Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2026 List Management

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tonga Bob
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I agree with Deathly. He's shown absolutely bugger all since early fluke goals. He lacks composure, he's not clean below his knees, and his kicking is hit and miss.
You may have been able to make an argument that he was our 23rd best player going into last season, but Murphy Reid has clearly gone past him. McVee will easily be better than him. Erasmus has gone past him. Heck, even old mate Banfield is miles ahead of him. I'd probably have Dudley ahead of him too in terms of impacting the game.
He needs a big year or hes going to have a nervous time come September/October.
I reckon you're a bit harsh. His goals weren't flukes - there were not many but there were repeat long distance goals in full flight, real quality wing man stuff. He's been cruelled by injury since. I agree he still has got to prove he can consistently deliver but if he gets his body right I think he can own a wing.
 
I reckon you're a bit harsh. His goals weren't flukes - there were not many but there were repeat long distance goals in full flight, real quality wing man stuff. He's been cruelled by injury since. I agree he still has got to prove he can consistently deliver but if he gets his body right I think he can own a wing.
Agree, he has at times looked like the wing we need with great run and inspiring goals. Don’t know what happened to his kicking last year, perhaps related to that horrible knee injury? But I do love his attack on the ball, he is the opposite of Freddie and Sharp and everyone should be hoping for his return to form as his best makes the team better.
 
O'Driscoll looks a million bucks in preseason prior to an interruption, then takes until the off season to regain that momentum.
Has never once looked like a million bucks when he can’t kick on both sides of his feet
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I saw that as well, maybe it isn’t the full 12 month rehab, was it a full reconstruction or just some stabilising surgery?
No talk about using the SSP to replace him either (except on here).

Will be interesting to see what it says on the injury list when it comes out. When does that usually happen? The week before round one or earlier in pre season?
 
I saw that as well, maybe it isn’t the full 12 month rehab, was it a full reconstruction or just some stabilising surgery?

According to the above link dated August 10, it was a full reconstruction, which would have been some time in mid August.

Will Aschroft - ACL 22 July, AFL return 28 June (can't see any record of him coming back via VFL?)
Darcy Jones - ACL 03 April, VFL return 24 March, AFL return 25 April
Georgiades - ACL 23 April, SANFL return 29 March, AFL return 05 April

It's possible Sturt could get back to the WAFL in July without any setbacks. But he would seem like the type that needs a solid WAFL block before earning an AFL recall, and he might run out of games.
 
Got a pump up from Mr Voss about his preseason recovery.
Voss was asked who he thought were some of the strongest players at the club in terms of pound for pound and he said Sturt. Pretty impressive considering most would consider strength an issue for Sam in the years he has been on our list. I still think Sam's a nice wildcard to have on our list. If he comes good it's a total bonus.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

the more hype I see for this Final Siren documentary, the more I am convinced that Mason Cox is a very astute business move by the club. Fyfe's story is going to be super compelling, our underdog story is going to be memorialised and our sport is going to have a FLOOD of new International (likely mostly American) new followers. It's a natural pipeline for people (Americans) to hey what's this new sport, oh let me follow the club that has an American player.
 
the more hype I see for this Final Siren documentary, the more I am convinced that Mason Cox is a very astute business move by the club. Fyfe's story is going to be super compelling, our underdog story is going to be memorialised and our sport is going to have a FLOOD of new International (likely mostly American) new followers. It's a natural pipeline for people (Americans) to hey what's this new sport, oh let me follow the club that has an American player.
Mason Cox rightfully pointed out the AFL should have given the rights out to the game for free during the Covid lockdowns to the entire world, and was quite audibly frustrated that the AFL didn't even try to maximise the situation, then reap the follow on affects that would have happened from such a move.

Then again - I genuinely don't trust this administration to not do something mega stupid like give all that extra money they could have made to North Melbourne or something.
 
