2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[Hairy Lager]

Cripps

L Neale also for me, Cockatoo V Boekhorst

Newton v Cripps

 

[MightyDons4]

Cockatoo ($177k) + $38k vs. Newton ($215k)

Cocky

Midfield depth at Melbourne means Newton is a couple under par games from being dropped/made sub.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Cocky

Midfield depth at Melbourne means Newton is a couple under par games from being dropped/made sub.

Good, I went this way.

 

[kangaroos3]

Racking my brain over mid price defenders..
Need to decide on 2 out of; KK, Pittard or Ibbo

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Racking my brain over mid price defenders..
Need to decide on 2 out of; KK, Pittard or Ibbo

KK, Ibbo for me... Albeit Ibbo being a risk.

All 3 are the main mid-price defenders I considered.

I also really reckon Savage will have a great year and should be considered.

 

[kangaroos3]

KK, Ibbo for me... Albeit Ibbo being a risk.

All 3 are the main mid-price defenders I considered.

I also really reckon Savage will have a great year and should be considered.

Yeah Savage was probably the next in line for me to chose from

 

[SnappyHappy]

Mumford/Cripps/Pittard
v
Mumford/Neale/Dalgleish
v
Naitanui/Neale/T.Hunt
v
Naitanui/JPK/Dalgleish

 

[toxic]

Mumford/Cripps/Pittard
v
Mumford/Neale/Dalgleish
v
Naitanui/Neale/T.Hunt
v
Naitanui/JPK/Dalgleish

Option 4

 

[SimplySublime]

Newton v Cripps

I'm having this same dilemma, Cocky, Newton or Cripps?

I don't know much about Cocky but have read the hype, I'm just really concerned about # of games.

He's much cheaper than Cripps but Cripps should play week in week out, however won't score too highly..

I've got no idea.

 

[toxic]

I'm having this same dilemma, Cocky, Newton or Cripps?

I don't know much about Cocky but have read the hype, I'm just really concerned about # of games.

He's much cheaper than Cripps but Cripps should play week in week out, however won't score too highly..

I've got no idea.

Cripps of the 3, however id prefer a sub 145k rookie fwiw

mine

in Def:
D4
KK versus jaksch from the blues

that extra 120k does amazing things when i try it

Gingy TheOz

thoughts on Jaksch

 

[Super Hans]

Mumford and Dangerfield
vs
Goldy and JPK/Sloane

 

[Hairy Lager]

I'm having this same dilemma, Cocky, Newton or Cripps?

I don't know much about Cocky but have read the hype, I'm just really concerned about # of games.

He's much cheaper than Cripps but Cripps should play week in week out, however won't score too highly..

I've got no idea.

Ok how about this Boekhorst v Cripps v Cockatoo v Newton
What are your thoughts on the first two, vest risks, potential earnings etc.
I'm thinking Sheed could be a good option to consider V Cripps also

 

[Hairy Lager]

Mumford and Dangerfield
vs
Goldy and JPK/Sloane

Mummy, Danger option for me.

 

[Lums23]

Damn it.

That's exactly my line up.

+1

 

[toxic]

Mumford and Dangerfield
vs
Goldy and JPK/Sloane

Goldy and sloane

 

[Krujan]

Cripps of the 3, however id prefer a sub 145k rookie fwiw

mine

in Def:
D4
KK versus jaksch from the blues

that extra 120k does amazing things when i try it

Gingy TheOz

thoughts on Jaksch

I'm not sure if Jaksch is in our best 22 yet. Probably isn't, at this stage. Competing with guys like White & Watson as the 3rd tall down back.

 

[MightyMark]

Cocky

Midfield depth at Melbourne means Newton is a couple under par games from being dropped/made sub.

Cocky will have the same problem. Geelong will drop him as soon as he looks out of place, they wont push rookies unless they really have too.

 

[TheOz]

Cripps of the 3, however id prefer a sub 145k rookie fwiw

mine

in Def:
D4
KK versus jaksch from the blues

that extra 120k does amazing things when i try it

Gingy TheOz

thoughts on Jaksch

I'm not sure if Jaksch is in our best 22 yet. Probably isn't, at this stage. Competing with guys like White & Watson as the 3rd tall down back.

I disagree, Jaksch was recruited to be played straight away in our backline and based on is preseason form, he is going to excel. Watson has been used up in the forward line during intra-club practice games and could be played down there, and White pinch hit a bit in the forwards too in our last game. I would play him ahead of White and Watson anyway.

 

[MightyMark]

Juggle my team with the possible absence of Ablett.

Gray and Prestia

vs.

Fyfe and Goddard

Currently running Fyfe and Goddard, but have some concerns over how Goddard might go if he has to carry the team.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Beams v JPK v Parker - in order

 

[SnappyHappy]

Juggle my team with the possible absence of Ablett.

Gray and Prestia

vs.

Fyfe and Goddard

Currently running Fyfe and Goddard, but have some concerns over how Goddard might go if he has to carry the team.

If Ablett doesn't play I like Gray & Prestia - Prestia handled a tag well last year when Ablett was out could be a top 10 mid in his absence.

 

[MightyMark]

If Ablett doesn't play I like Gray & Prestia - Prestia handled a tag well last year when Ablett was out could be a top 10 mid in his absence.

Thanks,

But i've kinda gone half way, I got Fyfe, dropped Goddard in the forwards for another rookie, and brought in Prestia.

Would swap out Prestia for Heppel if it wasn;t for this Essendon saga, alot of people dont seem to rate him but i reckon given the chance he would go huge this year.

Hoping another year shortens the gap between Prestia's highs and lows.

 

[Lums23]

Thanks,

But i've kinda gone half way, I got Fyfe, dropped Goddard in the forwards for another rookie, and brought in Prestia.

Would swap out Prestia for Heppel if it wasn;t for this Essendon saga, alot of people dont seem to rate him but i reckon given the chance he would go huge this year.

Hoping another year shortens the gap between Prestia's highs and lows.

Heppel was in my first team until I remembered the saga

 

[toxic]

I disagree, Jaksch was recruited to be played straight away in our backline and based on is preseason form, he is going to excel. Watson has been used up in the forward line during intra-club practice games and could be played down there, and White pinch hit a bit in the forwards too in our last game. I would play him ahead of White and Watson anyway.

what scores would you expect from him?

my goal is to make 150K from him if chosen

 

[toxic]

Beams v JPK v Parker - in order

for total points
JPK, Parker, Beams

for value
Parker, JPK, Beams