Position 2017 Rookies

[Riviat]

Smashed JLT and then Rocket was like, nup, not ready.

Was weird and now an awkward price when looking for downgrade targets.

I consider £155k (mcinnes, perryman) as far as I'd pay for a rook before they lose their appeal during the season. Maybe at the start of the season I'll pay overs but you start losing money for better premos as opposed to a 102k pricer. Money is king this year and rooks need to make max profit. It's a gamble and if brodie can do A SP Newman and be a potential keeper then he's worth it.

 

[Me Myself and I]

I consider £155k (mcinnes, perryman) as far as I'd pay for a rook before they lose their appeal during the season. Maybe at the start of the season I'll pay overs but you start losing money for better premos as opposed to a 102k pricer. Money is king this year and rooks need to make max profit. It's a gamble and if brodie can do A SP Newman and be a potential keeper then he's worth it.

At today's exchange rate converts to AUD$268k. Well, you'd certainly be paying overs.

 

[buttox]

When do freo reserves name there team?
Just wondering about balic....

 

[gutsroy]

Edit: This time the correct tweet, don't know how the Relton Roberts thing got in there:

 

[pincrusher]

Tim English (Ruck) to debut for the bulldogs. Cloke dropped.

Edit: And now they are saying the source can't confirm this.

 

[vanders]

102k mid

 

[gutsroy]

This one appears sketchier than others, would wait and see if it is true:

 

[The Lemon]

102k mid

LOCCCCKKKKKK

Balic to Cousins LOCK ME IN

 

[Goats]

LOCCCCKKKKKK

Balic to Cousins LOCK ME IN

I'm wrapped, the kid is a gun and has had an outstanding season in the VFL. Clarko will give him a good run at it too.

 

[The Lemon]

I'm wrapped, the kid is a gun and has had an outstanding season in the VFL. Clarko will give him a good run at it too.

One kid I am confident in.

 

[Sir Hugh Percy]

Oh I've included Perryman ...

Don't play the Perryman (until on the bubble)
Don't ever pay that price (155K)
Don't play the Perryman, until they (SC) let me pick a brand new side

Don't pay the Perryman
He won't even fix your side
Don't pay the Perryman
Unless you've got an Otten on the slide

 

[gutsroy]

Will know soon enough if genuine, some going early with Scharenberg in:

 

[pincrusher]

Rookies galore. Just in time for the bye rounds.

 

[jdwood]

Collingwood fans - assuming Scharenberg gets the nod shortly, is it safe to assume he gets an extended run at it?

I, for one, am tempted.

 

[gutsroy]

Collingwood fans - assuming Scharenberg gets the nod shortly, is it safe to assume he gets an extended run at it?

I, for one, am tempted.

From memory he got an ok run at it last time and the club was patient with him as he worked his way up to speed in the seniors.
For me the question is point production vs elevated price and he is yet another rd 13 bye rookie.
See what others closer to it say. Wouldn't go early unless absolutely necessary.

 

[Migzeh]

When do freo reserves name there team?
Just wondering about balic....

hes on indefinite leave aint he?

 

[keithrichards]

When do freo reserves name there team?
Just wondering about balic....

No WAFL being played this week as it is the WAFL vs VFL representative game

 

[Chaisa]

Perryman v Scharenberg - which makes more sense?

On the one hand, Scharenberg probably has better JS. On the other hand, Perryman's cheaper, has DPP and has already played.

 

[gutsroy]

Tim English tweet was right after all, by the looks. Named.

 

[Golden_6]

Do I skip on Stewart and go a week early on Greenwood? I'm planning on double/triple downgrading next week. Basically are Scharenberg/Perryman/Cousins going to be better rookie options than Stewart?

 

[toxic]

Do I skip on Stewart and go a week early on Greenwood? I'm planning on double/triple downgrading next week. Basically are Scharenberg/Perryman/Cousins going to be better rookie options than Stewart?

Yes yes and nfi

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Smashed JLT and then Rocket was like, nup, not ready.

Was weird and now an awkward price when looking for downgrade targets.

With his contested ball approach though, if Brodie has a good first game & his JS improves ....I'll certainly look at him

Coaches brought in Taranto as a $200+k forward .....a $175k midfielder is good by comparison

I'm also looking to have more playing rookies on the bench come trade exhaustion time

 

[WaynesWorld19]

102k mid

How would you describe his playing style? ....SC friendly? ....

 

[Listclogger]

Do I skip on Stewart and go a week early on Greenwood? I'm planning on double/triple downgrading next week. Basically are Scharenberg/Perryman/Cousins going to be better rookie options than Stewart?

We'll all be struggling to field 18 in R13 with all these rookies

 

[PoopingHindi]

We'll all be struggling to field 18 in R13 with all these rookies

i'll settle for 17 premo's instead if i have to