Andrew Walker OR play a man down

[Silvagnis]

Probably because he is held in such high regard at Carlton. Yes they have lots of good young players coming through, no he is not one of them.

Since you're a dog, do you manage to get your head down there after you post crap like this?

A Dockers fan isn't qualified to point the finger at another club and say they made poor choices.

 

[Silvagnis]

The little excerpt you just provided me demostrates exactly why Walker is more disappointing.

Do you even watch football?

The fact that the ensuing 4 choices also overlooked Tenace goes to show that he was most definately not regarded in the same esteem as the earlier choices. Hence, his failure to come on as a promising young player is less disappointing than Walker's.

I really hope that helps you sleep at night when Tenace is delisted this year or the next. It will only get uglier for Geelong when Stanton wins his first best and fairest and Butler plays in another Grand Final.

It is also less disappointing from the perspective that Geelong used pick 7, whilst Carlton had to use pick 2. I think it is fairly clear which Club got less bang for their buck, particularly considering that the Blues could have Brock McLean.

I think Melbourne got less bang for their buck because they picked Sylvia when they should have taken Mclean.

Walker is an out and out gun despite your uninformed comments.

A stuff up would have been taking Clarke, Tenace or Dunn ahead of better players.

 

[Rhys87]

what a joke!

he will shut everyone up by the end of this year!

 

[Demonic Ascent]

Thats just straight out of wikipedia.

??

I wrote that myself.

 

[Pavlov's Dog]

A Dockers fan isn't qualified to point the finger at another club and say they made poor choices.

Surely we are over qualified

 

[bzparkes]

He'd be in your top-5 players - easily - and would be in every teams starting lineup...

He wouldn't even be in an AusKick starting lineup

 

[Claude Balls]

He wouldn't even be in an AusKick starting lineup

He actually dominated Auskick, that's why the Blues took him at pick 2

 

[Claude Balls]

'Play a man down' is going away with it...

 

[Demonheart]

Actually I had no highlights last year

Could've fooled me, the way you're posting about last year I'm surprised you didn't get the keyboard all wet and sticky.

 

[mediumsizered]

Could've fooled me, the way you're posting about last year I'm surprised you didn't get the keyboard all wet and sticky.

I can only assume you are talking from personal experience.

 

[The Grover]

As ive said before, hes a poor mans Simon Godfrey. Atleast Godfrey is regarded as a good tagger. Walker is even a worse kick than him, something I never thought id see.
Mclean>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Godfrey>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Werribee sh.it farm>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>.Walker.

You are a ****************, ask every coach in the AFL Walker or Godfrey the vote 16-0 in favour of Walker, even Neale voted for Walker.

 

[Claude Balls]

You are a ****************, ask every coach in the AFL Walker or Godfrey the vote 16-0 in favour of Walker, even Neale voted for Walker.

Godfrey for me. He doesn't represent as big a liability as Walker. I know Walker is more athletic, but Godfrey is a slightly better tagger due to his superior footy smarts. I think you'll find that AFL coaches are less impressed by a few flashy runs down the wing than your average Carlton supporter and thus the vote would probably be more like 8-8, or even 9-7 in Godfrey's favour.

 

[Pavlov's Dog]

You are a ****************, ask every coach in the AFL Walker or Godfrey the vote 16-0 in favour of Walker, even Neale voted for Walker.

I think most coaches would rather have a Godfrey, a no-nonsense workhorse who can do a tagging job and won't turn the ball over at every opportunity. Unlike one-eyed supporters, good coaches can see past a flashy piece of play and focus more on the football aspect of the play.

 

[Melbdave81]

Claude, we should start a poll, support Geelong or follow netball?

 

[Claude Balls]

Claude, we should start a poll, support Geelong or follow netball?

Good joke nerd

 

[Silvagnis]

22 kicks to be the most effective player on the ground by foot with 19 effective kicks proves he is a terrible kick.

He wouldn't even be in an AusKick starting lineup

Matt Rosa would be running around in the WAFL if Walker was on your list.

 

[Thrawn]

All these stupid threads bagging younger players will backfire on them.

 

[Claude Balls]

All these stupid threads bagging younger players will backfire on them.

Will backfire on the players?

 

[parrot]

Andrew Walker is elite top-shelf talent, and now starting to show it on a consistent basis. Clearly the best from the 2003 draft. Amazing talent.

 

[dutchy12]

Andrew Walker is elite top-shelf talent, and now starting to show it on a consistent basis. Clearly the best from the 2003 draft. Amazing talent.

Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

He's still improving which is suprising cause he's actually had the most games out of any from the 2003 crop playing in such a depleted team early in his career still yet Brock McLean + Adam Cooney IMO is very much ahead of him.

 

[Beloved]

anyone who doubts him can go to hell. Hes amazing

 

[mark73]

22 kicks to be the most effective player on the ground by foot with 19 effective kicks proves he is a terrible kick.

But would be in Geelong's top 5 players? If we're talking reserves the poster who stated such "might" be onto something.

Matt Rosa would be running around in the WAFL if Walker was on your list.

Lolzass

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Walker has undoubtedly improved. Previously he couldn't kick at all, now he just can't kick while running.

 

[lookkg386]

best game yet

 

[blueheart]

Starting to get a little embarrassing for you now Claude