Analysis 2016 Draft...

[Scorpus]

Okay, question for you all - who would you prefer out of Cumming and Gallucci?

The one that isn't a defender

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Yeah could be right, it does seem like we prefer others though, no-one has us going for Cox. Can never say for sure.

Yeah that could be why he was invited, Twomey did say that Syd have interest in Cumming. Could happen, they need zip badly.

Honestly can not pick it at this stage, but if I had to say one, I'd say Gallucci. If Berry got past WCE, I'd say him.

I'd put money on Galluci too after GWS matching bid for Cumming first

If they had been stripped of picks we'd end up with Cumming

 

[Bicks]

Reckon he's clutching at straws a bit too this time !!

We need Matty Burgan back, bugger Melbourne FC giving him a job as their Media man!!

 

[Hank93]

Brett Anderson made the point clubs are being far more secretive, so a lot of these predictions could be way off.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

The one that isn't a defender

Cumming is a wing / half back ... Ditto Cox

They are natural outside mids being used as half backs , a bit like Brodie Smith in that regard

 

[Scorpus]

Cumming is a wing / half back ... Ditto Cox

They are natural outside mids being used as half backs , a bit like Brodie Smith in that regard

Still not interested. We have strong depth in both half back and pure outside midfield positions

 

[Bicks]

Cumming is a wing / half back ... Ditto Cox

They are natural outside mids being used as half backs , a bit like Brodie Smith in that regard

I really hate using 1st Round picks on guys that aren't really adept at winning their own ball, you can have all the upside you like but if they can't win their own ball consistently leave me out.

 

[StonesThrow]

Whoever we chose that hasn't been rated to 10, 1 thing is for sure, there will be hoards that will write him off straight away.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Still not interested. We have strong depth in both half back and pure outside midfield positions

Fair enough but just explaining what he does

I agree with you for what it's worth , drums are beating and I think it's on . Just gotta hope GWS match

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I really hate using 1st Round picks on guys that aren't really adept at winning their own ball, you can have all the upside you like but if they can't win their own ball consistently leave me out.

He lacks competitiveness which goes against recent drafting history and is very interesting

Think it shows that maybe we are changing tack for what we think our list needs

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

I really hate using 1st Round picks on guys that aren't really adept at winning their own ball, you can have all the upside you like but if they can't win their own ball consistently leave me out.

IMO Pykey would share the same view

 

[Bicks]

He lacks competitiveness which goes against recent drafting history and is very interesting

Think it shows that maybe we are changing tack for what we think our list needs

Obviously they've not been watching the Bulldogs the last 2 years if that's the case, the majority of their youngsters are adept at winning their own ball along with having a bit of pace...That's where we should be heading IMO...

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Obviously they've not been watching the Bulldogs the last 2 years if that's the case, the majority of their youngsters are adept at winning their own ball along with having a bit of pace...That's where we should be heading IMO...

Let's see how it unfolds

Re Cumming - I don't want to write him off completely as he could make me look silly , ditto Cox . Both talents with speed just not where I would go with pick 13

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

I not sure we bid on Cumming at 13, I think it's more likely we're looking at him for 43 but because of our surprise in Doedee last year the media experts are jumping at shadows.
Although hes been invited to sydney so someone in the top 10 must be keen.

 

[marty36]

Brett Anderson made the point clubs are being far more secretive, so a lot of these predictions could be way off.

Clubs may have finally worked out they need to stop the leaks

That is one thing Adelaide is well and truly on top of

 

[Scorpus]

Cumming seems to be one of those players boosting up the rankings after the combine. I'm always extremely wary of players rated highly only because of the combine. I'd much rather draft players who looked excellent on the footy field

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I not sure we bid on Cumming at 13, I think it's more likely we're looking at him for 43 but because of our surprise in Doedee last year the media experts are jumping at shadows.
Although hes been invited to sydney so someone in the top 10 must be keen.

The fact that he's been flown to the draft indicates someone in top 10 may also be interested . I'm looking at you Sydney !!

Along with Collingwood I'd rate Sydney and Adelaide the most likely clubs to go against the grain - done it before

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Cumming seems to be one of those players boosting up the rankings after the combine. I'm always extremely wary of players rated highly only because of the combine. I'd much rather draft players who looked excellent on the footy field

He looks great on the footy field but doesn't win enough ball

 

[Scorpus]

He looks great on the footy field but doesn't win enough ball

 

[marty36]

Cumming seems to be one of those players boosting up the rankings after the combine. I'm always extremely wary of players rated highly only because of the combine. I'd much rather draft players who looked excellent on the footy field

Imagine how Darren or Andrew jarman would have gone at the combine the beep test would have had to be cancelled for taking too long

 

[Bicks]

Imagine how Darren or Andrew jarman would have gone at the combine the beep test would have had to be cancelled for taking too long

Jonty didn't do too well by all reports I've heard in regards the beep test, you hear that??

 

[Knightmare]

Very strong interest in McInerney from several clubs. Adelaide one of several in the mix.

 

[marty36]

Jonty didn't do too well by all reports I've heard in regards the beep test, you hear that??

I'm not concerned about sharenberg he will be drafted then it will be up to the players for those who chose their draft if they are duds or not including berry

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

The fact that he's been flown to the draft indicates someone in top 10 may also be interested . I'm looking at you Sydney !!

Along with Collingwood I'd rate Sydney and Adelaide the most likely clubs to go against the grain - done it before

If it's true what you say about his lack of competitiveness, then I just don't see it, not at 13 anyway.

 

[Elite Crow]

Brett Anderson made the point clubs are being far more secretive, so a lot of these predictions could be way off.

If I was a club I wouldn't be telling anyone jack shit, I don't get the logic