Tom Lynch.
List Mgmt. 2020 List Management: Contracts, Trading, Drafting, Academy
- Thread starter Determinant
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Tom Lynch.
Both near the end of the article. Also Sproule out and Josh Green in works for me.
So given the primary list can't be more then 38 and with the re-signing of Lloyd and assuming he stays on the primary list that leaves 5 spots at the most on the primary list.
www.afl.com.au
Still the biggest: Suns to keep extended squad in 2021
The AFL will allow Gold Coast to have more listed players than other clubs in 2021 as part of the ongoing concessions granted last year
www.afl.com.au
Would prefer O McDonald. 81 games with plenty left in tank. Plug and play when Davis gets injured next.
Saint Michael
Draftee
- Nov 23, 2020
- 6
- 7
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Banned
- #2,330
Just came over to say I totally agree with everything Jason McCartney said about Dodoro & Essendon - they are chumps to deal with at trade time.
- Nov 18, 2015
- 2,400
- 5,483
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Understand the concept but I don't think it's realistic, lots of players(even early picks) struggle to get to afl level after being drafted and clubs need to be able to cut losses relatively early because of list size restrictions.
- Nov 18, 2015
- 2,400
- 5,483
- AFL Club
- Geelong
I'm sure we would love to have one of your top mids, you have some serious talent there... but I can't see it happening. I suspect we will be shopping for rucks and KPD's next season, not midfielders.
S Rioghal Mo Dhream
Buried in Balquhidder
- Aug 16, 2020
- 472
- 427
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Banned
- #2,333
Hey guys and girls how are we all?
Sorry to ask but I've got a random question and while this may be the wrong thread I'm hoping someone could help me out.
I know that back in 2016 there was multiple pick swaps and players traded in order for you to acquire the selection used to draft Tim Taranto that year.
Does anyone know what it ended up costing in full at all?
Sorry to ask but I've got a random question and while this may be the wrong thread I'm hoping someone could help me out.
I know that back in 2016 there was multiple pick swaps and players traded in order for you to acquire the selection used to draft Tim Taranto that year.
Does anyone know what it ended up costing in full at all?
Gigantic
Brownlow Medallist
GWS Giants traded Cam McCarthy, along with draft selections No.7, No.34 and No.72 to the Fremantle Dockers for their first selection at the draft, No.3 overall.
GWS Giants traded picks No.3 and No.16 to the Brisbane Lions for picks No.2, No.31, No.51 and No.60.
S Rioghal Mo Dhream
Buried in Balquhidder
- Aug 16, 2020
- 472
- 427
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Banned
- #2,335
Thanks very much for taking the time and making the effort to respond to my post - much appreciated.
My understanding was that the pick in question was obtained by undertaking the following trades:
GWS Giants traded Cam McCarthy, along with draft selections No.7 (received from Collingwood as part of the Adam Treloar Trade in 2015), No.34 (from Carlton in exchange for Lachie Plowman, Andrew Phillips, Liam Sumner and Jed Lamb) and No.72 (received from North Melbourne in exchange for Paul Ahern) to the Fremantle Dockers for their first selection at the draft, No.3 overall.
GWS Giants traded picks No.3 and No.16 (received from Carlton and tied to Geelong in exchange for GWS First Round Selection being Pick 8 in 2015) to the Brisbane Lions for picks No.2, No.31, No.51 and No.60.
Pick 2 was then taken to the Draft and used to select Tim Taranto in 2016.
That's a whole lot of movement to get your desired target and I know that he was rated extremely highly (and rightfully so) by your club, who effectively moved heaven and earth to get him.
Kids an absolute jet
GWS Goose
Brownlow Medallist
It is worth remembering that we had a strong academy class that year, so it was as much about points as anything else. It was no sacrifice all those trade downs.Thanks very much for taking the time and making the effort to respond to my post - much appreciated.
My understanding was that the pick in question was obtained by undertaking the following trades:
GWS Giants traded Cam McCarthy, along with draft selections No.7 (received from Collingwood as part of the Adam Treloar Trade in 2015), No.34 (from Carlton in exchange for Lachie Plowman, Andrew Phillips, Liam Sumner and Jed Lamb) and No.72 (received from North Melbourne in exchange for Paul Ahern) to the Fremantle Dockers for their first selection at the draft, No.3 overall.
