Unofficial Preview Changes & pre match discussion vs Fremantle

[Flawed Genius]

Combens injury is of concern - Wawson emergency flight?

 

[Rod Stroker]

I assume one of the Dawson's in for Chom

 

[Chadwiko]

What the changes SHOULD be:

OUT: Comben (inj), Wardlaw (omit), Powell (omit), Larkey (omit), RHJ (omit)
IN: Wil Dawson, Harvey, BANCH, Phillips, Maley

What the changes WILL be:

OUT: Comben (inj), RHJ (omit)
IN: Wil Dawson, Harvey

EDITED my post because I'm a bloody idiot who mixed up our MSD recruits and meant 'Banch', not Trembath as I originally had. Anyone who made fun of me because of this was correct to do so, and I deserved it

 

[Chadwiko]

Just as a refresher, the VFL stats from yesterday;

 

[SnowRoo]

I seriously hope a 21 tackle 22 possesion game is rewarded!

Mattlock in for Chom.
WilPhil in for RHJ
Harvey in for Fish

 

[King Hansen]

Out: Wardlaw
In: WP

 

[LETSGOKANGAS]

Whats Chom looking at? Big loss.

 

[CarnaKangas]

What the changes SHOULD be:

OUT: Comben (inj), Wardlaw (omit), Powell (omit), Larkey (omit), RHJ (omit)
IN: Wil Dawson, Harvey, Trembath, Phillips, Maley

What the changes WILL be:

OUT: Comben (inj), RHJ (omit)
IN: Wil Dawson, Harvey

I don't see why anyone would discuss dropping Wardlaw/Powell/Larkey. Wardlaw, if he is fit has to keep playing AFL and developing. Powell is clearly one of the better midfielders at the club currently. Larkey is Larkey, he is playing poorly but he will turn it around. If the club actually dropped those three for next week, I'd think Clarkson has lost the plot.

For me
Out: Comben, Fisher
In: K Dawson, Phillips

 

[gokangas]

Combens injury is of concern - Wawson emergency flight?

Anyone see the Flying Doctor evacuating him?

 

[the big lebowski]

Has to be Phillips in for Wardlaw

K Dawson in for Chom

Banch in for Fisher

RHJ to sub again

 

[Chadwiko]

I don't see why anyone would discuss dropping Wardlaw/Powell/Larkey. Wardlaw, if he is fit has to keep playing AFL and developing. Powell is clearly one of the better midfielders at the club currently. Larkey is Larkey, he is playing poorly but he will turn it around. If the club actually dropped those three for next week, I'd think Clarkson has lost the plot.

Agree to disagree on basically all those points.

 

[Flawed Genius]

Out Comben & Fisher
In W.Dawson & Phillips

 

[Possession]

Reckon we actually show up for this one now that we're not playing our Jungian shadow selves in West Coast.

 

[kool kangas]

Out Comben, Fisher & RHJ
In W.Dawson, Phillips & Harvey (sub)

l wouldn't mind Ford playing but l can't see another player Clarko will drop...

 

[My Left Foote]

Out: Preferential favouritism
In: Integrity and meritocracy

 

[StazMob]

What the changes SHOULD be:

OUT: Comben (inj), Wardlaw (omit), Powell (omit), Larkey (omit), RHJ (omit)
IN: Wil Dawson, Harvey, Trembath, Phillips, Maley

What the changes WILL be:

OUT: Comben (inj), RHJ (omit)
IN: Wil Dawson, Harvey

Trembath who's played 1 VFL game and local footy most of the year? Usually appreciate your calls but way off on that one

 

[DunderHead]

Comben looked like he copped that knee to his upper back. Not sure what injury will end up being.

If he is out, then maybe play Ford and go a little shorter in the backline.

 

[Mute Point]

Never seen him play a minute but I'd bring Banch in as sub over RHJ. Couldn't be any worse

 

[backtothedraft]

What the changes SHOULD be:

OUT: Comben (inj), Wardlaw (omit), Powell (omit), Larkey (omit), RHJ (omit)
IN: Wil Dawson, Harvey, Trembath, Phillips, Maley

What the changes WILL be:

OUT: Comben (inj), RHJ (omit)
IN: Wil Dawson, Harvey

Work your magic for me and justify bringing Trembath in

 

[Shermanator]

Out: Konstanty, RJH, Comben
In: Banch, WillPhill, Matlock

 

[tommy_uman]

No reason why Whitlock shouldn't come in over Corr/Dawson's. Has shown he is AFL quality and the one game he had was not a fair opportunity to show it.

 

[Waynesworld]

Both RHJ and Stephens defensive efforts and pathetic spoiling efforts could (should) have cost us the game on multiple occasions today, neither should ever be seen in a NMFC jumper again.

Don’t really care who comes in for them, couple of the tackers from the half time game could bring more pressure.

 

[the big lebowski]

No reason why Whitlock shouldn't come in over Corr/Dawson's. Has shown he is AFL quality and the one game he had was not a fair opportunity to show it.

Did you watch the vfl? K Dawson was 8 times as good

 

[Chip Scab1]

Out Comben & Fisher
In W.Dawson & Phillips

Out: Comben, Fisher, Darling, Hansen Jr, Dyldo, CDaniel
In: MWhitlock, Philip, Banch, Urquhart, WDawson, Duursma

-------------

B: Logue Pink LMAC
HB: FOS Whitlock Hardeman
C: McKercher LDU Duursma
HF:Zurhaar WDawson Curtis
F:Konstanty Larkey Simpkin
R: Xerri Sheezel Wardlaw
IC: Parker Powell Urquhart Phillip
Sub: Banchee

Em: Archer Goater Comben* Goad

 

[roos_fanatic08]

Out: Konstanty (omitted), Fisher (omitted), RHJ (omitted), Comben (inj), Wardlaw (rested - 6 day break)

In: Harvey Jnr, Banch, Ford, Whitlock, Phillips

I’d also like a way to get another tall in, but not sure how we’d squeeze that.

F: Banch, Larkey, Harvey
HF: Curtis, Darling, Zurhaar
C: Stephens, Parker, Sheezel
HB: Daniel, Logue, McKercher
B: Whitlock, Pink, McDonald
Foll: Xerri, LDU, Simpkin
Int: Powell, Phillips, FOS, Hardeman
Sub: Ford