Buddy or Fev

[jacko_boy]

Who would you take? age is irrelevent

 

[Hawks1523]

I think Buddy is more talented, but Fevola has a better more accurate kick on him then Buddy does.

 

[Upgrayedd]

I see Franklin pass now and then, He aint no Cam Mooney/Pavlich in giving team-mates goals anytime he can, but hell he'll give 1-2 a game to do the team thing and try to get other blokes in the game, I dont see Fevola do that at all.

Kicking Fevola is a dead eye dick, but Franklin is MUCH more talented then Fevola, ild take Franklin every day of the week

 

[walshy93]

Fev's consistancy.

 

[Thrawn]

If age is irrelevant, then I would take Fevola because he can kick at goal a lot better.

However, if one takes age into consideration then I'd take Buddy in a heartbeat.

I see Franklin pass now and then, He aint no Cam Mooney/Pavlich in giving team-mates goals anytime he can, but hell he'll give 1-2 a game to do the team thing and try to get other blokes in the game, I dont see Fevola do that at all.

Perhaps it's because you don't watch too many Carlton games? Fevola's defensive pressure in particular has been awesome this year, especially his run down tackles. If you want a really good example watch Round 4 Carlton vs Collingwood.

 

[Richo is God]

fev cos he is more accurate.

Quote:
I see Franklin pass now and then, He aint no Cam Mooney/Pavlich in giving team-mates goals anytime he can, but hell he'll give 1-2 a game to do the team thing and try to get other blokes in the game, I dont see Fevola do that at all.

he doesnt mean to do it, its because he has mongrelled a shot on goal and its fallen (by chance) to a hawks player

 

[BUSTER29]

Have to be Fev. If he was playing for Hawthorn he would have kicked a ton already. Franklins inaccuracy will hurt the hawks in the finals.

 

[Athomas]

I see Franklin pass now and then, He aint no Cam Mooney/Pavlich in giving team-mates goals anytime he can, but hell he'll give 1-2 a game to do the team thing and try to get other blokes in the game, I dont see Fevola do that at all.

Kicking Fevola is a dead eye dick, but Franklin is MUCH more talented then Fevola, ild take Franklin every day of the week

You obviously don't watch any Carlton matches then.

Watch the first goal against Brisbane.

I voted Fev due to bias, would be extremely close imo. Franklin is more talented athletically, but Fevola is a better kick, both take good contested marks, both give lots of frees away.

 

[jonoman89]

Different players with different abilities.

Fev better at kicking goals, Buddy better at getting own ball etc. Depends on what your team needs.

Fev has more x-factor though in my opinion, some of the shit he does is just rediculous.

 

[efcboy]

buddy has the ability to play and excel in any position on the ground. franklin for mine.

 

[hawks_time]

Different players with different abilities.

Fev better at kicking goals, Buddy better at getting own ball etc. Depends on what your team needs.

Fev has more x-factor though in my opinion, some of the shit he does is just rediculous.

I'll give you kicking at goals, but Buddy has more of an 'x-factor' than Fev.