is the point of this ?
So embarrassing to hand the shittest team in AFL their first win
So embarrassing to watch a side who lack basic skills and clearly train running over actual skills …
So embarrassing to watch no one at the club ask the question of condition and fitness when AGAIN pre season derailed by injuries
So embarrassing to watch a VFL side destroy development of young kids
So embarrassing watch a side refuse to show up to Spuds game against a side barely going
It’s time to face truths - I don’t care if we beat GC ….week later we’ll be shit again and promoting Jones etc who are taking us nowhere
It’s engrained we are shit

 

[Mowman]

Be happy if Steele and Hill never play another game for us

 

[Sir Owens]

Not surprised by the loss. Eagles are an improved team from previous seasons and are hard to beat at home.

This team is going nowhere and we desperately need high draft picks. Sick of finishing mid-table. Play the kids and tank for the rest of the year.

O’Connell has to play every game going forward. Really like the look of him.

 

[Saintos The ITK]

We’re gonna end up with pick in a heavily compromised draft aren’t we.
Then Tasmania will kick in and we won’t be able to catch up for another years will we

 

[Ricmel]

Just fold. Put us all out of our misery. I've put up with it for decades.

At least if they fold we could legitimately select a new team….no stigma.

Currently at least a rebuild and 7 years from a flag. More likely another 7 or 8 rebuilds and 60 years.

 

[Browny2Carlisle]

Steele should never be near the midfield again.
No selection integrity. Instead we make stupid team selections each week. Box dropped. Nas mid when he’s the most elite half back in the comp. Gus in for some reason. No tall forward. We use Owens in the middle to try save us in the last but refuse to any other time.
Hill just running around giving the opposition goals
Byrnes

 

[Veer Right]

My nice version summary of todays game

Brains and heart

Marshall
Sinclair
Higgins
Wilkie
O'Connell

Also didn't mind Pou with his interrupted season. Hall gets a pass.

7/23 players

 

[Sol Goodman]

It's hard to watch the team that beat Geelong and Port a few weeks ago and compare them to this. I know there's something to be said for a young team being inconsistent, but this is almost bi-polar levels of up and down.

Its just hard to understand. It's not like the coaches can go out there and do it for them but why the inconsistency in effort. And is it even that easy an explanation. It looks like that. Just confused.

 

[Pakenhamsaint]

We’re gonna end up with pick in a heavily compromised draft aren’t we.
Then Tasmania will kick in and we won’t be able to catch up for another years will we

We are going to decide to proper rebuild when tassie rock up.
It's the classic St Kilda ****up

 

[MVallence90]

McClennan selection just as diabolical as it seemed

Substitution could mirror a delisting I think. 4 years on the list and won't make it.

We have higher profile names in that basket. Marcus Windhager the biggest one, must be played 100% pure tagger if he's picked. Just doesn't have another string to his bow.

Brad Hill while I'm sure a much loved club man, has been gifted the worst contract in football. 3 years, he shouldn't play another 3 games. Toby should play his spot for the remainder of the year. Hill has played 112 games for us, and he's played maybe 12 good ones.

Bravo Jack Higgins, the rest, even Sinclair and Marshall who's stats look okay, just unacceptable on every level. This West Coast side is all-time bad...and you still couldn't beat them.

Please just bottom out properly. We so desperately need top end midfield talent. Don't win meaningless Marvel games at the back end of the year when not in finals contention.

 

[Saintos The ITK]

Never been a rip up membership guy always thought that was poor
Pay 4 a year for last 30 years - I’m only one who goes now
Tonight first time I’ve thought seriously what is the point of this ?
So embarrassing to hand the shittest team in AFL their first win
So embarrassing to watch a side who lack basic skills and clearly train running over actual skills …
So embarrassing to watch no one at the club ask the question of condition and fitness when AGAIN pre season derailed by injuries
So embarrassing to watch a VFL side destroy development of young kids
So embarrassing watch a side refuse to show up to Spuds game against a side barely going
It’s time to face truths - I don’t care if we beat GC ….week later we’ll be shit again and promoting Jones etc who are taking us nowhere
It’s engrained we are shit

I’ll be a member til the day I die.

 

[gringo2011]

Be happy if Steele and Hill never play another game for us

Yeah, both leaders who look like they can't be ****ed. Been defending Hill but he looks like it's time to take him out to pasture. Travaglia would offer more.

 

[cowboy18]

It's getting increasingly difficult to see the light at the end of the tunnel with this football club.

 

[Ads734]

Oh and Trav came and tried.

 

[Ricmel]

I would like a top 3 draft pick please.

We need about 5 of them.

 

[hangdog]

I'm over it

 

[Ads734]

I’ve been a huge Steele protector but Wilkie needs to captain or at least share

 

[Sully111]

Nas isn't our best player... Jack Higgins is.

Macrae's disposal was poor at times... so was Sinclair's.... sorry.... but it was.

Hill... FMD

Well done Liam

We're wasting Mitch Owens. Should have been a mid.... trained as a mid... from the start. But that's what we do, because we're stupid.

Under Ross v2 we've played some of the worst football in the competition.

Skills and composure, skills and composure... we hasn't gots it. Why the f*ck not? Are all our players just so shit that collectively we can't use the ball.... or is there a possibility that the coaching has something to do with it?

Enough... seriously.... enough.

I'm going to contact the club this week and tell them what I think. Will it do any good? No... but f*ck 'em.

 

[Browny2Carlisle]

Can’t wait to keep getting hbf
Eagles rebuild has overtaken ours now too

 

[Teflon]

We’re gonna end up with pick in a heavily compromised draft aren’t we.
Then Tasmania will kick in and we won’t be able to catch up for another years will we

No chance
Our culture will kick in and we’ll beat Lions by 1 point on siren to guarantee a pick outside any midfield quality
It’s the Saints thing to do then wonder why we are shit!!

 

[Teflon]

I’ll be a member til the day I die.

Good luck with that