Bock Vs Silvagni

[Rough_Edges]

Who is the better player?


Bock for me, much better dream team player.

 

[SA Blue]

Very odd and very sad poll.

 

[Knife Wrench]

Bock...only coz i had him in DT this year

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Bock is a useless chinese vegetable.

Neither.

 

[mightymightyblues]

Bock is a useless chinese vegetable.

Neither.

worst poll EVER

 

[pickman]

One good year does not warrant comparisons to Stephen Silvagni, the fullback of the century.

Looking forward to the next poll - Cameron Cloke v Polly Farmer

 

[Juddernaut08]

One good year does not warrant comparisons to Stephen Silvagni, the fullback of the century.

Looking forward to the next poll - Cameron Cloke v Polly Farmer

Can you not make such dumb comparisons? Cam is a full 4cm taller; 5kg stronger; and has won the prestigous NAB cup! How can you even mention the two in the same sentence? Next you'll be telling me Ablett Jr. is harder than butter (warm butter btw).

 

[Rough_Edges]

Bock is a useless chinese vegetable.

Neither.

2007 board.

 

[guitar god]

too early to call yet, bock is a good player, best half back at the moment but wait til bock retires then make the comparison.

 

[Willow_2000]

This poll is an insult

 

[pickman]

This poll is an insult

Yes and at the time of writing there are 10 voters that know little about AFL

 

[sifo]

whoever voted for bock should be fuking ashamed of urselves, silvagni is the full back of the century and by making this poll and comparing him to bock u r insulting his name a playing abilities.....for shame

 

[slippery crow]

stupid poll

not comparing apples to apples

SOS played mostly as FB and was named FB of the century

Bock played this year his 1st year at CHB

for Bock to be considered in he same breath as SOS, Bock needs to back this season up with 4-5 high quality seasons

 

[Ebert80]

Silvagni is over rated but hes certainly a class above Bock.

 

[parrot]

Who's Bock? lol.

 

[jonoman89]

Bock. Definitely Bock. Silvagni was never consistent, never went to the best forward, and never stood up in the finals.

 

[Gozz]

Could people who despise Carlton stop giving their votes to Bock to in an attempt to make us feel bad and just not vote at all if you hate us so much.

 

[Optus Penguin]

WTF kind of thread is this. Is this a cheap shot or are you incredibly biased you should be ashamed. Dream team.....WTF does that matter.

 

[Jimi]

Trolled

 

[BILC]

stupid poll

 

[BlueZippy]

Bock is a once in a lifetime player.

BOCK > ALL

 

[RU486]

Who is the better player?


Bock for me, much better dream team player.

Your a nutter!

 

[Thrawn]

Bock. Bock. Bock.

 

[Team Mo']

Bock. Bock. Bock.

haha gold!

Bock? Silvagni would turn over in his grave once he dies if he heard this.

 

[Thrawn]

Alby_Green, Barry Zuckercorn QC, Big Nasty, C-Dog, Campbell's Chunky, Crowboy#32, DemonErrol1964 - dees, DirrtyBee, flackjack, guitar god, jvtostinha, Knife Wrench, Kram81, macca69, Maestro15, Magic17, Rough_Edges, skankfest, Southerntakeover, windyhill

Not surprised by the ones in bold. One's cat got run over by Silvagni, the other thinks Lloyd has the wood on him.

But Barry?!

His age must be getting to him.