Preview Changes: R19 v Carlton

[StonesThrow]

******* Andy Otten, we’ve still got 2 fully sized KPDs plus Kelly. Wouldn’t this be an opportunity to go into a game with just the 2 KPDs and see if we can generate a bit more run out of our backline? fu** that selection committee, they’ve got no ******* idea at all. Full of belief, but not a single idea.

The thing is we've got 4 players who are all capable of generating run out of defence (Smith, Milera, Seed and Laird). We've lost the game plan to execute this and instead go with the kick across goal to the tallest and slowest hand to foot players in the team.

 

[Glenno23]

I don't blame Mackay for his selection. I don't even hate on him. It's not his fault he keeps getting picked. His numbers should say enough. WTF are we all missing?

Otten in? Wowsers.

I won't be renewing for next year. And i will state selections and lack of foresight as the reasons for my non-renewal. I'll still watch the Crows, but i won't financially support them until i see PROPER changes across the board. Coaches and philosophies

Got to hit them in the hip pocket

 

[JackBero]

FULL TEAM LINEUP FROM AFL.COM.AU IS AS FOLLOWS

ADELAIDE CROWS

B

Luke Brown | Daniel Talia | Kyle Hartigan

HB

Brodie Smith | Jake Kelly | Rory Laird

C

Riley Knight | Rory Sloane | Wayne Milera

HF

Brad Crouch | Taylor Walker | Tom Lynch

F

Lachlan Murphy | Josh Jenkins | Tyson Stengle

FOLLOWERS

• Reilly O'Brien,
• Matt Crouch,
• Patrick Wilson

INTERCHANGE

• Paul Seedsman,
• David Mackay,
• Rory Atkins,
• Andy Otten

EMERGENCY

• Sam Jacobs,
• Richard Douglas,
• Darcy Fogarty,
• Alex Keath

IN

• Tyson Stengle,
• Patrick Wilson,
• Andy Otten

OUT

• Hugh Greenwood (Omitted),
• Eddie Betts (Omitted),
• Alex Keath (Managed)

 

[Geoffa32]

Surely if we were replacing Greenwood this was a perfect chance to bring back Jones, Gallucci or even try Fogarty up forward....?

I guess I just don't rate Wilson at all and don't see a future for him at AFL level. On top of that, he'll probably get the graveyard shift and look atrocious and offer nothing because the only spot he can play is inside mid (and we won't play him there)

I would have gone Fog for Greenwood with Wilson for Knight.

Knight is still second grabbing and his defensive efforts poor.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

[Redleg Crow]

How the F is Mackay still in?

How the F did they not dump 4-5 players after that shite?

How does Gooch go from being concussed at a point when we are leading against Port to now not being best 22?

 

[1970crow]

Perfect replacement for a week.

Don’t be stupid. But I did give you warning. 2 KPDs plus Kelly is enough, we did not need to bring in Otten. But we do revert to experience when the chips are down and we lost Eddie, so he had to be replaced with equivalent experience level.

 

[King Elvis]

******* Andy Otten, we’ve still got 2 fully sized KPDs plus Kelly. Wouldn’t this be an opportunity to go into a game with just the 2 KPDs and see if we can generate a bit more run out of our backline? fu** that selection committee, they’ve got no ******* idea at all. Full of belief, but not a single idea.

I know we love to pretend our opposition doesn't exist, but how does our back line match up against their forward line?

HF

• Michael Gibbons,
• Levi Casboult,
• Josh Deluca

F

• Zac Fisher,
• Harry McKay,
• Jack Silvagni

Talia to McKay?
Hartigan to Casboult?


Otten to....?

 

[CrowinNT]

Otten isn’t up to this
Look at our youngsters In SANFL give them a go
Fuming

 

[Mike Smyth]

******* Andy Otten, we’ve still got 2 fully sized KPDs plus Kelly. Wouldn’t this be an opportunity to go into a game with just the 2 KPDs and see if we can generate a bit more run out of our backline? fu** that selection committee, they’ve got no ******* idea at all. Full of belief, but not a single idea.

I hate to say it but is PYKE becoming the least flexible coach we have had. He's got a system and by damn he's sticking to it. Even Craig was willing to experiment - Massie on Franklin.

