2012 SC Rucks

[toxic]

Wanted to bring in the mullet but Tom derickx inclusion has me worried about job/point sharing

 

[footyfan_25]

Wanted to bring in the mullet but Tom derickx inclusion has me worried about job/point sharing

Don't think Derickx has been playing ruck. Will probably be used fwd or back.

 

[footyfan_25]

Anyone heard about the Mummy? Is he looking ok at the moment, I am wanting to trade Sandi for him. Can anyone suggest why I should or shouldnt get him?

Cheers

Anyone else think this is the week to bring in Mummy??

Only concern is he seems to be playing fwd a lot more more Pyke spending more time in the ruck. It was his 40+ hitouts that got the massive scores last year.

 

[MRB37]

Anyone else think this is the week to bring in Mummy??

Only concern is he seems to be playing fwd a lot more more Pyke spending more time in the ruck. It was his 40+ hitouts that got the massive scores last year.

I thought about it, but I decided to go with McEvoy this week instead.

 

[UpTheGuts]

Ryder out for 4-6 weeks....

 

[rocker_oz33]

Peoples thoughts on jamar?

 

[Hawthorn United]

Giles has been rested.

 

[rocker_oz33]

That works for me might keep him seeing he wont go down in price.Hope mummy has a stinker in the west and swap giles for mummy next week ........................>hopefully.

 

[dlanod]

Peoples thoughts on jamar?

Risky first week back from injury. I'd hold off if you can.

 

[UpTheGuts]

Jamar out for 4+. Wouldn't surprise if he was mothballed.

So, last ruck. Cox a bit too pricey.

Jacobs
Maric
McEvoy

which one?

 

[toxic]

Jamar out for 4+. Wouldn't surprise if he was mothballed.

So, last ruck. Cox a bit too pricey.

Jacobs
Maric
McEvoy

which one?

McEvoy - had his mid year rest - saints fighting for a spot in the 8 and the only ruckman of any real ability at StKilda, ticks all 3 boxes in picking players from here on in IMHO

 

[UpTheGuts]

McEvoy - had his mid year rest - saints fighting for a spot in the 8 and the only ruckman of any real ability at StKilda, ticks all 3 boxes in picking players from here on in IMHO

Cheers for that. I think you're right. Close call, though

 

[Cudi]

I'm liking the look of Jacobs upgrade and Giles out. Adelaide have a soft draw home espically with Bris, Melb and GC in the last 3 weeks, makes him look very enticing.

 

[UpTheGuts]

I'm liking the look of Jacobs upgrade and Giles out. Adelaide have a soft draw home espically with Bris, Melb and GC in the last 3 weeks, makes him look very enticing.

Also makes a rest more likely. I think Sanderson said they would look to adjust his workload in coming weeks.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Also makes a rest more likely. I think Sanderson said they would look to adjust his workload in coming weeks.

Yep a agree with this but not really happy with sauce getting a rest since i have him.

 

[toxic]

Also makes a rest more likely. I think Sanderson said they would look to adjust his workload in coming weeks.

True - just makes McEvoy even more enticing

 

[Zim^zuM]

Also makes a rest more likely. I think Sanderson said they would look to adjust his workload in coming weeks.

The way it's going the top 4 will still be up in the air for the final round and % could be the difference between a home or away final. I don't think too many fit players would be in contention for a rest.

 

[footyfan_25]

Goldstein looking like a very tempting upgrade for Giles (despute his 112 this week don't trust him as my 2nd ruck come finals).

Only concern with Goldstein is the last round vs GWS ... Nth might use that as a chance to give him a rest before finals and get a game into McIntosh.

Thoughts?

 

[MightyMark]

Goldstein looking like a very tempting upgrade for Giles (despute his 112 this week don't trust him as my 2nd ruck come finals).

Only concern with Goldstein is the last round vs GWS ... Nth might use that as a chance to give him a rest before finals and get a game into McIntosh.

Thoughts?

I'd be careful with Goldstein, simply because HMac is due back in the next week or so. Goldy is flying now, but HMac is certain to eat into his points, same as he did during the start of the year.

 

[footyfan_25]

I'd be careful with Goldstein, simply because HMac is due back in the next week or so. Goldy is flying now, but HMac is certain to eat into his points, same as he did during the start of the year.

Scott earlier in the week did say the Hmac will only come back into the team as a fwd. Not sure how much to believe about that, but was interesting to read.

 

[MightyMark]

Scott earlier in the week did say the Hmac will only come back into the team as a fwd. Not sure how much to believe about that, but was interesting to read.

I didn't read that, but if true its a bonus for those with Goldstein, but wont be well received by those with Petrie.

 

[Super Hans]

Roughead is really doing well for me, great unique for finals.

 

[MightyMark]

I think just having 2 premium rucks this year could be unique, after the carnage half of us have suffered at the hand of injured ruckmen.

 

[footyfan_25]

Goldstein, NicNat or Mumford the 3 i'm look at as an upgrade for Giles ... just need to decide if the approx 100k saving on Mumford could be better used elsewhere.

Thoughts on Goldstein vs NicNat ??

 

[Jock]

Mummy looks 2 b just perfect going into the finals for Giles, rested, cheap and we know he can go big.