List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread

[stormskye]

unusual day being linked to four C -graders

If only we were a successful club like the saints. Our current fb and ruck were once viewed that way

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Wonder how true the rumours are of Blight doing a medical at Collingwood

Gotta say, it's really refreshing to see Collingwood going for young key position players, be it via trade or draft.

So god damn tired of all the sub 190 half back flankers we keep bringing in

 

[Exambolor]

Wonder how true the rumours are of Blight doing a medical at Collingwood

Gotta say, it's really refreshing to see Collingwood going for young key position players, be it via trade or draft.

So god damn tired of all the sub 190 half back flankers we keep bringing in

He’d be the easiest to obtain as he’s a DFA

 

[Jen2310]

Wonder how true the rumours are of Blight doing a medical at Collingwood

Gotta say, it's really refreshing to see Collingwood going for young key position players, be it via trade or draft.

So god damn tired of all the sub 190 half back flankers we keep bringing in

Havent heard that one but would be the best option given he has been delisted

 

[Exambolor]

unusual day being linked to four C -graders

We don’t have to overpay for them like the Saints do

 

[legendstatus]

Havent heard that one but would be the best option given he has been delisted

Yes, said it before, I like the look of him, especially early on, be keen to get him and really work on getting him to fit in our defence, only 23 yo I think

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Don’t know much about any of these players. Not unusual for me. But I don’t like Commenetti. That probably means he’s played well in the past! I don’t usually dislike players who are no good lol

 

[Scodog10]

Wonder how true the rumours are of Blight doing a medical at Collingwood

Gotta say, it's really refreshing to see Collingwood going for young key position players, be it via trade or draft.

So god damn tired of all the sub 190 half back flankers we keep bringing in

I’d say the 4 names to have come out are the most Collingwood KPP types you’ll ever see! The fascination with fringe KP talents is definitely alive and well.

• Caminiti = SSP
• Blight = MSD
• Buller = MSD
• Young = mature age RD

Who’s next Edwards from the Bombers?

 

[manicpie]

Don’t know much about any of these players. Not unusual for me. But I don’t like Commenetti. That probably means he’s played well in the past! I don’t usually dislike players who are no good lol

Dennis Cometti retired a few years ago

 

[manicpie]

I’d say the 4 names to have come out are the most Collingwood KPP types you’ll ever see! The fascination with fringe KP talents is definitely alive and well.

• Caminiti = SSP
• Blight = MSD
• Buller = MSD
• Young = mature age RD

Who’s next Edwards from the Bombers?

You know my opinion. It's a yes on all 4 for me

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Dennis Cometti retired a few years ago

Nah I liked that guy. Different bloke. He’s also better suited to our age demographics

 

[sr36]

unusual day being linked to four C -graders

I haven't read it all:
Caminiti
Someone called Buller

Who are the other 2?

 

[manicpie]

I haven't read it all:
Caminiti
Someone called Buller

Who are the other 2?

Blight and young

 

[sr36]

Don’t know much about any of these players. Not unusual for me. But I don’t like Commenetti. That probably means he’s played well in the past! I don’t usually dislike players who are no good lol

I think you might have forgotten the real reason you dislike him. He concussed Murphy in an off the ball "push off" to create some space.

 

[sr36]

Blight and young

Richmond blight?
Who is Young?

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

I’m sure this is bullshit but pleeeeeeeeeease be true lol

 

[gouki88]

Blight and young

Malcolm might be a bit young

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

I think you might have forgotten the real reason you dislike him. He concussed Murphy in an off the ball "push off" to create some space.

Maybe that’s it if I remember that. I just vaguely recall him being a knob. Often knobs have some talent if it can be harnessed. Anyway I’m purely admitting my ignorance here and just spouting crap for the hell of it.

 

[well left]

I’d say the 4 names to have come out are the most Collingwood KPP types you’ll ever see! The fascination with fringe KP talents is definitely alive and well.

• Caminiti = SSP
• Blight = MSD
• Buller = MSD
• Young = mature age RD

Who’s next Edwards from the Bombers?

It’s a valid point.

We just don’t have the capital to go after anything better than this right now.

Of the Telmo it’s probably Blight and Buller.

The point around Caminiti is spot on. If he was worth taking then the Saints would not have paid up to replace him with Silvagni and Aleer. It’s a pass for mine.

Id look at Blight as a free hit upgrade on Dean. Who might make it or might not.

Buller seems like a replacement for Cox as someone that can ruck and go forward.

Neither are earth shattering needle movers at first glance but either was Frampton and Cameron when we traded for them.

 

[peter9789]

I’m sure this is bullshit but pleeeeeeeeeease be true lol

Mumma's boy being shipped off to GWS would be GOLD.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

I’m sure this is bullshit but pleeeeeeeeeease be true lol

The one consolation if Geelong wins a flag is that he won’t be part of it.
Imagine thst

2022 omitted from finals series ( arguably could have got a game but was on the outer with Fly) ,gets traded to Geelong the premier.
2023 Pies win the flag
2024 finally plays a final. Kicks 4 but they lose the prelim.
2025 on the outer again. His club and ex club both in the box seat to meet in the grand final.

 

[riddick78]

I’m sure this is bullshit but pleeeeeeeeeease be true lol

Aintree Giants?? their Auskick team needs a forward.

 

[manicpie]

The one consolation if Geelong wins a flag is that he won’t be part of it.
Imagine thst

2022 omitted from finals series ( arguably could have got a game but was on the outer with Fly) ,gets traded to Geelong the premier.
2023 Pies win the flag
2024 finally plays a final. Kicks 4 but they lose the prelim.
2025 on the outer again. His club and ex club both in the box seat to meet in the grand final.

Ouch, serves him right

 

[Copeland]

Just watched some of his highlights on the AFL app. TD’s longer video is far better.
Good on the lead, thumping kick and can Ruck.
If he’s cheap he’s worth it.

I’m not sure he’d be cheap, has talent.

 

[WanderingDude]

Just watched some of his highlights on the AFL app. TD’s longer video is far better.
Good on the lead, thumping kick and can Ruck.
If he’s cheap he’s worth it.

Lacking wrinkles and not old enough for his first scooter.