List Mgmt. 2017 Trade/Draft/FA SuperMegaUltra Thread - Post Trade-Period Edition

[amazingjoshy]

Re: Kelly he most definitely is an inside mid at WAFL level. Clearance and contested ball machine from the numerous games I've seen in the last two years. The fact he has speed and is a beautiful user just means he has numerous strings to his bow. If there's one guy I hope we get in this year's draft, it's this guy. I'm in the minority, but I'd be more than happy if we reached for him early.

 

[EagleEgo]

I think 37 is a stretch. This is his 6th draft so to date 500 picks have been taken before him.

But a pick in the 40s or 50s in a weaker draft is about right but we dont have a pick in the 40s or 50s

Have Ah Chee and Tim Kelly played together in South Fremantle colt before?

 

[new breed]

Have Ah Chee and Tim Kelly played together in South Fremantle colt before?

Yes they played Colts together , Ah Chee won SF F&B in that Colts year ...Kelly missed some footy with an abdomen injury and his chances of being drafted were affected apparently .

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

View attachment 435355
http://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/ni...y/news-story/552e7aaebe36aedf66c7a08aba5d3c08

Doesn't look like it cobber. It's all about winning that time trial for Marsdo

No wonder he can put on any size with all the cardio he does . He should be in the gym Ffs not the track

 

[Patron]

Agree Allen but then again is not a tall he is a tweener.

As far as the talls go I see it a little differently to you in my ratings:

Naughton.
Brander.
Ballenden. love his ball use just worry that the pace of the game at the next level may test him.

Then for me Balta, Taylor , Krueger, Clavarino , Petty all much the same talent line, but all bring something different to a list.

As far as Brisbane playing funny buggers I think it was a tactical move to do the trade with Richmond to get a second pick in the first round fired off before they had to match a Ballender bid , likewise it suited Richmond to trade back to accommodate a Naish bid.

With all the chatter and fluff about us and Allen , thats very unlike us and I wonder if we too are playing ducks and drakes.

How do you rate naughtons kicking? To me it looks horrible. Would go Brander.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[beatlesmith]

A few more highlight videos from giantroo are trickling through.

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

How do you rate naughtons kicking? To me it looks horrible. Would go Brander.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Yep brander all the way .He is an eagles fan which is strange for a vic lad . good omen

 

[FKASC]

Is it possible we could go Brander and then Allen with our first two? And use the others for mids, thus justifying our trade to get more second rounders, given there are a bunch of second tier mids around that 20-40 mark?

 

[Rob L]

I really hope masten is Hitting the gym hard this offseason and working on his mental toughness. Who cares if he doesn't smash the 2 km time trial record.

Seen him twice at the gym in the past two weeks, no weights work, fittness work only....

 

[squashface]

A few more highlight videos from giantroo are trickling through.

From those three:
Big yes to Miers, do want
Wouldn't mind Starcevich
Big no to Garner, vanilla HBF

 

[FKASC]

A few more highlight videos from giantroo are trickling through.

Like the look of Miers. Seems to have a few tricks, good balance and a good awareness of who's around him.

 

[FKASC]

From those three:
Big yes to Miers, do want
Wouldn't mind Starcevich
Big no to Garner, vanilla HBF

Hmm I think Garner looks like a handy player but how much does he add that Duggan and Cole can't already?

 

[AsterixTheGaul]

A few more highlight videos from giantroo are trickling through.

Got to like Miers. When they have handball practice, he is excused and goes off for goal kicking practice. Love the way he gets the ball and just knows where the goals are. Instinct.

 

[kylealone]

Tim Kelly believes the Eagles will take him before Carltons pick. I'm guessing that means pick 21/26.

 

[RookiePick]

Garner has the kind of haircut our recruiters cream over tho'

 

[Eaglemaniac]

Garner has the kind of haircut our recruiters cream over tho'

But could you set your watch to it?

 

[FKASC]

Garner has the kind of haircut our recruiters cream over tho'

One you can set your watch to?

 

[avishka5]

Tim Kelly is the ideal second string mid. Has the class and polish to be the cream on top type player but the fact he can win his own ball and kick snags means that he is more valuable than the that type of player. He would definitely complement the rest of our mids

 

[RookiePick]

A few more highlight videos from giantroo are trickling through.

Mark LeGryan. I'm actually pretty partial to a small/med forward who is hungry as buggery. Provided they are class of course.

 

[Dark Sharks]

Amazing how highly other supporters (Bishop included) seem to rate Ryan, constantly being touted as a 2nd round pick.

Good luck to them if they want to run the risk on him for that price.

 

[Monocle]

How do you rate naughtons kicking? To me it looks horrible. Would go Brander.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Agree that the style ( or lack there of ) looks woeful and ungainly.

But here is the thing its generally effective ..... weird as that may sound, he he hits as many targets as some most of his cohort.

Brander plays both ends and that always rates very highly in my assessment of talent, not sure where he is best suited to at this stage of his development, but thats not a bad problem for the coaching team to have to work there way through.

 

[WCE_phil]

I agree Ryan is a second rounder on talent, but with all the negatives, application and average at best fitness i wouldn't touch him before very late in the draft or rookie.

 

[Monocle]

Garner has the kind of haircut our recruiters cream over tho'

The Rowan Jones Cut.

 

[Monocle]

From those three:
Big yes to Miers, do want
Wouldn't mind Starcevich But not with one of our second rounders
Big no to Garner, vanilla

HBF

 

[Monocle]

Amazing how highly other supporters (Bishop included) seem to rate Ryan, constantly being touted as a 2nd round pick.

Good luck to them if they want to run the risk on him for that price.

They are East Coast residents and I would bet that they have formed their opinions based on the highlights reel.