List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[SainterinSydney]

View attachment 2400179

Wait--so he has been playing for the wrong team the whole time! Someone needs to inform him immediately!

 

[Red White Black]

https://archive.md/GM5xb

 

[Remboy]

Honestly people should get down

I’d strongly advise getting there early. It will be a sell out (if they sell tickets for training). I don’t envy the girls making the coffee.

 

[Mat Mann]

My employer is going to charge St Kilda at this rate. My productivity is at an all time low this week already.

The big boss ( national franchise ) came and saw me today at work to say how good it was he's staying. There's a lot of goodwill out there on this one

 

[billings2paddy]

Easily explained.
He sees Ross as the formal leader/father figure.
He sees Wilkie (and Steele too if I’m correct) as informal leader/close friend.
He would formally notify the Club via Ross, informally talk to Wilkie beforehand.

The two can be true at the same time.

Also.
There’s zero chance that Windy/Chito didn’t know beforehand given how tight they are.

Bongos

 

[Murraj1966]

I’d strongly advise getting there early. It will be a sell out (if they sell tickets for training). I don’t envy the girls making the coffee.

Imagine the carpark pressure washer guy

He’s had it harder than anyone

 

[Lennylegs]

This Richo level of gameplan of chucking Carlisle forward.

Keep Michito as a mid/forward.

Chito is first picked in the forward line. Rarely gets beaten and creates so much space and opportunity for our smalls. No one works harder down there.

You also can't have one paced players as mids anymore. Chito doesn't have that change of pace. Those days are over. It's all about transition.

Fyfe is struggling with it, Cripps to a lesser extent this year. And our captain has been caught out often this year.

Not to say these players don't have their place anymore. It's just that the game is transitioning away from that kind of player.

 

[StCicatriz]

43K views · 50 reactions | LIAM RYAN HEADING TO ST KILDA | Dan Does Footy

LIAM RYAN HEADING TO ST KILDA.

www.facebook.com

 

[stfan]

Can’t see all of King, Marshall, Sharman and Owens playing in the same forward line.

One would be resting on the bench as part of the normal rotations.

​

 

[XhazzafootyX]

Owens maybe as a mid

 

[StCicatriz]

Log into Facebook

Log into Facebook to start sharing and connecting with your friends, family, and people you know.

www.facebook.com

 

[Moquo]

This may reflect my poor searching skills, but was the meaning of "Bongos for Longer" ever resolved?

Lots of theories going around, but I always thought they were talking about BOG. The talk was that in one particular game Hall was bongos, but Nas was bongos for longer. Urban dictionary has a huge list of definitions, but as with most groups and cliques, they like to create their own language. It's all dishwasher safe.

 

[Sainter88]

Log into Facebook

Log into Facebook to start sharing and connecting with your friends, family, and people you know.

www.facebook.com

If Maclure was getting cucked I don’t think he could confidently say who the guy was

 

[Dard Ball Get]

https://archive.md/GM5xb

Bassat discusses the infamous lunch in this article.
Yet another non-truth widely stated and accepted as fact by media and on here

 

[CursingFijian]

Just got done dealing with port fans over rating their players now we gotta deal with west coast fans

Imagine thinking you support a powerhouse club but your home grown talent wants to go to St Kilda.

Delulu.

 

[austinnn]

I don't get the interest in Ryan. He's the same age and size as Butler. They kick the same amount of goals. Ryan takes slightly more marks, Butler tackles slightly more. Would not improve us in any material way.

Maybe when the club were trying to get Nas to sign, they told him to name any players he wanted to play with and they'd being them in?

Otherwise, I agree

 

[sauce_head]

Honestly people should get down

NAS a late out on Sunday with RSI… (sorry, bad joke)

 

[billings2paddy]

With respect, if you believe any of the above you probably need to have a closer look.

He's not setting the world on fire and neither have the eagles
I would suggest you take your rose coloured glasses off and come to the realisation that this club is drastically different to any previous eagles administration In talent and experience hence the poor list management decisions, performance and future outlook.

 

[billings2paddy]

Maybe when the club were trying to get Nas to sign, they told him to name any players he wanted to play with and they'd being them in?

Otherwise, I agree

NAS makes good decisions on field and off field.
Choosing ryan is a poor descision

 

[Yawkey way]

So incoming recruits of:

Defence: Aleer
Midfield: ???
Ruck: TDK
Forward: Ryan

I’d love Walsh.

 

[eaglevision]

He's not setting the world on fire and neither have the eagles
I would suggest you take your rose coloured glasses off and come to the realisation that this club is drastically different to any previous eagles administration In talent and experience hence the poor list management decisions, performance and future outlook.

Not sure why you need to pot my club, think the discussion here has been pretty respectful both ways?

It’s really simple, he’s contracted, no cap issues and is a valuable player on and off the field. If an offer is not commensurate to that value then we’ll hang onto him or engage with other clubs. I’m sure you’d expect the same of your contracted players.

I think your club has built a strong indigenous culture and would be a good landing spot for him should he request a trade.

 

[jwikked]

https://archive.md/GM5xb

Pumps me up to think we could be the AFLs bad boys.

I’d rather be hated than forgotten, or resigned to being everyone’s harmless second team

 

[Dr Spaceman]

NAS makes good decisions on field and off field.
Choosing ryan is a poor descision

We should just let Nas make all these list decisions

 

[billings2paddy]

Not sure why you need to pot my club, think the discussion here has been pretty respectful both ways?

It’s really simple, he’s contracted, no cap issues and is a valuable player on and off the field. If an offer is not commensurate to that value then we’ll hang onto him or engage with other clubs. I’m sure you’d expect the same of your contracted players.

I think your club has built a strong indigenous culture and would be a good landing spot for him should he request a trade.

It's a good question what does a highly inconsistent, 1 goal a game 30yr old contracted small forward go for these days
Id just wait 12 months for him to be delisted then pick up the same inconsistent, 30 yr old delisted small forward for free

 

[westernsainter]

It's a good question what does a highly inconsistent, 1 goal a game 30yr old contracted small forward go for these days
Id just wait 12 months for him to be delisted then pick up the same inconsistent, 30 yr old delisted small forward for free

Not sure this is really warranted especially after we've just had to cop weeks of being told Ollie Lord and Jack Whitlock would be a fair price for Nas.

Ryan is 28 and a very solid player. Would be a great get for us and considering the Coasters have only managed one win this year and are going through an absolutely dire five year stretch they've got every right to want a bit back for him.