List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion

[Sainter88]

thoughts on curnow?

If we can win a flag without having to play a final then yeah I’ll take him

 

[StFly]

I swear, can't even go out for dinner...

If I missed a post, ping it, and I'll set it on fire as I am bloated to all buggery. Otherwise, lookit the trade thread if you want to continue that shit.

 

[botts]

Say the word and I will fire up my trade whisperer twitter account

Please

 

[heynow85]

'I was like HOLY': Marcus Windhager on record-breaking St Kilda win

St Kilda midfielder, Marcus Windhager, has opened up about the moment he realised his team had a chance to defeat Melbourne. The Saints were 46 points behind at three-quarter time on Sunday, making their win the biggest fourth quarter comeback in AFL history. “I was going along not sort of...

www.3aw.com.au

Windy on 3AW, doesn’t sound like he’s signing in a hurry.

 

[Dard Ball Get]

Misson said we should hear from nas in the next week. That’s only one option, he’s staying. No way would he tell us with 3 weeks to go he’s leaving. If we don’t hear from him then we are stuffed

I thought we were stuffed if Caro didn’t announce it on Agenda Setters?
And before that we were stuffed if we didn’t hear by end of week.
And before that we were stuffed if we didn’t hear by end of week.
And before that we were stuffed if we didn’t hear by Tuesday.
And before that we were stuffed if we didn’t hear by the waxing gibbous moon?

 

[Miha]

thoughts on curnow?

GONE

 

[Joffaboy]

GONE

Thoughts on Gawn?

 

[Miha]

Thoughts on Gawn?

Not Gone

 

[Joffaboy]

Not Gone

Not Gawn

 

[botts]

I thought we were stuffed if Caro didn’t announce it on Agenda Setters?
And before that we were stuffed if we didn’t hear by end of week.
And before that we were stuffed if we didn’t hear by end of week.
And before that we were stuffed if we didn’t hear by Tuesday.
And before that we were stuffed if we didn’t hear by the waxing gibbous moon?

To be honest I think we are stuff. Just finding bits of hope to hold onto

 

[phantom13]

I got one from Jack Steele, very generic thanks for a big year look forward to seeing you for our last home game etc

Nah mine was a PERSONAL message from Jack so yours must have been a look alike

 

[Mowman]

Nah mine was a PERSONAL message from Jack so yours must have been a look alike

Any chance you could clean the board up ?

 

[Sainter88]

'I was like HOLY': Marcus Windhager on record-breaking St Kilda win

St Kilda midfielder, Marcus Windhager, has opened up about the moment he realised his team had a chance to defeat Melbourne. The Saints were 46 points behind at three-quarter time on Sunday, making their win the biggest fourth quarter comeback in AFL history. “I was going along not sort of...

www.3aw.com.au

Windy on 3AW, doesn’t sound like he’s signing in a hurry.

Tony you need to come back, your work calming us isn’t finished tony74

 

[Moquo]

It's actually a pic of my daughter

I should elaborate...I did crop her out!

 

[littlecreatures]

hopefully the hold up is indeed him weighing up a 2 year deal, or an 8 year deal (or whatever the length may be)

In my close to 30 years of supporting the Saints, putting aside the losing grand finals particularly 2009, I don’t think there’s been a more painful and deflating time. Looking more grim by the day.

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

some of you clearly have deteriorating pattern recognition capabilities, the microplastics de-evolving us in real time, but I digress.

Nas is not a footballer, he's a storyteller, football is just his side hustle. The dees game, why did he wait until the last quarter to go bang? it's the hero's journey fellas, you can't have a rise without a fall. Like any great storyteller he waited till all hope was lost, till we were at a record breaking deficit before giving us the greatest final act of our footballing lives.

Everyone that's pleading for him to sign need to ask yourself one thing, are you at rock bottom yet? Because only then will he go bang, 10 years with no player option. Once you see the pattern you know it to be true

(yes im at rockbottom pls save me nas im wasting away my golden years in this stupid thread)

 

[BrutThough]

'I was like HOLY': Marcus Windhager on record-breaking St Kilda win

St Kilda midfielder, Marcus Windhager, has opened up about the moment he realised his team had a chance to defeat Melbourne. The Saints were 46 points behind at three-quarter time on Sunday, making their win the biggest fourth quarter comeback in AFL history. “I was going along not sort of...

www.3aw.com.au

Windy on 3AW, doesn’t sound like he’s signing in a hurry.

I'm concerned enough about Nas. I dont want to worry about Windy too.

 

[Sainter88]

some of you clearly have deteriorating pattern recognition capabilities, the microplastics de-evolving us in real time, but I digress.

Nas is not a footballer, he's a storyteller, football is just his side hustle. The dees game, why did he wait until the last quarter to go bang? it's the hero's journey fellas, you can't have a rise without a fall. Like any great storyteller he waited till all hope was lost, till we were at a record breaking deficit before giving us the greatest final act of our footballing lives.

Everyone that's pleading for him to sign need to ask yourself one thing, are you at rock bottom yet? Because only then will he go bang, 10 years with no player option. Once you see the pattern you know it to be true

(yes im at rockbottom pls save me nas im wasting away my golden years in this stupid thread)

We’d all turn into bottoms if it meant him signing

 

[Max the great]

Hurry up and sign 8 years at 1.8 or something Nas. This is killing me

 

[botts]

'I was like HOLY': Marcus Windhager on record-breaking St Kilda win

St Kilda midfielder, Marcus Windhager, has opened up about the moment he realised his team had a chance to defeat Melbourne. The Saints were 46 points behind at three-quarter time on Sunday, making their win the biggest fourth quarter comeback in AFL history. “I was going along not sort of...

www.3aw.com.au

Windy on 3AW, doesn’t sound like he’s signing in a hurry.

Both just letting there manager deal with it and letting it play out. I thought that sounded positive

 

[Diehard Saint]

I agree.

I think it was Kornes said on Monday - we cant pay him over $2mill for two years because when that contracts up, his management is going to expect more again and the salary cap cant handle that.

If he wants money that big, it needs to be a larger commitment than 2 years and accept it as his big payday contract

Then fine, pay him $2 mill a year IF he signs for beyond 2 years, simple as that. Get the big pay day, for the long term commitment

Fair is fair

Exactly what stavro#4 has been saying for ages now.
For what it’s worth I agree.

$2 mill for 2 seasons….and then what?
Where are we supposed to go from there if we can get him to sign for longer?
I get his manager is greedy AF but there comes a time when you have to be realistic. Does NAS want the club to be able to attract (and pay) other good players? Because we’re definitely not the finished product.

 

[_Maximus_12]

Windy wants to be treated like Nas and Mitch without performing like them.

 

[topbillings]

Windy wants to be treated like Nas and Mitch without performing like them.

I would argue Windy has outperformed Mitch considerably in 2025.

 

[heynow85]

 

[phantom13]

Any chance you could clean the board up ?