 

[OzSparrow]

I hate to say it but is PYKE becoming the least flexible coach we have had. He's got a system and by damn he's sticking to it. Even Craig was willing to experiment - Massie on Franklin.

Don't make me laugh!

 

[FullyBigKPro]

WOW.

Just WOW.

Otten

 

[Redleg Crow]

Seriously, I hate to say it, but for the good of their careers I feel like most of our draftees from the past 3 years should be on the phone to their agents to seek a way out of here.

 

[SloaneysDanger]

.................... why is David Mackay still playing AFL?

 

[thebeedee]

Let’s hope Tex is a late out, replaced by Fog.

 

[TRP1996]

FULL TEAM LINEUP FROM AFL.COM.AU IS AS FOLLOWS

ADELAIDE CROWS

B

Luke Brown | Daniel Talia | Kyle Hartigan

HB

Brodie Smith | Jake Kelly | Rory Laird

C

Riley Knight | Rory Sloane | Wayne Milera

HF

Brad Crouch | Taylor Walker | Tom Lynch

F

Lachlan Murphy | Josh Jenkins | Tyson Stengle

FOLLOWERS

• Reilly O'Brien,
• Matt Crouch,
• Patrick Wilson

INTERCHANGE

• Paul Seedsman,
• David Mackay,
• Rory Atkins,
• Andy Otten

EMERGENCY

• Sam Jacobs,
• Richard Douglas,
• Darcy Fogarty,
• Alex Keath

IN

• Tyson Stengle,
• Patrick Wilson,
• Andy Otten

OUT

• Hugh Greenwood (Omitted),
• Eddie Betts (Omitted),
• Alex Keath (Managed)

Haha. I'll believe Wilson being on-ball when I see it.

 

[Concussion test]

great news for Paddy Wilson - absolutely deserves his chance being a standout all year for the SANFL team. But FFS crows, don't shunt him to a half forward flank!!

Stengle should add a bit of nip and Otten?? - they must have a specific player in mind they want him to mark

Yes I think we're a little worried about Lance Whitnall getting off the chain!

 

[CrowinNT]

Surely Eddie is being rested. Eddie is massively better than Stengle. I hope I am wrong about Stengle but he does not look AFL material.

He will be fine

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Kreuzer is out..you would think ROB is going to have a field day

Important our mids have 1st use, given they don't chase!

 

[Cap]

Apparently Greenwood wants 3 years, we're offering 2. Keath, we are under salary cap pressure and can't offer anywhere near what the Bulldogs are offering. But.. but.. the war chest?!

I wouldn't give Greenwood 3.

Interesting it's the Bulldogs, plenty of cash from players leaving.

 

[hey shorty]

Don’t be stupid. But I did give you warning. 2 KPDs plus Kelly is enough, we did not need to bring in Otten. But we do revert to experience when the chips are down and we lost Eddie, so he had to be replaced with equivalent experience level.

I do agree.with the KPDs, however the defence is the least of our issues. So you change like for like.

The rest we could've made 10 changes.

 

[Cap]

Mate. Im sure it isn't a big deal for you.

It shouldn't be for any rationale football fan.

 

[thebirdman 24]

I know we love to pretend our opposition doesn't exist, but how does our back line match up against their forward line?

HF

• Michael Gibbons,
• Levi Casboult,
• Josh Deluca

F

• Zac Fisher,
• Harry McKay,
• Jack Silvagni

Talia to McKay?
Hartigan to Casboult?


Otten to....?

our structure has 3 talls and a mid tall in kelly. there is no deviating from this.

 

[SugarShane]

Kreuzer out for us is a big win for you. Phillips is a statue and averages about 5 disposals.

Can see us having to shark your ruckman's taps. Cripps and Curnow will have their work cut out.

Alternatively you could just let us win the clearance, bomb it inside 50, turn it over, then walk it back through the corridor unchallenged.

 

[Firewalker]

Andy Otten back on the MCG. Just glorious.

I suppose no matter how Otten plays it will still be better than his last outing on the MCG...

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Starting to get angry about Fog's lack of game time now

Sent from my SM-N950F using Tapatalk

So we manage Keath who is still playing OK, but won't manage a clearly injured Tex with Fog.

I'm hoping for a late change.