Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Deliverance]

I can only afford $484k and my best options for that price are Himmelberg, Preuss and Heeney.

All of them have an iffy side to them but at least with Preuss I have English and Teakle as cover if he misses a week or 2.

Did you get Heeney?

 

[Jiska]

Jiska this is why I said get mills lol
Very stiff missing him though mate

Prick is gonna go 200. Had him all week. Started mucking around with diff options last night after a few drinks and forgot to change back. Story of my season. s**t happens.

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Prick is gonna go 200. Had him all week. Started mucking around with diff options last night after a few drinks and forgot to change back. Story of my season. s**t happens.

Add butters to our woes

 

[Jiska]

Add butters to our woes

What did I miss?

 

[rocker_oz33]

What did I miss?

Butter knee prob a PCL..

 

[ForeverHardcore]

What did I miss?

Done his knee tackling 5 mins into the second quarter
Was on 60 points
Looked like a massive ton coming
Typical butters
Whenever he looks good something happens to him

The new Heeney and on my never again list

 

[Jiska]

Butter knee prob a PCL..

Never again list likely

 

[Jiska]

Done his knee tackling 5 mins into the second quarter
Was on 60 points
Looked like a massive ton coming
Typical butters
Whenever he looks good something happens to him

The new Heeney and on my never again list

I started with him last year. An inspired left field choice. Was on 110 at half time when he went down. How frustrating.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Gawn ..trade to Tim England.

Wait and get Cameron next week.
When's Grundy back.

Any other good rucks ....? This is fine

Gawn to film.

Butters to Henney or Hawkins .

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Bont (this week) vs Stewart (next week)?

I have Buters/Preuss this week to deal with, thinking Bont and one of Heeney/Hawkins/Rozee. But if I get Bont this week it's very likely I won't have enough cash to turn Whitfield into Stewart when he bottoms out next week.

 

[Mateyman]

Darcy vs Witts

 

[catstragic]

Darcy vs Witts

Darcy has tendency to both break and score 50's.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Himmelberg, Preuss or Heeney?

Last 2 I'd be roughing back in.

I’m hoping for some info on Taranto and the new coaches plans for him.

 

[Northernsoul74]

I don't think his JS is terrible, he's a better ruckman than Flynn by a country mile.

He was ill so that explains why he missed the last couple but kinda weird that he was still fine to play in the 2's which I found strange. Why didn't he just have 2 weeks off instead if he was ill?

His coach has come out today and said he needs get fitter and more robust.

 

[SC fish]

Darcy vs Witts

Witts, same reason as catstragic

 

[toxic]

Darcy vs Witts

Darcy easily from here

 

[VeinGlorious]

I’m hoping for some info on Taranto and the new coaches plans for him.

The new coach plans on teaching him how to kick.

 

[Northernsoul74]

The new coach plans on teaching him how to kick.

That’s a great start.

 

[Soggy2112]

Darcy easily from here

Curious the thought process on this

 

[DaveyBoy123]

Bont vs Parker?

Money is no issue, but durability is... I'm a little worried Bont gets rested/injured at some stage and I really don't have the FWD depth to cover him.

 

[toxic]

Curious the thought process on this

Darcy's ceiling is so so so much higher than J Wit

We don't play Supercoach to procreate (insert F K word) spiders

Ask yourself

Is Witts a VC or C option - answer is no

Is Darcy a VC or C option ' imho he's a yes to VC option

 

[toxic]

Bont vs Parker?

Money is no issue, but durability is... I'm a little worried Bont gets rested/injured at some stage and I really don't have the FWD depth to cover him.

Bont - dogs still finals bound

ZERO chance of being rested

 

[Axly]

Blicavs vs Nank vs Darcy

 

[stevebbb]

If I trade Butters:

• Parker ($6.1k left)
• Libba ($18.4k left)
• Gresham ($75.4k left)
• Treloar ($60.2k left)
• Hawkins ($106.1k left)
• Heeney ($112.3k left)
• Rozee ($116.1k left)
• Duncan ($113.7k left)
• Greene ($129k left)

If I hold Butters and trade Hamilton instead:

• Willie Rioli (will he get any midfield time?)
• JJK (he's old, but Eagles look better with a few big names back, he might kick a few goals)
• Larkey
• Mead (is his spot in the side secure? looked good against the Swans)
• MacDonald (any chance for more time on-ball?)
• Bazzo and cash

who are you taking?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

If I trade Butters:

• Parker ($6.1k left)
• Libba ($18.4k left)
• Gresham ($75.4k left)
• Treloar ($60.2k left)
• Hawkins ($106.1k left)
• Heeney ($112.3k left)
• Rozee ($116.1k left)
• Duncan ($113.7k left)
• Greene ($129k left)

If I hold Butters and trade Hamilton instead:

• Willie Rioli (will he get any midfield time?)
• JJK (he's old, but Eagles look better with a few big names back, he might kick a few goals)
• Larkey
• Mead (is his spot in the side secure? looked good against the Swans)
• MacDonald (any chance for more time on-ball?)
• Bazzo and cash

who are you taking?

Butters to Hawkins/Heeney. You'll need the cash for other sideways injury trades.