GWS Giants traded picks No.3 and No.16 (received from Carlton and tied to Geelong in exchange for GWS First Round Selection being Pick 8 in 2015) to the Brisbane Lions for picks No.2, No.31, No.51 and No.60.
Pick 2 was then taken to the Draft and used to select Tim Taranto in 2016.
That's a whole lot of movement to get your desired target and I know that he was rated extremely highly (and rightfully so) by your club, who effectively moved heaven and earth to get him.
Kids an absolute jet
We picked up Setterfield, Perryman and Cumming in the first round, took Tizanni late and passed on McCreadie in the draft proper and picked up Zach Sproule in the Rookie draft.
So all we wanted was one high end pick (ahead of Setterfield) as well as our academy kids.
Very different to this year for instance where the sacrifice to move up would be real.
S Rioghal Mo Dhream
Buried in Balquhidder
- Aug 16, 2020
- 472
- 427
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Banned
- #2,337
Thanks for the insight - I guess given the dramatic drop in quality after the projected first few picks and the uncertainty of the draft pool itself, that this year would be one where your club wouldn't need or want multiple mid - late first round selections and would most likely have an intended target at the pointy end of the draft?
Our board is quite split on this. Personally I see merit to both sides but lean towards getting into the top 5 and taking a KPD
S Rioghal Mo Dhream
Buried in Balquhidder
- Aug 16, 2020
- 472
- 427
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Banned
- #2,339
I could totally see why your supporter base would be split - just figured that given your recent departures that perhaps you'd be seeking quality over quantity and back yourselves in to not only select the right player, but also have them buy into the club and stay long term.
While I'm intrigued with who we'll take with our highest selection in close to two decades, I'm wondering if we'd in fact be better splitting our pick into 3-4 selections and obtain multiple solid citizens as opposed to trying to land a star.
Will be interesting to see how things pan out either way I guess.
Thanks for the response and hope you guys do well regardless
Last edited:
You should def split your pick imoI could totally see why your supporter base would be split - just figured that given your recent departures that perhaps you'd be seeking quality over quantity and back yourselfs in to not only select the right player, but also have them buy into the club and stay long term.
While I'm intrigued with who we'll take with our highest selection in close to two decades, I'm wondering if we'd in fact be better splitting our pick into 3-4 selections and obtain multiple solid citizens as opposed to trying to land a star.
Will be interesting to see how things pan out either way I guess.
Thanks for the response and hope you guys do well regardless
might be with us might not be.... but you have a chance to get two first round picks in.... you would be silly not to imo
- Nov 23, 2015
- 11,806
- 17,450
- AFL Club
- GWS
- Moderator
- #2,342
Interesting. What will GWS do? Who might we drop back to rookie status? Perhaps Lloyd, Shipley or Hutchesson? Or do we just pick up a DFA as a rookie and not use this option?
S Rioghal Mo Dhream
Buried in Balquhidder
- Aug 16, 2020
- 472
- 427
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Banned
- #2,343
Both options have merit, if it's not with yourselves then Collingwood would be a real possibility.
Their pair of firsts and next years would probably get it done you'd think.
Although any one of Elijah Hollands, Riley Thilthorpe or Will Phillips would also be great.
Guess we'll find out soon enough.
Did you guys and girls here have anyone in particular you'd be hoping your club targets?
Why unrealistic. Most clubs fall over themselves to extend first round picks in first 3 months of players being there. Maybe top 30 are minimum 3 yrs with some triggers. Try being a "why not" person for a week. It would be good for your personal development!
GWS Goose
Brownlow Medallist
You might get next year's first plus two in the teens this year from Collingwood
Hi all,
Just wanting to know what type of player you think the giants would be targeting in the draft with their first. As a north supporter I’m trying to work out the types of player left on the board at 11.
Specifically I’m hoping for Cox and to a lesser degree Reid. And I feel one of those will be available after Essendon’s picks. I can’t see the crows going for a tall defender, so that leaves the Giants.
Any thoughts? Thanks.
Just wanting to know what type of player you think the giants would be targeting in the draft with their first. As a north supporter I’m trying to work out the types of player left on the board at 11.
Specifically I’m hoping for Cox and to a lesser degree Reid. And I feel one of those will be available after Essendon’s picks. I can’t see the crows going for a tall defender, so that leaves the Giants.
Any thoughts? Thanks.
