Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[WaynesWorld19]

I suggested him in the Planning Thread, got poo-poo'd.

He's ripe to go SP imo, just needs to shake a tag better and he'll be pushing 120+

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I suggested him in the Planning Thread, got poo-poo'd.

He's ripe to go SP imo, just needs to shake a tag better and he'll be pushing 120+

So which players aren't taggable .....Steele, Touk Touk ...about it

If Touk Touk can out run opponents, Walsh should be able to likewise ....Oliver, Zerrett, and others have been successfully tagged where clubs have shown a will to tag

Brayshaw, another PS to be even fitter ....wih Cerra gone, and Fyfe ??? ....I'm hoping Brayshaw steps up, particularly if there's a Captaincy change

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

So which players aren't taggable .....Steele, Touk Touk ...about it

If Touk Touk can out run opponents, Walsh should be able to likewise ....Oliver, Zerrett, and others have been successfully tagged where clubs have shown a will to tag

Brayshaw, another PS to be even fitter ....wih Cerra gone, and Fyfe ??? ....I'm hoping Brayshaw steps up, particularly if there's a Captaincy change

Jack Macrae never seems effected by a tag, doesn't get many though. They usually go to the Bont. Just another reason to pick him.

Does Steele get tagged? That would just even more contested possessions.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

So which players aren't taggable .....Steele, Touk Touk ...about it

If Touk Touk can out run opponents, Walsh should be able to likewise ....Oliver, Zerrett, and others have been successfully tagged where clubs have shown a will to tag

Brayshaw, another PS to be even fitter ....wih Cerra gone, and Fyfe ??? ....I'm hoping Brayshaw steps up, particularly if there's a Captaincy change

With cerra gone would brayshaw get more attention and get tagged more often by the opposition?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

With cerra gone would brayshaw get more attention and get tagged more often by the opposition?

Possible .....but if you're going to choose a midfielder in your top 5-6 players, they have to be either the #1 or #2 midfielder for that club

Just think ATS Brayshaw represents great value .....expecting he'll end up being a M7 / M8 in my final side

 

[Caztheconquerer]

Possible .....but if you're going to choose a midfielder in your top 5-6 players, they have to be either the #1 or #2 midfielder for that club

Just think ATS Brayshaw represents great value .....expecting he'll end up being a M7 / M8 in my final side

More than likely mate, hopefully he will be a great pick and go to another level this year

 

[VeinGlorious]

Left-field. Waaaaaaaay left.

Shiel V Gresham

 

[King_Steele]

Left-field. Waaaaaaaay left.

Shiel V Gresham

Shiel

 

[VeinGlorious]

Shiel

What’s the word on Gresh?

We all know Shiel is s**t, but his best can be serviceable - stepping stone type… pity the campaigner can’t kick.

 

[King_Steele]

Oliver & Laird
Vs
Walsh & Petracca

Big O v Marshall
Short v Daniel

 

[King_Steele]

What’s the word on Gresh?

We all know Shiel is sh*t, but his best can be serviceable - stepping stone type… pity the campaigner can’t kick.

I’m expecting Gresh to mainly play up fwd next year coming back from Achilles injury

 

[Obese Arachnid]

I’m expecting Gresh to mainly play up fwd next year coming back from Achilles injury

Will he be magic though?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Beer vs scotch vs wine?

 

[Andrew Birch]

Beer vs scotch vs wine?

Depends, since you're asking at 5am

Scotch if you're up really late. Beer, if you're up really early and need a pick me up/hair of the dog.

 

[Significant]

Oliver & Laird - both able to go large, and not many points being taken off Laird at CROM, but very close call
Vs
Walsh & Petracca

Big O v Marshall - don't understand the Big O hype (cringe), provided he is fit Marshall is the better more consistent scorer, regardless of Ryder
Short v Daniel - going for a risk here, but think Short is on an upward trajectory, whilst Daniel getting tagged out still haunts me

 

[Ingy]

The 'hype' over Oscar revolves around his form at the end of last season, from Round 15 onwards when he averaged 115 over 9 games with nothing under 90 and a high of 148.

For 500k that's good buying, if that's him now and you get a 115 average from him for the whole season, which is possible. I mean he might even keep improving.

I've just recently tipped him out of my team for Grundy, because of fears that Fort might take some work from him and lower that average but I might still reverse that, because the 130k difference in price is quite handy and there probably isn't that level of difference between their likely outputs. I.e. Oscar is better value

 

[Changa10]

Beer vs scotch vs wine?

Scotch all day long Judd_Magic

 

[King_Steele]

Scotch all day long Judd_Magic

+1.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Scotch all day long Judd_Magic

especially on boxing day morning

 

[King_Steele]

Witts & Dunkley
V
Big O & Gresh

 

[Ingy]

Witts & Dunkley
V
Big O & Gresh

Of those options, probably Witts and Dunks.

Having said that, I'm a bit worried about the likelihood of Dunks missing games to injury.

11 games each the past two seasons.

It's damned if you do or don't I reckon. I'm tempted to leave him, but then he'll average 135 for the first month and I'll feel the need to burn a trade to get him in. Then he'll get injured. That's what happened last year, I got a single score from the kent.

Didn't you reckon Gresh wasn't going to get the midfield time it has been rumoured he was going to get?

 

[King_Steele]

Of those options, probably Witts and Dunks.

Having said that, I'm a bit worried about the likelihood of Dunks missing games to injury.

11 games each the past two seasons.

It's damned if you do or don't I reckon. I'm tempted to leave him, but then he'll average 135 for the first month and I'll feel the need to burn a trade to get him in. Then he'll get injured. That's what happened last year, I got a single score from the kent.

Didn't you reckon Gresh wasn't going to get the midfield time it has been rumoured he was going to get?

I’m assuming ease him into it up fwd with spurts in the middle or I could be completely wrong & he will play full time mid just like pre injury..

 

[St Steady]

berry...hannaberry...caldberry ? same price , im leaning hannaberry if any

 

[WaynesWorld19]

berry...hannaberry...caldberry ? same price , im leaning hannaberry if any

Berry .....resilience and injury will play a big part next season .....can't carry too many injury prone players

 

[blueiris]

berry...hannaberry...caldberry ? same price , im leaning hannaberry if any

Out of the 3 Berry is the more competitive score he’s very capable of massive scoring potential