List Mgmt. 2022 List Management: Draft, Trade and FA
- Thread starter Cobbler
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
For those that haven’t been playing attention to Gold Coast (I don’t blame them), Chol and Levi Casboult are playing every game. Ouch.
Meanwhile they draft mids year after year and in some cases have given away very good players for nothing.
Sorry Taylor. No chance. That's not how trading works in the slightest anyway. Teams regularly have to make other trades to get a trade done and despite what most think the trading of uncontracted players who want to come home who have star potential nearly always ends up in a fair trade. Eg. Tim Kelly or Jake Lever. Jackson's as promising a tall as Ive seen in a long time, It will take way more than what the Cerra trade was to get it done. No way he goes into the preseason as he'd be more likely to do a Papley and sign a short term contract with the team he knows.
Snuffaluphagus
Moderator
- Sep 10, 2015
- 21,185
- 71,168
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Moderator
- #2,831
I’ll ask you more on here because it’s easier then the draft board and you defs always are happy to hand over a lot for peeps, do you think two low teens first and Lobb is enough currency for Jackson?
If Darcy and Lobb beat Chol and Meek at SuperCoach or whatever this week I’ll unblock you and like all your posts for a year
If they don’t you have to block me and stop ******* quoting me
Sent from my iPad using BigFooty.com
Typical disingenuous post. Nothing wrong with the past 6 games to make an instant comparison.
And you are replying to a post I don't quote you or reference you in.
unless.... you are Chol.
Some pretty funny valuations of player trade values going on here as usual.
I have a proposed formula to get the actual real trade value of a player that Fremantle may be involved in (works for both a player leaving and coming to freo).
Step 1 is to get the opinion of Taylor. That is usually a ridiculously extreme optimistic value from Fremantles perspective. A good recent example was Jesse hogan supposedly being worth pick 3 the year we traded him to GWS.
Then to balance that we get the other extreme from Freomaniac. A good recent example was him regretfully informing this board last season that we’d do very well to get pick 18 for Adam Cerra in his view.
Land about half way between their respective valuations and that’s probably the ballpark of what the player being discussed is worth.
I reckon it would be a very reliable formula!
Also - I solemnly promise to gift a premium platinum big footy membership for 12 months to every person who has posted on this thread so far, if either Luke Jackson or Tim English find their way to west coast for free via the pre season draft in the 2022 trade period. There is a better chance of Andrew Gaff being the best man at Andy Brayshaws wedding than either of those scenarios happening.
I have a proposed formula to get the actual real trade value of a player that Fremantle may be involved in (works for both a player leaving and coming to freo).
Step 1 is to get the opinion of Taylor. That is usually a ridiculously extreme optimistic value from Fremantles perspective. A good recent example was Jesse hogan supposedly being worth pick 3 the year we traded him to GWS.
Then to balance that we get the other extreme from Freomaniac. A good recent example was him regretfully informing this board last season that we’d do very well to get pick 18 for Adam Cerra in his view.
Land about half way between their respective valuations and that’s probably the ballpark of what the player being discussed is worth.
I reckon it would be a very reliable formula!
Also - I solemnly promise to gift a premium platinum big footy membership for 12 months to every person who has posted on this thread so far, if either Luke Jackson or Tim English find their way to west coast for free via the pre season draft in the 2022 trade period. There is a better chance of Andrew Gaff being the best man at Andy Brayshaws wedding than either of those scenarios happening.
Standing Bet to Be Honoured
You’re a boring campaigner to argue with which is why I blocked you in the first place
I learnt my lesson in the Lyon days , bickering with people over pages and pages for no point just *s up the site for everyone
Block me and we can just get on with our lives aye
Sent from my iPad using BigFooty.com
jimboslice
Senior List
- Mar 27, 2015
- 260
- 577
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Newcastle Utd, Cleveland Cavaliers
You quote him and then pretty much state arguing on this page is a waste of everyone’s time and ask to be left alone. You’re a fruitloop mate.
I don't block anyone.
I also don't get it. You bring up Chol, and I recalled that you had liked him previously. It's a football discussion site. I'm discussing football, you are discussing me.
Sure bro , I’ll leave you to your passive aggressive w***ery
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
So do people think Neale will attempt to return to WA again this year?
And if so, what would be the price.
I’m not convinced he will stay in brisbane at all, have seen this kinda thing before. Saying all the right things now but unless a contract extension is signed by Neale at brisbane before trade week I wouldn’t bet on it
And if so, what would be the price.
I’m not convinced he will stay in brisbane at all, have seen this kinda thing before. Saying all the right things now but unless a contract extension is signed by Neale at brisbane before trade week I wouldn’t bet on it
Taylor
Community Leader
- Moderator
- #2,845
If Brisbane are going to have to pay a top three pick for Ashcroft then trading Neale for a top three pick from the Eagles will be a huge win for them.
I floated the trade in the Jackson main thread on drafts board but something like:
Pick #2 for Neale, Brisbane's first this season and next
Could work out for both parties, including Freo because it pushes the start date for their rebuild back until end of 2023
I floated the trade in the Jackson main thread on drafts board but something like:
Pick #2 for Neale, Brisbane's first this season and next
Could work out for both parties, including Freo because it pushes the start date for their rebuild back until end of 2023
Only thing is they don’t do rebuilds at Lathlain. The eagles are too good for that. Instead they just do “periods of transition”
Taylor
Community Leader
- Moderator
- #2,847
Well let's go right off the deep end...Only thing is they don’t do rebuilds at Lathlain. The eagles are too good for that. Instead they just do “periods of transition”
...to follow on from that Neale trade for their pick #2, they could then trade their two Brisbane first round picks to GWS for Coniglio and GWS' pick #4
Sending their pick #20 to the Dogs for English
Trade pick #4 to Freo for our pick #15 and Logue
We trade pick #4 and Lobb to Melbourne for Jackson
Eagles walk out of the off season with Neale and Coniglio to bolster their midfield, English to lead their rucks, Logue to sure up defense and pick #23 at the draft to start.
That side should win eight to ten games a year.
But clearly Logue, Lobb and our first round pick would be a high price for us to pay to leave us exposed in defense.
- Apr 25, 2011
- 6,778
- 14,853
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
You are diabolical. I love it. Ha.
My head is spinning.
- Oct 1, 2015
- 1,169
- 2,197
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Logue is steak knives in any deal. Catch ya
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
