List Mgmt. Cam McCarthy Requests Trade to WA

[Clems Knee]

Yeah but don't think we can use it now after using our 2nd

We'll give you our future second round.
You give us 9, 13 and future 1st round
And I would still be pissed off to lose Lachie Neale.

 

[simpsonwillo]

Don't know what all this Weller trade talk is all about. The club has slready stated he ain't for sale and neither is Neale and rightly so.

 

[theGav56]

So your willing to give up the next Sam Mitchell who is already a game winner and huge potential for a 20 yr old who's played 20 games?

Sure would. Like I said, if Neale wanted to go, that is a good offer.

 

[Bicco]

So your willing to give up the next Sam Mitchell who is already a game winner and huge potential for a 20 yr old who's played 20 games?

Lachie is good but he ain't Sam Mitchell. 9 + 13 for a player taken in the 50's which would get us the forward we need and a pick higher than we've had in years is a great deal. BF BS I know but if it was real you'd have to take it.

 

[Unique Name]

I actually think Bennell will make Mayne look a whole extra grade better next season, plus he is out of contract so big year coming up.

Is Bennell going to be our kicking coach as well?

Mayne does everything well apart from his set shots on goal. He knows where to lead, he can take a mark, he runs all game, he applies pressure and can lay a great tackle.

But his set shot on goal is atrocious and let's him down even when there is no pressure. Bennell could deliver the ball lace out 30m in front of goal but it's on Mayne to finish.





Freo were in front when he went for each of these shots, each one about 30m out from goal so not exactly what you would call a pressure shot. IMO he needs to go back to Peel to regain his confidence in front of the big sticks. A decent forward coach that could help him wouldn't go astray either.

 

[theGav56]

Hi Schwabbie.

I think there are times when trading is the right strategy, and other times it isn't.

 

[Clems Knee]

I think there are times when trading is the right strategy, and other times it isn't.

Yep. I just think two mid first round picks is unders for an up and coming midfield star who is in contract and doesn't want to go anywhere.

 

[Freo Shark]

Folks this isnt a friggin auction!
Neale for essentially McCarthy. Pick 9 is speculative.
Neale is a gun player and will get AA+'s. You trade him for part of a Hogan deal not for f'ing McCarthy. Hes a good player but not a Pav replacement.

I think we are losing the plot a little. Jesse is out of contract in two yrs and 12mths time is probably the time to have a go.
Neale = say equiv 9 & 13. Plus our first and then 2017 1st then we half way there.

 

[theGav56]

Hi Schwabbie.

Actually I possibly would go the full Schwabbie and offer 9, 13 and Weller for Hogan.

 

[Clarko95]

Lachie is good but he ain't Sam Mitchell. 9 + 13 for a player taken in the 50's which would get us the forward we need and a pick higher than we've had in years is a great deal. BF BS I know but if it was real you'd have to take it.

Lachie is only 22 he still has all the attributes of someone like Mitchell
And in a year or 2 who replaces Mundy and then in the near future after that Barlow. Even once sandi is done the mids will be even more important as we won't always have first hands.

And a great forward is only as good as the guys delivering it

 

[Deathly]

Oh god, Neale trade suggestions again...

 

[scon]

Lachie is only 22 he still has all the attributes of someone like Mitchell

He's not Evil.

 

[Arcassius]

For what it's worth, Neale's manager hasn't spoken to anyone regarding Neale - suggestions that he's had offers thrown his way are full of shit

 

[Clarko95]

He's not Evil.

Ahaha yes good point

 

[Doggy doo doo]

Ross just received a letter from GWS stating they will not trade Cam......he's not happy

 

[Kram]

Geez some people need to calm down for a lad that's only played a few good games..

Also for about the 100th time sure he's tall but he isn't really 'key' position.

 

[Taylor]

Is Bennell going to be our kicking coach as well?

Mayne does everything well apart from his set shots on goal. He knows where to lead, he can take a mark, he runs all game, he applies pressure and can lay a great tackle.

But his set shot on goal is atrocious and let's him down even when there is no pressure. Bennell could deliver the ball lace out 30m in front of goal but it's on Mayne to finish.





Freo were in front when he went for each of these shots, each one about 30m out from goal so not exactly what you would call a pressure shot. IMO he needs to go back to Peel to regain his confidence in front of the big sticks. A decent forward coach that could help him wouldn't go astray either.

I'm expecting such an obvious thing to be fixed by the coaching team in the off season. Jonny Wilkinson style taking shots every day

 

[theGav56]

Oh god, Neale trade suggestions again...

It is the off season. Speculation happens. And in recent times some amazing trades have come to pass.

 

[purplerunsdeep]

For what it's worth, Neale's manager hasn't spoken to anyone regarding Neale - suggestions that he's had offers thrown his way are full of shit

Does that make me full of shit?

 

[theGav56]

I'm expecting such an obvious thing to be fixed by the coaching team in the off season. Jonny Wilkinson style taking shots every day

I hope so.

 

[Freo Shark]

2016 might not be a bad year for mini rebuild. Say we slide to round 8 or 9th spot +/- gets a decent pick. The 2017yr pick starts about there.

 

[Unique Name]

I'm expecting such an obvious thing to be fixed by the coaching team in the off season. Jonny Wilkinson style taking shots every day

We had the same criticisms of Mayne's set shots last season too.

He has this robotic regimented routine and it's failed him for the last two seasons.

 

[Clarko95]

Someone on fox's live chat made a good point when I went through the comments

Why don't we bid 22 on himmelberg and **** GWS right over since they're really keen on him

 

[im_a_lazy_sod]

Freo trade Weller to Adelaide and 1st round pick in 2016. Adelaide pick pick 9 to GWS and Walker to Freo. GWS McCarthy to Adelaide.

#plzmakeithappen

 

[Taylor]

We had the same criticisms of Mayne's set shots last season too.

He has this robotic regimented routine and it's failed him for the last two seasons.

It looks to me like his last step is too long, causing him to lean back on the kick.

But what do I know

You hear me Chris?