Aaron Davey vs Daniel Wells

[FOOOOTY]

Who would you rather have? Whos the better footballer?

 

[blblues]

I voted Davey because he plays more consistent games. I think Wells best is better but we only see that once or twice a season. It's a shame reallly, he has the talent to be one of the greats but i don't think we'll ever see him become more then just a good player.

 

[whelan=legend]

Not even the most mentally challenged of North fans (Spitz) would vote Wells.

 

[DapperDon]

Davey, has been excellent this year. Gone to another level

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Davey, has become elite.

 

[anti.]

davey's consistency puts him above wells.

 

[Grandmaster_B]

Davey by the length of the Nullarbor.

 

[DarwinRoo]

Davey, has become elite.

What exactly makes Davey elite?

 

[Grandmaster_B]

What exactly makes Davey elite?

Best kick in the AFL.
Revolutionised the small forward position.
Can play anywhere on the ground.


A few reasons right there.

 

[HolyWars]

Davey.

 

[DarwinRoo]

Best kick in the AFL.
Revolutionised the small forward position.
Can play anywhere on the ground.


A few reasons right there.

LOL. You are kidding aren't you?

He can play in the Ruck and KP forward and back can he?

8 games does not make you elite.

 

[Godzke]

once again ... another useless poll by comparing a player whose in top form to one whose only just returned to the AFL from a lay off.

good one

 

[GrandBlue]

Davey's elite. Absolutely freakishly good kick, gamebreaker ability, super speed, revolutionized the small forward position and is a rough Brownlow chance. Davey by the length of the West Gate Bridge.

 

[Grandmaster_B]

once again ... another useless poll by comparing a player whose in top form to one whose only just returned to the AFL from a lay off.

good one

Here is another poll that Davey would win in a landslide -

Aaron Davey vs Zaharakis/Stanton/Pears/Monfries/Alwyn/Lovett combined

 

[DarwinRoo]

Davey's elite. Absolutely freakishly good kick, gamebreaker ability, super speed, revolutionized the small forward position and is a rough Brownlow chance. Davey by the length of the West Gate Bridge.

Another misguided fool.

 

[Grandmaster_B]

Another misguided fool.

Wells is finished. Should retire.

Deal with it.

 

[DarwinRoo]

Wells is finished. Should retire.

Deal with it.

Bugger off to Bay 13.

 

[Godzke]

Here is another poll that Davey would win in a landslide -

Aaron Davey vs Zaharakis/Stanton/Pears/Monfries/Alwyn/Lovett combined

hilarious

 

[DapperDon]

Best kick in the AFL. - Hodge, Gilbee or Goddard
Revolutionised the small forward position. - Why is he a midfielder then?
Can play anywhere on the ground.- Can't play ruck or Key position


A few reasons right there.

I'm a massive Davey fan, but you're just being stupid.

 

[cannons]

Another misguided fool.

The word 'another' is interesting here. Another implies that multiple people share the view that you consider to be misguided and foolish. Perhaps this would indicate that you, in fact, are misguided and/or foolish in your assessment of this issue.

 

[whelan=legend]

Another misguided fool.

Ever stop to think that maybe you're the misguided fool, while obviously the vast majority of people are right?

Not one neutral fan has voted for Wells yet. A definitive poll if i've ever seen one.

 

[Collingwoodity]

Close call but I still think that Bryce Gibbs gets the nod.

Na seriously Davey is good and so is wells but I honestly think that if they dont play as midfielders instead of backman other more mediocre talents who did play in the middle will be looked back on as better players (not biased as i think the same for dale thomas). Gameplan of coaches does not help these talented players either.

 

[jacko57]

once again ... another useless poll by comparing a player whose in top form to one whose only just returned to the AFL from a lay off.

good one

But if Davey wins the poll, it makes up for North winning in Round 1, after a couple of these kids had been telling us the Dees were set to blitz.

 

[GrandBlue]

Another misguided fool.

Misguided? Face it, Davey IS elite, watch him play for christ sake. For once in your life, you should look away from your doomed club and look at the ultimate skills of Aaron Davey who is much MUCH better than Daniel Wells at pretty much every position on ground

 

[DarwinRoo]

Misguided? Face it, Davey IS elite, watch him play for christ sake. For once in your life, you should look away from your doomed club and look at the ultimate skills of Aaron Davey who is much MUCH better than Daniel Wells at pretty much every position on ground

No he is not elite? How many elite players do you think are currently playing in the AFL?

Davey has sat his arse in the forward line for most of his career and has hardly come close to being one of the better players in the league and now suddenly after a rich vein of form he is elite. Give me a freaking break.

My doomed club? You do realise you barrack for the Western Bulldogs. You do realise that you recieve more money from the AFL as us and that without the State Government's intervention the club would have been bankrupt.

He is better than Wells in every position in the ground? Explain why Wells has been playing in the midfield since day dot when Davey has been hiding in the FP for 5 years especially considering how good he is.

Judd is elite, Ablett is elite, Bartel is elite, Cox is elite. Davey is not.