Best and Worst Callers (Radio + TV)

[KeithBlight]

Ben Allan and Tim Gossage

Ben is on the Freo board but constantly cheers against the club.

Gossage is an idiot! Loud, biased and stupid.

Anagram of TIM GOSSAGE; EMITS GO-GAS... apt.

I actually rate Tony Leonard on 3AW. Gets a bit excited and out of breath at times, which is entertaining, but doesn't come out with corny (and over the top) Dwayne Russell style sayings. Just calls the action.

 

[Benno_900]

TV
Best - Brian Taylor

Wowee!

 

[Willsy82]

Gossage is an idiot! Loud, biased and stupid.

You said it, he sure does think the sun shines outa his arse.

Also cant stand him and lachy reid on the Western Front, when i see ppl making the 'W' sign, i see red

 

[Buzzasto DaSilva]

TV
Best - Anthony Hudson/Michael Christian/Brian Taylor
Worst - Dwayne Russell

Radio
Best - James Brayshaw
Worst - Rex Hunt

 

[Adelaide Hawk]

TV
Best: Anthony Hudson
Worst: Far too many to choose from

Radio
Best: Karl Langdon
Worst: Rex Hunt

 

[Geelong Fella]

TV
Best: Dennis Cometti
Worst: Tim Lane

Radio
Best: Rex Hunt/Tim Gossage (quite entertaining, the way he just laughs at everything )
Worst: Brian Taylor and Tim Lane

 

[SpecialComments]

TV
Best: 3 votes Dennis Cometti, 2 Bruce McAvaney, 1 Anthony Hudson
Worst: 3 votes Dwayne Russell, 2 Tim Lane, 1 Brian Taylor

Radio
Best: 3 votes Gerard Whatley, 2 James Brayshaw 1 Rex Hunt
Worst: 3 votes Smokey Dawson, 2 Tim Lane, 1 Brian Taylor

 

[avanauts]

Absolutely love Rex Hunt and Brian Taylor. Offer a lot more than most other commentators and aren't so generic as a lot are. Whenever they give opinions they aren't as useless as Robert Walls who bores me to death with his Captain Obvious like statements.

 

[HARPSichord]

Best overall would have to be Gerard Whately. I dislike many commentators including: Dennis Cometti and Bruce McAvaney. Their constant freakiness towards players freaks me out, especially Bruce's love of Cyril and Yarran. Also don't like BT as he and his Fox colleagues no nothing about North Melbourne.

 

[Supermercado]

I like Hudson on both. Don't mind Hamish McLachlan on the radio even he makes me stabby on TV.

Worst is Dwayne by the length of the straight from Darcy. On radio I avoid Drew Morphett like the plague because he's a whingy old git.

 

[Toshowyouwhy]

Russel is clearly the worst. But I reckon BT is catching up. He's not funny, he's not clever, he's just a sexually confused man who ruins games of football with his homoerotic calls.

 

[DREAM TEAM BUFF]

Radio
Best : Chris Dittmar and Shane McInnes
Worst : Kym Dillon and Tony Leonard

Tv
Best : Anthony Hudson
Worst : Dennis Cometti

 

[handy point]

Whately is streets ahead in the radio stakes.

Tim Lane has gone from one of the best a decade ago to one of the worst since his move to television.

Exactly what you said.

 

[Shade]

Best - Michael Christian & Matthew Lloyd & Dunstall
Worst - Dwayne Russel & Matt Campbell

 

[Those]

Best - Anthony Hudson
Worst - Matthew Campbell

Special comments

Best - Matthew Lloyd
Worst - Luke Darcy

 

[tek87]

Radio

Best Main Caller: Anthony Hudson
Worst Main Caller: Karl Langdon

Best Special Comments: Chris Connolly
Worst Special Comments: Tony Shaw

TV

Best Main Caller : Brian Taylor
Worst Main Caller: Tim Lane

Best Special Comments: Gerard Healy
Worst Special Comments: Tony Shaw

 

[42DM]

Cometti best TV caller by a mile.
BT the worst, should be restricted to commenting on the Gay Mardi Gras.

Gerard Whately, gets my vote on the Radio.
BT for the daily double.

Gerard Healey best special comments man overall.
Tony Shaw and Glen Jakovich get the nod for being the worst.