Beerfish
Unscripted Hot Takes
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2008
- Posts
- 65,107
- Reaction score
- 111,033
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Nic Martin
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

yes they didPosts on page 385 aged well
He's back.
Crazy people wanted to trade him out for a bag of smiths chips.
Fu to ask the haters. He had always been an asset when not carrying injuries. I hope he can have a good crack at it this year. He's like hird the way he reads the ball
I think so too. Delivered a really nice i50 against North as well that stuck out to me, and I'm fairly sure in a game prior to that.Is it just me or does he look like he has tidied up his kicking over his long injury layoff? Kicks look lower, punchier, less floaty and better directed. Will never be Zach Merrett with the ball but he's looked a lot better this season to my eye.
I don’t think so.Is it just me or does he look like he has tidied up his kicking over his long injury layoff? Kicks look lower, punchier, less floaty and better directed. Will never be Zach Merrett with the ball but he's looked a lot better this season to my eye.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
I was ranting about him at half time, but credit where credit is due he was awesome in the 2nd half. He may not be a complete package but when he is in form he has a pretty unique ability to win clearances.Yep i whip Parish
Great game the third quarter was top notch but that's the bar maybe not quite to that extent but he needs to rock up every week
His first 4 games were awful
Is it just me or does he look like he has tidied up his kicking over his long injury layoff? Kicks look lower, punchier, less floaty and better directed. Will never be Zach Merrett with the ball but he's looked a lot better this season to my eye.
Regular kicker of floaters and knuckleballsDarcy isn't a particularly poor kick, his decision making is what lets him down. His action looks technically, ok, albeit rushed at times
This.Regular kicker of floaters and knuckleballs
Not to the same degree as Shiel but historically he’s been average at best
He also leans back and kicks over the head of short targets
Barely cracked the ton in supercoach. Weak!Haters?
If he’s fit and firing, he’s usually consistent. Been a while since those conditions have been metGood to see him play two good games in a row. Hope he keeps it up, for our sake.
15 contestedBOG for Ess - 30 touches
Where’s the room for a team having different roles? I’m not arguing that his defence isn’t deficient, but what about the deficiencies in other mids not winning enough ball or enough clearances? I’d argue that unless you can have a team full of zerretts then you probably want players who balance each others roles. Our midfield was superior to the suns yesterday and did it with frenetic defence and dominant attack.People are getting sucked in again.
Yes he wins footy. His use is just ok - sometimes better than that, especially by hand.
He is a big problem defensively. Never gets out of a jog in transition. What happens when you don’t have the footy matters!
Where’s the room for a team having different roles? I’m not arguing that his defence isn’t deficient, but what about the deficiencies in other mids not winning enough ball or enough clearances? I’d argue that unless you can have a team full of zerretts then you probably want players who balance each others roles. Our midfield was superior to the suns yesterday and did it with frenetic defence and dominant attack.
He’s a decent offensive mid….but not good enough that you accept and work around his defensive deficiencies. He’s not that guy.Where’s the room for a team having different roles? I’m not arguing that his defence isn’t deficient, but what about the deficiencies in other mids not winning enough ball or enough clearances? I’d argue that unless you can have a team full of zerretts then you probably want players who balance each others roles. Our midfield was superior to the suns yesterday and did it with frenetic defence and dominant attack.
Yeah nah. He’s a lot better than decent. Winning the ball hasn’t meant much in his career when his team mates can’t make use of it.He’s a decent offensive mid….but not good enough that you accept and work around his defensive deficiencies. He’s not that guy.
Not sure I agree re midfields yesterday. Petracca and Rowell did plenty of damage.
Agree to disagree.Yeah nah. He’s a lot better than decent. Winning the ball hasn’t meant much in his career when his team mates can’t make use of it.