I aim to motivate.
Voss was asked who he thought were some of the strongest players at the club in terms of pound for pound and he said Sturt. Pretty impressive considering most would consider strength an issue for Sam in the years he has been on our list. I still think Sam's a nice wildcard to have on our list. If he comes good it's a total bonus.
Moose took years. Hopefully Sam gets the chance.
 
The comparison with Pearce is fair I think.. Neither are natural footballers, but both have some elite traits. Both copping injuries in the starting phases of their careers.

Lots of upside: low cost, high reward at this stage of Sturts career if he gets a positive report from a return from injury.

Personally I don't quite see how he fits into our current forward line. Maybe an alternative to Amiss would be an option.
 
He's 23 yrs old, has played 30 odd games and shown his best is good enough. He is safe for a while yet. If he is our 23rd best player in 2026 and beyond then we arere right in the hunt. No team has 23 a-graders. Switch on pls.

Also - he loves to tackle. And in a team that simply struggles in that area, i love it!
He shouldn’t be.
Bar a flukey 2022 season, he has been ordinary.
Horrible below the knees, fumbles, isn’t fast and goes missing far too often. Really should get a ultimatum
 
The comparison with Pearce is fair I think.. Neither are natural footballers, but both have some elite traits. Both copping injuries in the starting phases of their careers.

Lots of upside: low cost, high reward at this stage of Sturts career if he gets a positive report from a return from injury.

Personally I don't quite see how he fits into our current forward line. Maybe an alternative to Amiss would be an option.
yeah I'm happy to keep one talented bloke on the injury list to give our rehab people something to do. Been pretty good the last few years generally compared to some in the past going into round 1, e.g.

2019
Harley Bennell (Calf) — TBC
Connor Blakely (Hamstring) — 7-9 weeks
Reece Conca (Knee) — Test
Brennan Cox (Hamstring) — TBC
Hugh Dixon (Hip) — 3 weeks
Bradley Hill (Calf) — TBC
Stephen Hill (Quad) — 3-4 weeks
Shane Kersten (Foot) — 1 week
Griffin Logue (Hamstring) — TBC
Aaron Sandilands (Calf) — TBC
Sam Switkowski (Hamstring) — TBC
Luke Valente (Groin) — 3 weeks
 
Last edited:

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.


According to the above link dated August 10, it was a full reconstruction, which would have been some time in mid August.

Will Aschroft - ACL 22 July, AFL return 28 June (can't see any record of him coming back via VFL?)
Darcy Jones - ACL 03 April, VFL return 24 March, AFL return 25 April
Georgiades - ACL 23 April, SANFL return 29 March, AFL return 05 April

It's possible Sturt could get back to the WAFL in July without any setbacks. But he would seem like the type that needs a solid WAFL block before earning an AFL recall, and he might run out of games.
I don’t believe it was a full rupture. Described as unstable ACL. As such should be a better/quicker outcome than full rupture. In saying that I’d expect early July timeframe, which is 11 months and then a gradual build over the subsequent 4 weeks via managed mins in reserves and league etc.
 
I don’t believe it was a full rupture. Described as unstable ACL. As such should be a better/quicker outcome than full rupture. In saying that I’d expect early July timeframe, which is 11 months and then a gradual build over the subsequent 4 weeks via managed mins in reserves and league etc.
Still enough time to impact if he's good enough and the team is good enough to be playing well into September.

Plenty of players have returned from LTIs later than July and had a massive impact in finals.

Not saying Sturt is the calibre of some of those player but if the role is available at the right time I can still see him coming in and having some impact.
 
No chance we see Sturt at AFL level this year imo.

Coming from too far back, too much competition, and too short a timeframe to break in.
 
No chance we see Sturt at AFL level this year imo.

Coming from too far back, too much competition, and too short a timeframe to break in.
Who knows what the injury list looks like by July. Personally I think we'd consider him if two of the KPFs or rucks were injured and he'd had a month in the WAFL.

Don't think he's really an option anymore replacing a small forward with so many KPFs in the side.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom