Opinion Answer a question ask a question

[The King!]

Thought a few more discussions would be good on here, but delete mods if its not appropriate.

But how about answer the question above on the swans or the comp in general then ask a question the next poster answers then asks one and so on

Ill start by asking is shane mumford a chance be the best player post their career with the swans? Been plenty of good players leave for long careers, who is currently the best?

 

[RW]

If current players only, I'd say Sean Dempster has had a pretty solid career with the Saints... but Mumford could do very well at the Giants if he stays fit.

Who out of our 2013 draftees do you think will make their senior debut first?

 

[The King!]

If current players only, I'd say Sean Dempster has had a pretty solid career with the Saints... but Mumford could do very well at the Giants if he stays fit.

Who out of our 2013 draftees do you think will make their senior debut first?

Zak jones looks a likely type, im bullish on allir and hewett i have no idea about so ill guess jones

My next question- Will we win the 2014 premiership

 

[scaryness]

My next question- Will we win the 2014 premiership

We always start slow, but on current form you would have to say we are no chance. Of course, it's only April.

Will Ryan O'Keefe play 300 games? He needs 16.

 

[The King!]

We always start slow, but on current form you would have to say we are no chance. Of course, it's only April.

Will Ryan O'Keefe play 300 games? He needs 16.

Yes he will, he wont be chopped as quick as some on this board want


Is the full forward position in football dead forever?

 

[S120]

Yes he will, he wont be chopped as quick as some on this board want


Is the full forward position in football dead forever?

It isn't what it used to be, but who gives a ****.

Over or under on Adam Goodes playing 10.5 games this year?

 

[Superstar swan]

It isn't what it used to be, but who gives a ****.

Over or under on Adam Goodes playing 10.5 games this year?

Under, I think he will be managed through the year and possibly play 6 or 7 late to get ready for finals.

Barring paddy Mitchell because he is new to the game and must be given a chance, which swan do you think has the least chance of succeeding at afl level??

 

[robbieando]

Great idea SR

Jordan Lockyer purely because of his position, size and the length of time spent on the list already. Would like to be proven wrong though.

Draft wise (and forget where we would be picking) what would be the number area to target - ruck, key position defender or midfielder?

 

[GoTheSwannies]

skip..

 

[Superstar swan]

Key position defender. Really need to add some depth their. Can never have enough kpp in my book.

Parker or Tom Mitchell , who will have the greater influence on this club and the greater career?

 

[GoTheSwannies]

Key position defender. Really need to add some depth their. Can never have enough kpp in my book.

Parker or Tom Mitchell , who will have the greater influence on this club and the greater career?

Really tough question, but I'd say Parker, cause he's an absolute wrecking ball

which senior player (say 28+) will be first to be pushed out of our best 22?

 

[The King!]

I'd have to go Daniel Robinson, he's a midfielder, who are a dime a dozen, and he's a fair way down a long list of players. But in saying that, I know very little about him, and wish him all the best. Tough question btw.

Which current senior player (as in the older brigade, say 28+) will be the first to be pushed out of the best 22, and will it happen in 2014?

Okeefe if goodes gets back as he forces him out so yeah in 2014

Ill say tom mitchell over luke parker ss


My question who is the best captain since we moved to sydney and why

 

[GoTheSwannies]

wtf... I obviously suck at this game lol... continue

 

[Superstar swan]

Okeefe if goodes gets back as he forces him out so yeah in 2014

Ill say tom mitchell over luke parker ss


My question who is the best captain since we moved to sydney and why

Tie between Brett Kirk and Paul Kelly. Both were nothing short of inspirational. Truly played swans football and are a big reason why the club is respected today

 

[The King!]

wtf...

I answered two cos i went out of order sorry

Got no answer for wtf tho

 

[Superstar swan]

Will we win a flag in the next 9 years and if so when??

 

[GoTheSwannies]

I answered two cos i went out of order sorry

Got no answer for wtf tho

lol, I was referring to myself with the wtf, I got beaten to the punch, then i tried to correct it and hit reply instead of edit and messed the whole thing up.

I understand you were just getting things back on track.

Sorry guys.

Carry on

 

[GoTheSwannies]

I'll say yes, 2015. We will win a second, but I haven't decided when the next will be.

Who out of GWS & GC will be first to a GF appearance?

 

[Superstar swan]

I'll say yes, 2015. We will win a second, but I haven't decided when the next will be.

Who out of GWS & GC will be first to a GF appearance?

Gws , far too much talent to be ignored.

Will we have an any all Australians this year??

 

[GoTheSwannies]

Gws , far too much talent to be ignored.

Will we have an any all Australians this year??

That was a trick question, everyone knows both GWS & GC will contest every flag between 2017-2020.

Yes, Buddy & Parker

Who will win the coleman

 

[Number37]

Buddy.

Who should be our next captain?

 

[robbieando]

Smith

Do we think the AFL screw us over and do a deal with ANZ Stadium to play finals in Sydney there forcing us in turn to do a deal ourselves?

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Really tough question, but I'd say Parker, cause he's an absolute wrecking ball

which senior player (say 28+) will be first to be pushed out of our best 22?

Shaw replaced by Biggs.

 

[GoTheSwannies]

Shaw replaced by Biggs.

lol, late to the party and didn't follow the answer question protocol. Ban this man!!

 

[GoTheSwannies]

Who will be the first big name player we lose to a Melbourne-based club, if any?