- Joined
- Jul 18, 2012
- Posts
- 2,161
- Reaction score
- 3,786
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
One Is a ruck & the other a key defender, so apples & orangesThis won’t go down well but there is a fair argument to say that Cox is a better player than Darcy too

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

One Is a ruck & the other a key defender, so apples & orangesThis won’t go down well but there is a fair argument to say that Cox is a better player than Darcy too

The same coach made the decision to play three tall forwards and two rucks in the same team last year when most on here would've called that stupidity.I'm enjoying the media distraction about Cox. Creates a bit of uncertainty.
If the ultra conservative leaning Longmuir makes the radical decision to play 3 rucks I'd be amazed. It would be a courageous move, and would put his career on the line beyond what is already the case.
A story about Darcy in the ruck, Jackson midfield, and Cox forward may be enough to distract from how our defence is transitioning the ball with the addition of McVee. Or how Amiss is being developed. Or the how the preseason of not-3-million-dollar Reid is going. Or the Epstein files.
Yes I'm hoping we are in ambush mode whichever way this plays out.
What I am actually excited about from what is happening with the rucks is there seems to be a clear push to maximise the impact Jackson can have. He's a game changer.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Brennan looks terrific. He was out there Monday and hasn't missed a session from what I can tell. He's done a ton of extra laps and looks fitter than ever. Hasn't joined in a fair bit of match sims because he's been doing extra laps. Him and Ryan look way fitter than a year ago. Before the Christmas break Ryan was also running a ton of extra laps and hating every minute of it.Worst part about Cox on the team is that I always assume we’re talking of the Brennan kind. As someone who does not care about Mason but would like updates to how Brennan is tracking this upsets me greatly
Thanks mate appreciate the updatesBrennan looks terrific. He was out there Monday and hasn't missed a session from what I can tell. He's done a ton of extra laps and looks fitter than ever. Hasn't joined in a fair bit of match sims because he's been doing extra laps. Him and Ryan look way fitter than a year ago. Before the Christmas break Ryan was also running a ton of extra laps and hating every minute of it.
In the AFLs Fantasy footy list, Sweid is the most expensive of our new recruits.Im going to be the first to call Adam Sweid as being ready to go from Day 1 of the season and right in the frame for early selection. It will be very tough to debut early as I think Dudley and Murray both look fantastic but make no mistake I think Sweid will be right in contention for an early debut. My friend with contacts at the club has told me Sweid was told to ease up on his training as he was pushing himself to the limits with personal training sessions over the break. Possibly why he sat out Mondays session.
There was a damn good reason Reidy couldn't get a look. He was not up to AFL level. At best, a WAFL ruckman.The ruck situation is an interesting one because Riedy could not get a look in (if Jackson or Darcy was injured) and now there is talk of playing 3 rucks…
On another note, has a rule change (5 on the bench) just extended cox’s career by 2 years.
Means nothing except he was a draft pick inside 30 or so.In the AFLs Fantasy footy list, Sweid is the most expensive of our new recruits.
I never play FF or any other make believe footy games, so not sure if that means much.
Joe Brierty told me that we were taking Sweid with our first pick regardless and Murphy with our second pick if available. If we had a top 10 pick I’m assuming that would be a different story but we didn’t.Means nothing except he was a draft pick inside 30 or so.
Having said that, from what I have been told Freo rated Sweid far higher than pick 25 and even near the top 10. Might be they see him as closer to best 23 than would be expected.

now my mind is full of team stats, what do we hope to achieve by becoming the land of the giants by using up our 5th bench spot for another ruck/tall?
In 2025, we had Voss, Amiss, Tracy, and Jackson as excellent marking talls and the team stats show we were:
I50 Marking rate - 18th
In50 marks - 15th
marks on lead - 13th
so Cox is suddenly going to improve that? I would have thought maybe we should bring in an extra player who is good at kicking to leads so we can actually use the talls we already have for better result, like just about everyone else is doing.
No disrespect to the guy, I wish him all the best, but I also wish all the worst for Carlton and every one of their supporters, so yeah hopefully he stinks it up for Carnton and loses them multiple games.There was a damn good reason Reidy couldn't get a look. He was not up to AFL level. At best, a WAFL ruckman.

Or else what?Vote for your favourite game preview of 2025 here: https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/season-2025-game-previews.1392502/
Or else.
Any one know if they will be at Cockburn or Fremantle oval today.
Or have they stopped the Fremantle oval Wednesday thing?
Thanks
Ok, thanks. Guess i will start at Cockburn and work my way down. I just had a couple appointments cancel on me.I tried asking this to other training watches but all they could say was main training is Friday..
Last season it was at east freo oval
Ok, thanks. Guess i will start at Cockburn and work my way down. I just had a couple appointments cancel on me.

Interchanges happen at quarter, half time and three quarter time.No interchange in those match sims either so it's start elsewhere or not play at all (which would make no sense)
Im pretty confident we rated Sweid in the top 15 but thought he would still be available at a pick in the mid 20's judging by the amount of interest he was receiving from other clubs including Essendon. In my opinion that's why we did the McVee trade so easily. Considering the pick we downgraded in that trade started at 12 but was taken at 19 there would appear to be a very good chance we would have bid on (and recruited) Sweid if we didn't downgrade.Joe Brierty told me that we were taking Sweid with our first pick regardless and Murphy with our second pick if available. If we had a top 10 pick I’m assuming that would be a different story but we didn’t.![]()